Re: [Biofuel] Amateurs are trying genetic engineering at home

2009-01-03 Thread Keith Addison
http://journeytoforever.org/fyi_previous4.html#1511 2001/11/15 Technology and the poor Technology, Poverty and the Future of the Developing World -- from Human Development Report 2001 - ITDG response, Intermediate Technology Development Group (now Practical Action), see Practical Action

Re: [Biofuel] Amateurs are trying genetic engineering at home

2009-01-02 Thread Keith Addison
http://www.precaution.org/lib/09/prn_biohackers_unstitch_life.081227.htm From: The Times (London, U.K.) December 27, 2008 Biohackers attempt to unstitch the fabric of life [Rachel's introduction: As we enter the new year, an astonishing new social phenomenon has emerged: amateur genetic

Re: [Biofuel] Amateurs are trying genetic engineering at home

2009-01-02 Thread Keith Addison
Hi Chip Keith Addison wrote: Hi Peter Hi Keith ; I have made the point previously many times on-list that genetic engineering is not the answer to anything and in fact it will kill millions of people. This is one way. Could be. I don't altogether agree with you though, I don't

Re: [Biofuel] Amateurs are trying genetic engineering at home

2009-01-02 Thread Keith Addison
Hi Peter snip Many thanks to moderator Keith, we are WAY off the thread. You're welcome. :-) Definitely off-thread yes, not just the topic itself, but also the a-priori mode of reasoning, which may be a valid basis for discussion of Christian theology but not for an assessment of technology,

Re: [Biofuel] Amateurs are trying genetic engineering at home

2008-12-31 Thread Guag Meister
Hi David and All ; The reason I said it's a very difficult problem is because it's a very difficult problem. My feeling is that the problem is made difficult to understand by the current teachers of all persuasions who never clearly explain it. Perhaps they themselves lack understanding.

Re: [Biofuel] Amateurs are trying genetic engineering at home

2008-12-31 Thread Keith Addison
http://diybio.org/blog/ DIYbio DIYbio is an organization that aims to help make biology a worthwhile pursuit for citizen scientists, amateur biologists, and DIY biological engineers who value openness and safety. This will require mechanisms for amateurs to increase their knowledge and skills,

Re: [Biofuel] Amateurs are trying genetic engineering at home

2008-12-31 Thread Chip Mefford
Keith Addison wrote: Hi Peter Hi Keith ; I have made the point previously many times on-list that genetic engineering is not the answer to anything and in fact it will kill millions of people. This is one way. Could be. I don't altogether agree with you though, I don't think

Re: [Biofuel] Amateurs are trying genetic engineering at home

2008-12-31 Thread David House
Peter, Guag Meister wrote: [N]o offense at all intended David, but you seem to be asking a question and not really expecting an answer. There is an answer. Find it. [...] Some of the answers you seek are here, and in my previous email. I appreciate the spirit of generosity which has

Re: [Biofuel] Amateurs are trying genetic engineering at home

2008-12-30 Thread Guag Meister
Hi David and All ; Wow, I am impressed. I feel I have some answers for you, I will offer them up if I may, the other folks on the list may not be ready to listen and understand. So here's the problem: If He had the powers you appear to believe He had (and that I believe He had), then why

Re: [Biofuel] Amateurs are trying genetic engineering at home

2008-12-30 Thread David House
Dear Peter, Guag Meister wrote: It seems to me [...] that there is no courage unless there is danger, no faith without a context of doubt [...] (Although quite frankly this is only part of the answer-- the outside surface of a great mystery-- since while these things are true, they don't

Re: [Biofuel] Amateurs are trying genetic engineering at home

2008-12-29 Thread Keith Addison
[EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: Re: [Biofuel] Amateurs are trying genetic engineering at home To: sustainablelorgbiofuel@sustainablelists.org Date: Sunday, December 28, 2008, 2:53 AM Hi All ; In other words, it seems to me that anyone who really believes this should argue vociferously

