Re: [Syslog] #3 NUL octets, #4 binary data, #8 octet-counting

2005-11-30 Thread Darren Reed
Hi WG, I have received notes via private mail telling me there seem to be some existing (and eventually soon upcoming) valid use cases for binary data in syslog. I think there is no point in arguing whether that's fortunate or not. It simply looks like that's the way it is. I do not like

RE: [Syslog] #3 NUL octets, #4 binary data, #8 octet-counting

2005-11-30 Thread Rainer Gerhards
Darren, I have received notes via private mail telling me there seem to be some existing (and eventually soon upcoming) valid use cases for binary data in syslog. I think there is no point in arguing whether that's fortunate or not. It simply looks like that's the way it is. I do

RE: [Syslog] #3 NUL octets, #4 binary data, #8 octet-counting

2005-11-30 Thread Chris Lonvick
Hi, Let's keep in mind that syslog-sign will transport binary signatures. In that, the authors are proposing to use base-64 encoding. I agree with Rainer that we've provided enough means in syslog-protocol so that may be accomplished. As Rainer says, let's focus on getting syslog-protocol

RE: [Syslog] #3 NUL octets, #4 binary data, #8 octet-counting

2005-11-30 Thread Anton Okmianski \(aokmians\)
Specifying the encoding makes sense to me. This way we can state that only certain encoding support is required, but not preclude other options. We are still ok with always having UTF-8 in SD values, right? We need this for foreign usernames. We have discussed this before. Thanks, Anton.

RE: [Syslog] #3 NUL octets, #4 binary data, #8 octet-counting

2005-11-30 Thread Rainer Gerhards
Anton: Specifying the encoding makes sense to me. This way we can state that only certain encoding support is required, but not preclude other options. We are still ok with always having UTF-8 in SD values, right? Yes, I was talking exclusively about MSG. I expect SD values to be

RE: [Syslog] #3 NUL octets, #4 binary data, #8 octet-counting

2005-11-30 Thread Andrew Ross
We are still ok with always having UTF-8 in SD values, right? We need this for foreign usernames. We have discussed this before. Yes, this would work for me. We need to ensure that the SD-IDs are always going to be encoded in a known format. UTF-8 is a good choice. Cheers Andrew

RE: [Syslog] #3 NUL octets, #4 binary data, #8 octet-counting

2005-11-30 Thread Andrew Ross
, November 30, 2005 7:19 AM To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: RE: [Syslog] #3 NUL octets, #4 binary data, #8 octet-counting Rainer, That sounds good to me at this stage, and it keeps the door open. I would prefer to see all binary data encoded in some safe format like base64. It just makes