RE: Re: t-and-f: Short/Long course cross country

2001-02-20 Thread malmo
There is more to cross country than a long race on bumpy ground! John UHH . . . NO THERE ISN'T!!! THAT'S WHAT CROSS COUNTRY IS BY DEFINITION, LONG RACES OVER CHALLENGING TERRAIN!! I USUALLY DON'T MAKE STATEMENTS LIKE THIS BUT . . . YOU ARE FLAT WRONG! PERIOD! Dan World Cross Country is

t-and-f: Short/Long course cross country

2001-02-20 Thread Mcewen, Brian T
Dan, I don't want to add more fuel to the fire ... what you are saying is for the most part true, and this whole discussion is really a matter of perspective and opinion. But, even the most elite milers run a lot of aerobic endurance type workouts. In the "off-season" (when he ought to be

RE: Re: t-and-f: Short/Long course cross country

2001-02-20 Thread alan tobin
To: [EMAIL PROTECTED]@[EMAIL PROTECTED] CC: [EMAIL PROTECTED]@darkwing.uoregon.edu Subject: RE: Re: t-and-f: Short/Long course cross country Date: Tue, 20 Feb 2001 06:49:27 -0800 There is more to cross country than a long race on bumpy ground! John UHH . . . NO THERE ISN'T!!! THAT'S WHAT

RE: Re: t-and-f: Short/Long course cross country

2001-02-20 Thread Subfour359
why not run worlds at SUNY Cortland? i hear they have a strem running through the course that the runners have to go through!

Re: Re: t-and-f: Short/Long course cross country

2001-02-20 Thread Ed Prytherch
My experience with HS kids is that everyone wants fast times, so flat, short courses are preferred. I directed the state championship meet for South Carolina independent schools this season. The course was a full 5k, it was hilly and the surface was uneven and had some loose sand. The main

RE: t-and-f: Short/Long course cross country

2001-02-19 Thread Mcewen, Brian T
e 12k race. -Original Message- From: R.T. [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]] Sent: Saturday, February 17, 2001 11:09 AM To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: Re: t-and-f: Short/Long course cross country Except that the world of specialization has grown in the last couple of decades. At the

RE: t-and-f: Short/Long course cross country

2001-02-19 Thread Dan Kaplan
--- "Mcewen, Brian T" [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Over history, there have been many, many steeplers who ran high level 12k races in the winter. [snip] but the steeplers and 5k runners should be in the 12k race. Have you looked over this weekend's results and the disproportionate number of

RE: t-and-f: Short/Long course cross country

2001-02-19 Thread Mcewen, Brian T
D] Subject: RE: t-and-f: Short/Long course cross country --- "Mcewen, Brian T" [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Over history, there have been many, many steeplers who ran high level 12k races in the winter. [snip] but the steeplers and 5k runners should be in the 12k race. Hav

RE: t-and-f: Short/Long course cross country

2001-02-19 Thread Dan Kaplan
--- "Mcewen, Brian T" [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Which is tougher (or a bigger "adjustment to training" as was posted); a 1500/5000m runner or Steepler adjusting "up" to the 12k distance ... OR A MARATHONER adjusting "down" ? I think moving up is tougher for most people, especially when it's

Re: t-and-f: Short/Long course cross country

2001-02-19 Thread Mpplatt
In a message dated 2/19/01 1:51:27 PM Eastern Standard Time, [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: think moving up is tougher for most people, especially when it's 4-8x the distance. Moving down significantly in distance may make the speed seem harsh, but at least you can run the whole thing at a

RE: t-and-f: Short/Long course cross country

2001-02-19 Thread GHTFNedit
In a message dated Mon, 19 Feb 2001 1:06:57 PM Eastern Standard Time, "Mcewen, Brian T" [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: The idea has always been to have a World Championship of XC ... and a race to suit all the XC runners ... where one best one could be crowned. I guess it is fair to say that (as

Re: t-and-f: Short/Long course cross country

2001-02-19 Thread Ed Dana Parrot
Dan wrote: I think moving up is tougher for most people, especially when it's 4-8x the distance. Moving down significantly in distance may make the speed seem harsh, but at least you can run the whole thing at a steady clip. Also, I would venture to guess that the training of many 12k and

Re: t-and-f: Short/Long course cross country

2001-02-17 Thread Runtenkm
Ditch the 4k. The appeal of the World XC Champs is the bringing together of the world's best distance runner's over one race. Everyone from 800m runners to marathoners battling it out. Who is the current men's world xc champ? It's Mohammed Mourhit not whoever won last year's 4k. Steve S.

