Re: [OSM-talk] Quality reports of non EU area

2011-08-23 Thread John Harvey
I took a look at a bunch of cities around Europe, North America and some of Asia. I convert the OSM data into a compressed vector form that scales pretty linearly with node density, way density and POI metadata. For these cities, I try to fit as much city as I can into less than 20MB. I use

Re: [OSM-talk] Quality reports of non EU area

2011-08-23 Thread Matthias Meisser
Thanks for your work John! I need to take a clother view if I have a bit more time for that. Well I guess what Jaakko says is partly true. Mssive Data (see e.g. the fat imports) doesn't show up how good (here lively) the quality of the data is. thats why I personaly like OSMatrix as you can

Re: [OSM-talk] Quality reports of non EU area

2011-08-23 Thread John Harvey
If you are looking for an aesthetic metric for quality, you are probably looking for a human to evaluate quality. I would argue that most of the cities in North America (save Boston and maybe Toronto) quality is poor because there just isn't enough content. New York is a wicked example of no

[OSM-ja] FW: [OSM-talk] Quality reports of non EU area

2011-08-23 Thread Hiroshi Miura
Osmの品質とくにアジアについて研究は ないかという話がでています。 どなたか、考えたことはありますか。 過去に、sotmで商用との比較について、発表が ありました。 三浦 -Original Message- From: Matthias Meisser Sent: 23/08/2011 12:52:22 AM Subject: [OSM-talk] Quality reports of non EU area Hi there, well I'm looking for somekind of research/stats on the quality

Re: [OSM-ja] FW: [OSM-talk] Quality reports of non EU area

2011-08-23 Thread Shu Higashi
/23, Hiroshi Miura miur...@osmf.jp: Osmの品質とくにアジアについて研究は ないかという話がでています。 どなたか、考えたことはありますか。 過去に、sotmで商用との比較について、発表が ありました。 三浦 -Original Message- From: Matthias Meisser Sent: 23/08/2011 12:52:22 AM Subject: [OSM-talk] Quality reports of non EU area Hi there, well I'm looking

Re: [OSM-ja] FW: [OSM-talk] Quality reports of non EU area

2011-08-23 Thread Toshikazu SETO
University e-mail: gr000...@ed.ritsumei.ac.jp Hiroshi Miura miur...@osmf.jp wrote: Osmの品質とくにアジアについて研究は ないかという話がでています。 どなたか、考えたことはありますか。 過去に、sotmで商用との比較について、発表が ありました。 三浦 -Original Message- From: Matthias Meisser Sent: 23/08/2011 12:52:22 AM Subject: [OSM-talk] Quality reports of non

[OSM-talk] Quality reports of non EU area

2011-08-22 Thread Matthias Meisser
Hi there, well I'm looking for somekind of research/stats on the quality of our project especially in US or Asian area. I browsed the most of the scientific papers at http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Research but that ones, that concern the quality (and it's metrics) are mostly focused on the

Re: [OSM-talk] Quality reports of non EU area

2011-08-22 Thread Martijn van Exel
Hi Matthias, I'd like to see some non-EU quality analysis as well, and I am willing to work on it too. Right now I am just getting settled here in the US and doing some mapping locally, but next on my list is doing some quality analysis for at least some major US metro areas. If you find