Re: Imported steam - can the US compete?

2004-06-13 Thread Sam Evans
I suspect that the reason litigation was far from the TE owner's mind was that the machine was probably legally insured without inspection as per your comment' so from that point of view he was covered. I wonder how many garden railway steamologists have 3rd party insurance? Apart from the

Re: Imported steam - can the US compete?

2004-06-13 Thread Sam Evans
Clue, loco was built in 1954 as part of a gift to Sierra Leone (former colony)from the UK, on getting its independence. The basic design IIRC dates to the 1890's?. N#ow that would age me!! Best Sam E Geoff Spenceley wrote: Sam, The prototype two years younger than you? doesn't that make

Re: Imported steam - can the US compete?

2004-06-13 Thread Daniel McGrath
Bede and all, As far as I can determine the lack of "live steam in the garden" or garden railroading at all is that most poeple are not aware of either Neither run "out of the box".Both take a fair amount of effort and dare I say "commitment" to a long term project. Along with these aspects,

Re: Imported steam - can the US compete?

2004-06-13 Thread Pthornto
In a message dated 6/13/2004 3:09:24 AM Eastern Daylight Time, [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: my point is that the dearth of live steam in garden/back yard railroadways in the US is probably due to something other than fears of litigation- perhaps LGB as Sam mentions, and other gauge 1

Re: Imported steam - can the US compete?

2004-06-13 Thread Geoff Spenceley
Well, well Young Sam, I'm 32 yrs older than the Hunslet--hell, I'm closer to the 1890 design! Wheezing Groan Geoff, It'sClue, loco was built in 1954 as part of a gift to Sierra Leone (former colony)from the UK, on getting its independence. The basic design IIRC dates to the 1890's?. N#ow

Re: Imported steam - can the US compete?

2004-06-13 Thread Keith Taylor
- Original Message - From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: Multiple recipients of sslivesteam [EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Sunday, June 13, 2004 12:13 PM Subject: Re: Imported steam - can the US compete? My observation, from the perspective of switching to a garden railroad in the '90s

Re: Imported steam - can the US compete?

2004-06-13 Thread Sam Evans
, 2004 12:13 PM Subject: Re: Imported steam - can the US compete? My observation, from the perspective of switching to a garden railroad in the '90s, is that the US didn't have the 2' prototypes and therefore the SM32 concept was a non-starter. So the simple Roundhouse-type live steamers

Re: Imported steam - can the US compete?

2004-06-13 Thread Cgnr
In a message dated 6/13/2004 11:13:28 AM Pacific Daylight Time, [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: In a message dated 6/13/2004 3:09:24 AM Eastern Daylight Time, [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: my point is that the dearth of live steam in garden/back yard railroadways in the US is probably due to

Re: Imported steam - can the US compete?

2004-06-12 Thread Sam Evans
The only way to beat low-labor-cost manufacturers is to maximize automation and minimize labor costs so that shipping costs and delays from overseas negate the labor cost competitiveness of imports. Ahem, so how does any one afford to buy anything when they are either a) out of work b)

Re: Imported steam - can the US compete?

2004-06-12 Thread Tag Gorton
On 12/6/04 4:46 am, Daniel McGrath [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Is Aster actually Made in Japan? I cannont say, I've never seen one up close. As far as small production runs, seems that both Cheddar and Roundhouse are able to do it. There are a few more to be sure. Never say it's

Re: Imported steam - can the US compete?

2004-06-12 Thread Bede McCormack
From: Sam Evans [EMAIL PROTECTED] Reply-To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] I am surprised a little bit that no Roundhouse clone has sprung up in the US, you have a far greater potential market. In the UK we suspect that high product liability insurance in your highly litigious country may have put

Re: Imported steam - can the US compete?

2004-06-12 Thread Tag Gorton
On 12/6/04 8:46 am, Bede McCormack [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: From: Sam Evans [EMAIL PROTECTED] Reply-To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] I am surprised a little bit that no Roundhouse clone has sprung up in the US, you have a far greater potential market. In the UK we suspect that high product

Re: Imported steam - can the US compete?

2004-06-12 Thread Sam Evans
It probably has more to do with what re-sparked the interest in garden railways in both countries. In the UK it is commonly credited to Stuart Browne of Archangel Models who made affordable 16mm 'scale' live steamers that WORKED in a garden environment. He had his apostles who wrote in the

Re: Imported steam - can the US compete?

2004-06-12 Thread Sam Evans
Oh yes, and what is less gratifying about preparing and firing up a loco and 8 mins later having a REAL steam engine to use. If you are referring to the traction engine explosion at the State Fair; according to the official report (copy on web), that was down to the owner avoiding having his

Re: Imported steam - can the US compete?

2004-06-12 Thread Geoff Spenceley
Right Sam, It was Aster and then Tom Cooper's Merlins who helped me into live steam. Tom needs a great deal of credit as a pioneer. His Merlin Hunslet was a terrific performer despite some minor defects. I had one for 18 years, some repairs of course but how it steamed! Big boiler, big butane

Re: Imported steam - can the US compete?

2004-06-12 Thread Bede McCormack
PROTECTED] Date: Sat, 12 Jun 2004 15:40:49 +0100 To: Multiple recipients of sslivesteam [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: Re: Imported steam - can the US compete? Oh yes, and what is less gratifying about preparing and firing up a loco and 8 mins later having a REAL steam engine to use. If you

Re: Imported steam - can the US compete?

2004-06-12 Thread Harry Wade
At 05:05 PM 6/12/04 -0400, you wrote: Yes, I did have the traction engine explosion in mind- I guess I was making the tenuous assumption that if the late owner of the TE was unconcerned enough about litigation I would guess that the whole lot of them were unconcerned about anything

Re: Imported steam - can the US compete?

2004-06-12 Thread Sam Evans
My first loco was the Merlin Hunslet. I still have it and it still steams. As a member of the WLLR I always thought No 85b a rather elegant little engine when Tom did his model A small irony, the full-sized loco is actually two years younger than me! Best Sam E Geoff Spenceley wrote:

Re: Imported steam - can the US compete?

2004-06-12 Thread Geoff Spenceley
Sam, The prototype two years younger than you? doesn't that make you rather old?? Heck, it must be 50 yrs younger than me!! I sold my two Merlins to Tom Toth, gotta raise money for those expensive Asters as I prefer 1/32 scale. Expensive is right tho', we live in a shack in the woods, our autos

Re: Imported steam - can the US compete?

2004-06-11 Thread Jeffrey Williams
Wasn't ASTER a manufacturer of mechanical calculators who switched to live steam locos after electronic calculators took over their market? In the US, Marchant Calculators Inc. couldn't figure out what to do with their capability to manufacture lots of very small precision moving parts and

Re: Imported steam - can the US compete?

2004-06-11 Thread Daniel McGrath
somewhere. Food for thought, you just never know... From: Jeffrey Williams [EMAIL PROTECTED] Reply-To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: Multiple recipients of sslivesteam [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: Re: Imported steam - can the US compete? Date: Fri, 11 Jun 2004 20:15:32 -0700 Wasn't ASTER a ma