Re: Result of Proof Of Concept for Redis Event bus user notifications

2024-03-01 Thread Benoit TELLIER
Hello Jean On 01/03/2024 14:01, Jean Helou wrote: Hello Benoit This is very clear thanks. I was not implying you should use pulsar :) I use a sass deployment and I am aware it is quite complex to operate:) I might well end up deciding that a pulsar+redis makes more sense than pulsar only when

Re: Result of Proof Of Concept for Redis Event bus user notifications

2024-03-01 Thread Jean Helou
Hello Benoit This is very clear thanks. I was not implying you should use pulsar :) I use a sass deployment and I am aware it is quite complex to operate:) I might well end up deciding that a pulsar+redis makes more sense than pulsar only when I start trying to deploy the MDA side of James:) -

Re: Result of Proof Of Concept for Redis Event bus user notifications

2024-03-01 Thread Benoit TELLIER
Hello Jean! First, the decision is made at Linagora. I hope that we can come up with enough feedback to convince people in the Apache community. Why Redis?  - RabbitMQ is a bad match for pub sub, I won't repeat the litany of issues encountered with it...  - We are using Redis in our tech

Re: Result of Proof Of Concept for Redis Event bus user notifications

2024-03-01 Thread Jean Helou
Hello  I'm not (yet) familiar with the event bus :) Out of curiosity could you describe what made you chose redis and what other systems you considered ? What characteristics you thought would match well with the problem. I'm interested in part because there is a Jira to implement the event

Re: Result of Proof Of Concept for Redis Event bus user notifications

2024-02-29 Thread Maksim Meliashchuk
Hello! I'm interested in this topic. I prefer to consider the subtleties that experts talk about. If there is an opinion that it is not desirable to expand the use of Redis, then https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/JAMES-3956 can be closed. But if anyone can provide assistance in defining the

Re: Result of Proof Of Concept for Redis Event bus user notifications

2024-02-28 Thread Benoit TELLIER
Hello Quan, Thanks a lot for this work. It is very encouraging. Having the whole eventbus based on Redis is IMO however not a good idea. For notifications / registration being best effort will be OK however RabbitMQ quorum queues address reliability issues. Going fully away of RabbitMQ for