Re: [spring] [Detnet] 答复: IETF-111 SPRING presentation on sr-redundancy-protection

2021-07-26 Thread Gyan Mishra
Hi Greg Redundancy Protection positioned for both SRv6 and SR-MPLS and can address all use P2P cases extending SR functionality. That is the new goal of the draft. At this time DETNET is out of scope and we will update the draft to reflect. >From a DETNET perspective my thoughts are that excl

Re: [spring] [Detnet] 答复: IETF-111 SPRING presentation on sr-redundancy-protection

2021-07-26 Thread gregory.mirsky
Hi Fan, thank you for the detailed explanation of the author's view of the scope of the draft. As the proposed mechanism is being positioned as a generic for SRv6, it seems logical that it addresses all the use cases. That, in my opinion, would include p2p and p2mp SR policies and DetNet in SR

Re: [spring] [Detnet] 答复: IETF-111 SPRING presentation on sr-redundancy-protection

2021-07-26 Thread Pascal Thubert (pthubert)
Hello Fan, It would be neat that the proposal can be used for DetNet and RAW. I trust that we can find a way to alleviate the issues that Bala’zs has raised and maintain the capabilities that you are after. Regards, Pascal Le 26 juil. 2021 à 23:09, Yangfan (IP Standard) a écrit :  Hi Bal