Re: [Standards] [STANDARDS] XEP-0394: too weak to replace XEP-0071

2018-03-31 Thread Stephen Paul Weber
Can we really replace XEP-0071 with something that is as "powerful" without triggering all the reasons that people wanted it deprecated in the first place? I would say if you want the power, keep using XEP-0071. It's implemented just about everywhere, and works very well, no matter what the

Re: [Standards] Proposed XMPP Extension: Bookmarks 2 (This Time it's Serious)

2018-03-31 Thread Stephen Paul Weber
The 'autojoin' flag name is a bit misleading in the time of always-on clients. Maybe we should change the text to indicate that a client is supposed to join and stay joined(!) if this flag is set, and maybe also to automatically leave when the flag is unset. I’d argue that clients should