Re: [sidr] FW: I-D Action: draft-manderson-sidr-geo-01.txt

2011-07-19 Thread Terry Manderson
Hi John, Thanks for taking the time to review the draft and post your thoughts. On 20/07/11 7:00 AM, John Kristoff j...@cymru.com wrote: 1) Use cases? who wants this. I'll assume that you're looking for more use cases beyond those you had envisioned when deciding to write it up.

[sidr] FW: I-D Action: draft-manderson-sidr-geo-01.txt

2011-06-09 Thread Terry Manderson
This document reflects the feedback from Prague both in the WG and around the halls, being: 1) Use cases? who wants this. 2) Privacy, bad idea to geotag ghostbusters, put in coordinates for just what you need. 3) Currency and 'legal', RPKI repository operator doesn't want to be responsible for