Re: [Tagging] Feature Proposal - RFC - protection_class=* (Words, not numeric codes)

2020-04-07 Thread Martin Koppenhoefer
sent from a phone > On 7. Apr 2020, at 11:41, Andrew Davidson wrote: > > boundary=national_park is an *existing* tag that is used to tag "a relatively > large area of land" that is "set aside for human recreation and enjoyment, as > well as the protection of the natural environment and/or cu

Re: [Tagging] Feature Proposal - RFC - protection_class=* (Words, not numeric codes)

2020-04-07 Thread Martin Koppenhoefer
sent from a phone > On 7. Apr 2020, at 09:28, Joseph Eisenberg wrote: > > But if Wikidata is already storing this info, maybe we don’t need a tag for > it? if the information is useful for us, or maybe even essential to understand the nature of the thing, then we should have the informatio

Re: [Tagging] building=public vs. building=civic

2020-04-07 Thread Martin Koppenhoefer
Although I also see a lot of overlap, I could imagine public buildings to be a bigger category of which civic buildings are only a part, according to your culture and context, one could imagine public buildings that aren’t civic buildings such as churches and temples. I could also imagine peop

Re: [Tagging] building=public vs. building=civic

2020-04-07 Thread Simon Poole
It doesn't really matter if I think the current mixup of use-based vs. style building values is particular useful or not, I still need to be able to display (and suggest) them in a meaningful way. Am 07.04.2020 um 15:13 schrieb Marc M.: > Le 07.04.20 à 12:19, Simon Poole a écrit : >> is here any

Re: [Tagging] building=public vs. building=civic

2020-04-07 Thread Marc M.
Le 07.04.20 à 12:19, Simon Poole a écrit : > is here any actual differentiation between the two values both are often badly used to describe the current function of the building and not what it look like. the description of building=civic said "A building hosting any civic amenity", so it's nothi

Re: [Tagging] Feature Proposal - RFC - Urgent Care

2020-04-07 Thread Ty S
Reservation, in my head, would steer me far away from doctors. They mean somewhat similar things, but reservation conjures up more of a restaurant with full service than a doctor's office or clinic. My definition of reservation is: "A reservation is a hold on a table at a restaurant" My definit

[Tagging] building=public vs. building=civic

2020-04-07 Thread Simon Poole
While doing my regular comparison of different sets of presets (see my talk at SotM Milano for more information), one of the more noticeable differences  is the the presets that I maintain, and by extension JOSM, does not include building=civic. This was introduced later than building=public and by

Re: [Tagging] Feature Proposal - RFC - protection_class=* (Words, not numeric codes)

2020-04-07 Thread Andrew Davidson
On 7/4/20 5:27 pm, Joseph Eisenberg wrote: There is also a third tag: leisure=nature_reserve, which is even more common, and traditionally has been used for natural conservation areas which are not National Parks or similar. Used 110k times: https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:leisure%3Dnatu

Re: [Tagging] Feature Proposal - RFC - protection_class=* (Words, not numeric codes)

2020-04-07 Thread Joseph Eisenberg
> Currently there are two ways to tag a conservation area: > boundary=national_park > or > boundary=protected_area + protect_class=1 to 7 There is also a third tag: leisure=nature_reserve, which is even more common, and traditionally has been used for natural conservation areas which are not Natio