Re: [Standards] XEP-0369: MIX - About create a room/channel

2018-04-23 Thread Ralph Meijer
On April 23, 2018 5:34:06 PM GMT+02:00, Steve Kille wrote: > > >> -Original Message- >> From: Manuel Rubio >> Sent: 23 April 2018 16:12 >> To: XMPP Standards >> Cc: Steve Kille >> Subject: Re: [Standards] XEP-0369: MIX - About create a room/channel >> >> Hi Steve, >> >> thanks for yo

Re: [Standards] Abolishing 'proposed' status for XEPs

2018-04-23 Thread Kevin Smith
I note that my suggestion in the MUC for this was that there were three outcomes from an LC, and Council will pick which. Draft, Rejected or Experimental, and Rejected really did mean rejected. /K > On 23 Apr 2018, at 19:11, Dave Cridland wrote: > > > > On 23 April 2018 at 17:59, Matthew Wi

Re: [Standards] Abolishing 'proposed' status for XEPs

2018-04-23 Thread Dave Cridland
On 23 April 2018 at 17:59, Matthew Wild wrote: > On 23 April 2018 at 16:46, Dave Cridland wrote: > > -1 to removing Proposed. We only know there's a problem because a bunch > of > > XEPs are sitting in Proposed; removing Proposed wouldn't remove the > problem, > > just the fact we can see it. I'

Re: [Standards] Abolishing 'proposed' status for XEPs

2018-04-23 Thread Matthew Wild
On 23 April 2018 at 16:46, Dave Cridland wrote: > -1 to removing Proposed. We only know there's a problem because a bunch of > XEPs are sitting in Proposed; removing Proposed wouldn't remove the problem, > just the fact we can see it. I'd really like a similar state during the CFE, > since that's

Re: [Standards] Abolishing 'proposed' status for XEPs

2018-04-23 Thread Dave Cridland
-1 to removing Proposed. We only know there's a problem because a bunch of XEPs are sitting in Proposed; removing Proposed wouldn't remove the problem, just the fact we can see it. I'd really like a similar state during the CFE, since that's quite hard to manage. My preferred change would be to up

Re: [Standards] XEP-0369: MIX - About create a room/channel

2018-04-23 Thread Steve Kille
> -Original Message- > From: Manuel Rubio > Sent: 23 April 2018 16:12 > To: XMPP Standards > Cc: Steve Kille > Subject: Re: [Standards] XEP-0369: MIX - About create a room/channel > > Hi Steve, > > thanks for your answers. About one I think was omitted, if I (hag66) create a > channe

Re: [Standards] XEP-0369: MIX - About create a room/channel

2018-04-23 Thread Manuel Rubio
Hi Steve, thanks for your answers. About one I think was omitted, if I (hag66) create a channel saying the owners are "hecate" and "greymalkin", am I an owner for that channel? Thanks. Manuel Rubio. El 2018-04-23 15:46, Steve Kille escribió: Manuel, -Original Message- From: Standa

Re: [Standards] Abolishing 'proposed' status for XEPs

2018-04-23 Thread Kevin Smith
On 23 Apr 2018, at 15:09, Matthew Wild wrote: > We have a number of XEPs stuck in 'proposed' with an expired Last Call. > > I think the reality is that the council "rejected" these, or last call > feedback is awaiting to be incorporated. By "rejected" I mean to imply > that the council didn't wan

Re: [Standards] Abolishing 'proposed' status for XEPs

2018-04-23 Thread Peter Saint-Andre
On 4/23/18 8:09 AM, Matthew Wild wrote: > We have a number of XEPs stuck in 'proposed' with an expired Last Call. > > I think the reality is that the council "rejected" these, or last call > feedback is awaiting to be incorporated. By "rejected" I mean to imply > that the council didn't want to ad

[Standards] Abolishing 'proposed' status for XEPs

2018-04-23 Thread Matthew Wild
We have a number of XEPs stuck in 'proposed' with an expired Last Call. I think the reality is that the council "rejected" these, or last call feedback is awaiting to be incorporated. By "rejected" I mean to imply that the council didn't want to advance the XEP yet (presumably based on LC feedback

Re: [Standards] XEP-0369: MIX - About create a room/channel

2018-04-23 Thread Steve Kille
Manuel, > -Original Message- > From: Standards On Behalf Of Manuel Rubio > Sent: 23 April 2018 09:30 > To: standards@xmpp.org > Subject: [Standards] XEP-0369: MIX - About create a room/channel > > Hello, > > I was reading today the create form for the room creation. I have several > dou

[Standards] XEP-0369: MIX - About create a room/channel

2018-04-23 Thread Manuel Rubio
Hello, I was reading today the create form for the room creation. I have several doubts about that. First one, is it possible to include as many owners as I want and they are supposed to be included in the channel or only are intended to be owners when they join to the channel?