Re: [Biofuel] Amateurs are trying genetic engineering at home

2008-12-29 Thread Keith Addison
Hi Peter Hi Keith and All ; Not much time to elaborate on this subject, and I am ok with your views and mine. Could this be the reason that almost all religious leaders (and by that I mean Jesus, Mohammad, Bhuddha, etc) shun technology. Do they? Jesus was a carpenter, what did he

Re: [Biofuel] Amateurs are trying genetic engineering at home

2008-12-28 Thread Guag Meister
Hi All ; In other words, it seems to me that anyone who really believes this should argue vociferously against the infection of democracy. Yes and of course. My contention all along is that Democracy is not a stable system. Witness our own experiment with it. With a huge and resource

Re: [Biofuel] Amateurs are trying genetic engineering at home

2008-12-28 Thread Guag Meister
Hi Keith and All ; Not much time to elaborate on this subject, and I am ok with your views and mine. Could this be the reason that almost all religious leaders (and by that I mean Jesus, Mohammad, Bhuddha, etc) shun technology. Do they? Jesus was a carpenter, what did he use to cut

Re: [Biofuel] Amateurs are trying genetic engineering at home

2008-12-28 Thread Guag Meister
Hi Keith ; I didn't see this post... BR Peter G. --- On Sun, 12/28/08, Guag Meister [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: From: Guag Meister [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: Re: [Biofuel] Amateurs are trying genetic engineering at home To: sustainablelorgbiofuel@sustainablelists.org Date: Sunday, December

Re: [Biofuel] Amateurs are trying genetic engineering at home

2008-12-28 Thread David House
Peter, Guag Meister wrote: Could this be the reason that almost all religious leaders... shun technology[?] Do they? Jesus was a carpenter, what did he use to cut wood [...] If Jesus was who He said He was, then why couldn't He have invented electricity? [...]Or ANY other

Re: [Biofuel] Amateurs are trying genetic engineering at home

2008-12-26 Thread Keith Addison
Hi Peter Hi Keith ; I have made the point previously many times on-list that genetic engineering is not the answer to anything and in fact it will kill millions of people. This is one way. Could be. I don't altogether agree with you though, I don't think genetic engineering should be

Re: [Biofuel] Amateurs are trying genetic engineering at home

2008-12-26 Thread David House
Peter, Good to hear from you again... Guag Meister wrote: [...] So many times with technology we find that the last condition is worse than the first. Extrapolating this out to its logical conclusion, we find that all technology advances are bad. Could this be the reason that almost

Re: [Biofuel] Amateurs are trying genetic engineering at home

2008-12-26 Thread dwoodard
The more powerful technology becomes, the less we can tolerate its misuse by a few. The possibility of its misuse by a few can never be excluded, especially in a complex society with an atomised society, and much alienation and anomie. In such a society, powerful technology requires large and

Re: [Biofuel] Amateurs are trying genetic engineering at home

2008-12-26 Thread Chris Burck
well, this is an interesting discussion! on the one hand, i agree with keith that it's less about technology 'yes' vs. technology 'no' than about who is making that decision. yet for this very reason, i also agree with peter and doug, because once you get a high enough degree of centralization

Re: [Biofuel] Amateurs are trying genetic engineering at home

2008-12-26 Thread David House
Doug, [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: The more powerful technology becomes, the less we can tolerate its misuse by a few. The possibility of its misuse by a few can never be excluded, especially in a complex society with an atomised society, and much alienation and anomie. In such a society,

Re: [Biofuel] Amateurs are trying genetic engineering at home

2008-12-26 Thread David House
Chris, Chris Burck wrote: [...] i also agree with peter and doug, because once you get a high enough degree of centralization (in a society), the technologies that are pursued become ever more rarified and removed from the human level. With respect, I disagree. The clear and most

[Biofuel] Amateurs are trying genetic engineering at home

2008-12-25 Thread Guag Meister
Hi Keith ; I have made the point previously many times on-list that genetic engineering is not the answer to anything and in fact it will kill millions of people. This is one way. So many times with technology we find that the last condition is worse than the first. Extrapolating this out