Re: SPDX-License-Identifier for composite-licensed source files

2019-12-17 Thread Matija ?uklje
Hi Richard, I think both your possibilities work, and with the current state of art, I would agree with Kate, Jilayne and Gary. On the other hand it seems to me that exactly how to mark source code is perhaps a bit out of the scope of SPDX (I might be wrong though). A project that is based

Re: How to best handle modification notices and notices of origin in SPDX

2019-09-16 Thread Matija ?uklje
On petek, 06. september 2019 05:35:48 CEST, J Lovejoy wrote: I really wouldn’t conflate attribution and copyright notices - that seems to lead to a lot of unnecessarily confusion and other energy FWIW - this reminded me that there are some licenses that require a specific acknowledgment (I’m

How to best handle modification notices and notices of origin in SPDX

2019-07-24 Thread Matija ?uklje
Hi all, recently I’ve been thinking about how to store¹ additional notices that are required by some licenses on the SPDX license list. Specifically reference to the origin of the work, and notice of modification of original work. I’m sure people on this list are very well aware of the

Re: meeting minutes from today

2019-06-01 Thread Matija ?uklje
Die 1. 06. 19 et hora 00:58 Dave Marr scripsit: > +1 > > SPDX is only pragmatically useful to me if it generally reflects > the licenses I’m likely to encounter when vetting community > software. I agree. Although the question still remains what constitutes a popular license – does a non-FOSS

Re: Updated project ideas - new login workflow

2019-01-21 Thread Matija ?uklje
Die 18. 01. 19 et hora 18:30 Gary O'Neall scripsit: > Let me know if you see any issues with the proposal. We can > always tune up the project idea over the next couple of weeks. I can see no issues (at least after only my first coffee) and it looks really cool to me :) cheers, Matija --

Re: New License/Exception Request: The Star And Thank Author License

2018-10-25 Thread Matija ?uklje
On petek, 19. oktober 2018 08:08:09 CEST qiwihui wrote: > Short Identifier: SATA In any case, should we decide to adopt this license, I would suggest we use a different short ID, as it could cause confusion with the widely known SATA/Serial ATA: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Serial_ATA

Re: New License/Exception Request: The Star And Thank Author License

2018-10-25 Thread Matija ?uklje
On petek, 19. oktober 2018 08:08:09 CEST qiwihui wrote: > The basic idea is, whenever using a project using SATA license, > people shall star/like/+1 that project and thank the author. …this brings up so many questions in me. Would I really not be allowed to use the software, if I don’t +1 it?

Re: Proposal for a generic new exception for OpenSSL

2018-10-05 Thread Matija ?uklje
First of all, I apologise for the long delay. I got distracted by illness, work etc. I see this discussion has progressed a bit since then. I’ll try to weave the new parts of the thread into my old draft. Dne četrtek, 09. avgust 2018 ob 15:43:15 CEST je James Bottomley napisal(a): > Sure ...

Re: Proposal for a generic new exception for OpenSSL

2018-08-10 Thread Matija ?uklje
Dne četrtek, 09. avgust 2018 ob 02:46:21 CEST je James Bottomley napisal(a): > Most of the alternative formulations go for wordier versions, but I > think brevity is better. I have pondered on this for longer than I thought I would, but don’t have a proposal I would be happy with yet. Would

Re: Proposal for a generic new exception for OpenSSL

2018-08-09 Thread Matija ?uklje
Hi James, if there is interest, I volunteer to help with this one. cheers, Matija -- gsm:+386 41 849 552 www:http://matija.suklje.name xmpp: matija.suk...@gabbler.org sip:matija_suk...@ippi.fr -=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=- Links: You receive all messages sent to this group.

Re: Change use of SPDX *-Identifier tags in REUSE.software and Linux kernel best practices?

2018-08-02 Thread Matija ?uklje
Dne četrtek, 02. avgust 2018 ob 15:25:51 CEST je Kate Stewart napisal(a): > I think if we socialize it with the kernel community in advance, and > then send a pull request to change the locations in the kernel and > reference the change to the REUSE.software to implement this, we > shouldn't

Change use of SPDX *-Identifier tags in REUSE.software and Linux kernel best practices?

2018-08-01 Thread Matija ?uklje
Hi all, I’m currently battling figuring out how to integrate SPDX through REUSE.software and am at a stage of severe head-scratching¹. I am CC’ing Jonas (FSFE, REUSE), in case he is not actively following this list. While I am referring to REUSE.software² here, the situation is near identical