Re: [sumo-user] waiting time and average speed

2022-01-31 Thread Jakob Erdmann
The default 'accel' parameter is the same for all models (and this is reflected in the documentation). However, the driving dynamics still differ between the models: - Krauss makes full use of it's default accel and decel values in almost all traffic situations - ACC/CACC sometimes accelerate with

Re: [sumo-user] waiting time and average speed

2022-01-31 Thread Royal Bhandari
Thanks, Jakob for the explanation. To check my understanding, the default acceleration of the Krauss model is higher than that of ACC and CACC? Is there documentation listing this? Regards, Royal On Mon, Jan 31, 2022 at 4:46 AM Jakob Erdmann wrote: > The outputs are probably "valid" for the

[sumo-user] Using TAZ as junction departed flow

2022-01-31 Thread Rob Maris
Junction flow is new to 1.12, and upon trying this, it was reported that a TAZ would be needed. Well first time examining TAZ. This seems very suitable for my needs, but still I'm stuck. The screenshot shows that the TAZ has edges associated with it, as expected. Ideal to let a flow run from on

[sumo-user] Scenario with demand loaded from vehroute-output behaves different from the original run

2022-01-31 Thread Khaled Belhassine
Hello, I am trying to re-create a scenario which uses oneshot assignment. I export the final routes by using --vehroute-output option and provide that as an input to my simulation again I get a totally different traffic situation a lot of teleports. As Recommanded here https://github.com/ecli

Re: [sumo-user] Building Walking Areas from Polygons

2022-01-31 Thread Jakob Erdmann
Polyconvert can work without without a net-xml file and generates geo-coded shapes which can be put into any geo-referenced network. One approach might be to use those imported polygons to generate additional netconvert input that sets the walkingarea shapes: https://sumo.dlr.de/docs/Networks/Plai

Re: [sumo-user] Calibrating OD with edge count data

2022-01-31 Thread Jakob Erdmann
Thanks four comment! Having more open source code to chose from would be good. I do think that your problem of OD estimation is a bit different from that one that the outlined routeSampler approach solves. The above approach takes the OD-matrix as ground truth (either es edge-to-edge or zone-to-z

Re: [sumo-user] Building Walking Areas from Polygons

2022-01-31 Thread Sasan Amini
It is exactly that case, closed polygons are defined as waling areas. I tried polyconvert but it did just generate an empty xml file. I am not sure if a sumo network is required as an input to make it work... On Thu, Jan 27, 2022 at 7:27 AM Jakob Erdmann wrote: > It might be because the walking

Re: [sumo-user] Calibrating OD with edge count data

2022-01-31 Thread Mahajan, Vishal
Dear Jakob and Joel, I am working on a similar problem so wanted to jump into this discussion. But I am using a different optimizer than the routesampler.py. This problem pertains to the class of problems popularly known as (Indirect) OD demand estimation. So basically I am using another opti

[sumo-user] marouter: weight-adaption, weight-expand, (and weights-interpolate)

2022-01-31 Thread Lukas
Hi all, I have some trouble understanding the notion of the weight-adaption and weight-expand. I have a scenario where the aggregation period is 3600 and the weight-period is 900s. Demand is in one scenario, an OD matrix for 3600s and in the other one, two OD matrices for each 3600s (similar to ht

Re: [sumo-user] waiting time and average speed

2022-01-31 Thread Jakob Erdmann
The outputs are probably "valid" for the particular models but whether the ACC/ CACC models conform to the behavior of any particular real life fleet cannot be answered without prior calibration. Please also refer to my previous answer (https://www.eclipse.org/lists/sumo-user/msg11040.html). Obviou

Re: [sumo-user] capacity analysis

2022-01-31 Thread Jakob Erdmann
Please be aware that 'ACC' and 'CACC' are just one possible implementation of (cooperative) automated cruise control. They are not the "definite" models for these things. If the models behave differently from your expectations, this may reflect the very specific situations they were calibrated for