Re: t-and-f: Short/Long course cross country

2001-02-17 Thread R.T.
Except that the world of specialization has grown in the last couple of decades. At the top level (not at collegiate where you do whatever your coach tells you, for team points), if all they have is a 12K race, everybody from Steeple specialists and shorter (middle distance) simply won't run.

Re: t-and-f: Short/Long course cross country

2001-02-17 Thread Steve DiNatale
That's the problem. Everybody thinks that they're so special. A true distance runner enters the real race (12K) because they want to see what they can do against the best runners in the world. Remember Steve Jones, he said he'll run any distance because he's just a runner, not a marathoner.

t-and-f: Short/Long course cross country

2001-02-16 Thread DLTFNedit
ABOLISH THE 4K CROSS COUNTRY!!! That is my request. The experiment has been a failure. I would guess that the IAAF's idea was to bring in the mile stars, such as Morceli and El Guerrouj, to the harrier season. It hasn't worked. I also suspect they were hoping it would break Kenya's

Re: t-and-f: Short/Long course cross country

2001-02-16 Thread lehane
I'm in full agreement. Cross country - one race, one champion. Beautiful simplicity. [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: ABOLISH THE 4K CROSS COUNTRY!!! That is my request. The experiment has been a failure. I would guess that the IAAF's idea was to bring in the mile stars, such as Morceli and El

RE: t-and-f: Short/Long course cross country

2001-02-16 Thread malmo
12k = varsity 4k = junior varsity ABOLISH THE 4K CROSS COUNTRY!!! That is my request. The experiment has been a failure. I would guess that the IAAF's idea was to bring in the mile stars, such as Morceli and El Guerrouj, to the harrier season. It hasn't worked. I also suspect they were hoping

Re: t-and-f: Short/Long course cross country

2001-02-16 Thread Ed Dana Parrot
ABOLISH THE 4K CROSS COUNTRY!!! That is my request. The experiment has been a failure. I would guess that the IAAF's idea was to bring in the mile stars, such as Morceli and El Guerrouj, to the harrier season. It hasn't worked. I also suspect they were hoping it would break Kenya's

Re: t-and-f: Short/Long course cross country

2001-02-16 Thread Steve DiNatale
I agree 100%. The World Cross Country Championships was always unique because you had marathoners to milers racing together, that was the idea. Having two races defeats the purpose. I still consider the 12K to be the Championship and the 4K the kids race. If you can't run with the big boys,

Re: t-and-f: Short/Long course cross country

2001-02-16 Thread John Lunn
Bob, COOL! While you are down sizing cross country, why not do the same to track. Only 1 weight event. Heck they all spin now, so as long as they spin and have a weight they must be the same. Let's not water down the events. Same with the horizontal jumps. If you can jump once,you can jump 3

Re: t-and-f: Short/Long course cross country

2001-02-16 Thread Buck Jones
Personally, I love the 4k. But I do understand your wish to see everybody duke it out in one race. Honestly, in the u.S. anyway, I think most of the athletes do the 12k if they want to be in the more competitive race - thus I don't see the dilution of competition you're concerned about. As to

Re: t-and-f: Short/Long course cross country

2001-02-16 Thread DHSTFCOACH
In a message dated 01-02-16 15:01:38 EST, [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: If they can't run the mile, they shouldn't be on the track. There is more to cross country than a long race on bumpy ground! John Actually there isn't much more to cross country than one long race on some bumpy ground,

Re: t-and-f: Short/Long course cross country

2001-02-16 Thread Ryan Grote
: Short/Long course cross country Bob, COOL! While you are down sizing cross country, why not do the same to track. Only 1 weight event. Heck they all spin now, so as long as they spin and have a weight they must be the same. Let's not water down the events. Same with the horizontal jumps

Re: t-and-f: Short/Long course cross country

2001-02-16 Thread Subfour359
In a message dated Fri, 16 Feb 2001 3:01:31 PM Eastern Standard Time, John Lunn [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: Bob,... There is more to cross country than a long race on bumpy ground! John UHH . . . NO THERE ISN'T!!! THAT'S WHAT CROSS COUNTRY IS BY DEFINITION, LONG RACES OVER CHALLENGING

Re: t-and-f: Short/Long course cross country

2001-02-16 Thread Ed Dana Parrot
There is more to cross country than a long race on bumpy ground! John UHH . . . NO THERE ISN'T!!! THAT'S WHAT CROSS COUNTRY IS BY DEFINITION, LONG RACES OVER CHALLENGING TERRAIN!! I USUALLY DON'T MAKE STATEMENTS LIKE THIS BUT . . . YOU ARE FLAT WRONG! PERIOD! Dan Actually no, a long