Re: [OSM-talk-be] identifier in ref:xOperatorx=y0yyyy to url=http://mijnlijn.be/y0yyyy

2018-11-18 Thread André Pirard
On 2018-11-18 13:47, Jo wrote: Frank, url wasn't used yet on the bus stops, so no conflict there. Jakka's point is not that "url" is used but that it could be wanted and that this usage would prevent it. To prevent the

Re: [OSM-talk-be] identifier in ref:xOperatorx=y0yyyy to url=http://mijnlijn.be/y0yyyy

2018-11-18 Thread Jo
Frank, url wasn't used yet on the bus stops, so no conflict there. Pieter, good to hear De Lijn plans such deep links. I think it will be good to have them on our route_master relations. The route relations are for the longest variations in itinerary, not sure if they fit there. For the stops,

Re: [Talk-transit] [OSM-talk-be] identifier in ref:xOperatorx=y0yyyy to url=http://mijnlijn.be/y0yyyy

2018-11-18 Thread Pieter Colpaert
Hi Polyglot, We are in a Linked Data project with De Lijn and we’re going to have official persistent identifiers (HTTP URIs) soon for stops (but also for things like the routes and zones). It might be interesting to integrate these in OSM rather than the mijnlijn.be one? From the moment we

Re: [OSM-talk-be] identifier in ref:xOperatorx=y0yyyy to url=http://mijnlijn.be/y0yyyy

2018-11-18 Thread Marc Gemis
I would not drop the ref. The ref is visible on the signs, so it is a "real thing". I have no problem that people add the URL as well. The same is done for heritage sites. There is both a ref (refLOnroerendErfgoed and a heritage:website.) m. On Sun, Nov 18, 2018 at 10:52 AM Jo wrote: > > Our bus

Re: [OSM-talk-be] identifier in ref:xOperatorx=y0yyyy to url=http://mijnlijn.be/y0yyyy

2018-11-18 Thread Jakka
Using key as "url=" not comming in conflict with already other keys that use short key url ? Op 18/11/2018 om 10:51 schreef Jo: Our bus stops in Flanders have unique identifiers visible to the public on the flags of the stop poles. I started by entering those in the ref tag, then later

[OSM-talk-be] identifier in ref:xOperatorx=y0yyyy to url=http://mijnlijn.be/y0yyyy

2018-11-18 Thread Jo
Our bus stops in Flanders have unique identifiers visible to the public on the flags of the stop poles. I started by entering those in the ref tag, then later decided to use ref:De_Lijn=y0, as some of those stops are served by other operators as well. For several years now itt's possible to