Hi,
I would like to support two ideas that appeared in this thread:
1. Peter Wendorff's about documenting discouraged/old tagging schemes
in wiki as such - with link to correct schemes.
2. Worst Fixers general idea of merging multiple tags describing the
same thing into one (possibly globally).
Am 30.05.2012 02:40, schrieb Russ Nelson:
Frederik Ramm writes:
2. I don't think you should continue to make mass edits under the
username WorstFixer because that implies that before you fixed
things they were among the worst which has the potential to offend
people.
I always
Because if people are still editing like this, then I don't see the
problem that WorstFixer is fixing as actually being fixed. Users of
the map will still have to deal with both the format that WorstFixer
doesn't like AND the format he does like. Less of the former and more
of the latter, but
Hello Paul,
You use HTML letters in mailing list. Using blue color shows your power.
2012/5/30 Paul Norman penor...@mac.com:
Could you post the code used to generate the changesets?
Ich may not. Some parts of it are not open source. I think of clean rewrite.
That would be the
easiest way
From: Worst Fixer [mailto:worstfi...@gmail.com]
Subject: Re: [OSM-talk] Edit review: intermittent waters
Hello Paul,
You use HTML letters in mailing list. Using blue color shows your power.
My client uses HTML to reply to HTML messages. Since your message was HTML, I
followed up in HTML
Worst Fixer writes:
Persuade people to map just one way, THEN once they're doing that, go
back and get rid of the old way.
Sane people use type= for relation types.
They use water= tag to express whether it is lake, pond, river or
stream. Not how often it flows.
You seem not to
On 29 May 2012, at 12:51, Worst Fixer wrote:
Hello.
I ask you to review my planned edit.
There are lot of ways to tag intermittent water feature found in database.
Most popular is intermittent=yes. All others come from different old imports.
Date ist 2009-2010 year. I countiered ~350
Hi,
On 05/29/12 13:51, Worst Fixer wrote:
There are lot of ways to tag intermittent water feature found in
database. Most popular is intermittent=yes. All others come from
different old imports. Date ist 2009-2010 year. I countiered ~350 000
features tagged in different such ways. Most is done
2. I don't think you should continue to make mass edits under the
username WorstFixer because that implies that before you
fixed
things they were among the worst which has the potential to
offend people.
I've not been following what has and hasn't been done, or is
proposed, but the username
Worst Fixer wrote:
I ask you to review my planned edit.
There are lot of ways to tag intermittent water feature found in database.
Most popular is intermittent=yes. All others come from different old
imports. Date ist 2009-2010 year. I countiered ~350 000 features tagged in
different such ways.
2012/5/29 Phil Endecott spam_from_osm_t...@chezphil.org:
You're going to remove 9413 ele tags; why? No doubt at some point someone
decided that lake:shore_length:miles=2 was a useful thing to record, and
you want to remove it. Why?
because there is no such thing as a shore length, it
Martin Koppenhoefer wrote:
2012/5/29 Phil Endecott spam_from_osm_t...@chezphil.org:
No doubt at some point someone
decided that lake:shore_length:miles=2 was a useful thing to record, and
you want to remove it. Ã Why?
because there is no such thing as a shore length, it depends on the
Hello.
I used reply to instead of reply to all in my mail agent. We had a
small thread with Thomas. Here is major result we achived.
Thomas expressed opinion that not 100% of water=intermittent have
other tags, so we have no way count them as water.
In my sub-extract of water=intermittent:
Actually, the conclusion, while it involved that, also involved that there are
potential other uses (e.g. on river=intermittent; stream=intermittent etc) that
need to be checked too, and that this seems like an arbitrary renaming of tags
that doesn't gain anything, but may destroy data.
Thanks
Worst Fixer writes:
Just removed stream=fixme.
Why?
Removed all id-like tags.
Why?
If no valid objections will be raised, I upload this change on 2012-06-12.
Don't.
--
--my blog is athttp://blog.russnelson.com
Crynwr supports open source software
521 Pleasant Valley Rd. | +1
Frederik Ramm writes:
2. I don't think you should continue to make mass edits under the
username WorstFixer because that implies that before you fixed
things they were among the worst which has the potential to offend people.
I always thought it meant that he was the worst person to be
on
untouched objects.
From: Worst Fixer [mailto:worstfi...@gmail.com]
Sent: Tuesday, May 29, 2012 4:51 AM
To: talk@openstreetmap.org
Subject: [OSM-talk] Edit review: intermittent waters
Hello.
I ask you to review my planned edit.
There are lot of ways to tag intermittent water feature found
17 matches
Mail list logo
