[Sip-implementors] XML Body in the 200 OK SIP Response of SIP MESSAGE

2019-04-15 Thread abhishek jain
Hi, Can a Sip Response (to a Non-Dialog creating SIP Request) contain a body ? I would appreciate a quick response. For example - *Server to **Client **:* MESSAGE : Content-Type: application/chat-info+xml Content-Length: ... : *Client to Server:* SIP/2.0 200 OK :

Re: [Sip-implementors] XML Body in the 200 OK SIP Response of SIP MESSAGE

2019-04-14 Thread abhishek jain
I understand your point in the broadband environment, but actually, we have very strict requirements of KPIs and limited bandwidth usage in the radio environment in certain conditions that we would like to save every single byte where possible. I again appreciate your great help and time you gave

Re: [Sip-implementors] XML Body in the 200 OK SIP Response of SIP MESSAGE

2019-04-14 Thread Paul Kyzivat
On 4/13/19 9:31 PM, abhishek jain wrote: Thanks Paul for your great suggestions. Since, I don't want to add traffic to network, so I don't want to use a separate set of SIP MESSAGE request/response. I doubt that this would have any appreciable affect on your network traffic unless you are

Re: [Sip-implementors] XML Body in the 200 OK SIP Response of SIP MESSAGE

2019-04-13 Thread abhishek jain
Thanks Paul for your great suggestions. Since, I don't want to add traffic to network, so I don't want to use a separate set of SIP MESSAGE request/response. Based on our requirements, I find your suggestion of Content-ID header field option being really suitable. I am putting the request/response

Re: [Sip-implementors] XML Body in the 200 OK SIP Response of SIP MESSAGE

2019-04-13 Thread Paul Kyzivat
On 4/13/19 4:43 PM, abhishek jain wrote: Thanks Paul for your quick response on a Saturday. I really appreciate. I am wondering how to implement below without introducing another pair of SIP request/response, if you could suggest that would be great with SIP compliance - 1. My server sending

Re: [Sip-implementors] XML Body in the 200 OK SIP Response of SIP MESSAGE

2019-04-13 Thread abhishek jain
Thanks Paul for your quick response on a Saturday. I really appreciate. I am wondering how to implement below without introducing another pair of SIP request/response, if you could suggest that would be great with SIP compliance - 1. My server sending some configurations to client using SIP

Re: [Sip-implementors] XML Body in the 200 OK SIP Response of SIP MESSAGE

2019-04-13 Thread Paul Kyzivat
On 4/13/19 3:58 PM, abhishek jain wrote: Hi, Can a Sip Response (to a Non-Dialog creating SIP Request) contain a body ? I would appreciate a quick response. Sometimes. The rules vary depending on the type of message. But not for MESSAGE. RFC3480 (section 7) says: A 2xx response to a

[Sip-implementors] XML Body in the 200 OK SIP Response of SIP MESSAGE

2019-04-13 Thread abhishek jain
> > Hi, > Can a Sip Response (to a Non-Dialog creating SIP Request) contain a body ? > I would appreciate a quick response. > > For example - > *Server to **Client **:* > MESSAGE > : > > Content-Type: application/chat-info+xml > > Content-Length: ... > > > > > : > > > > > *Client to