Re: [Talk-GB] Sources - was "Re: Upcoming changes to OpenStreetMap.org website"

2013-11-18 Thread Nick Whitelegg
nes wrote: - To: "OSM GB" From: Philip Barnes Date: 18/11/2013 01:17PM Subject: Re: [Talk-GB] Sources - was "Re: Upcoming changes to OpenStreetMap.org website"  Also the area we are lacking at the moment is rights of way, these are often not visible on sate

Re: [Talk-GB] Sources - was "Re: Upcoming changes to OpenStreetMap.org website"

2013-11-18 Thread Philip Barnes
It depends on the county, in most cases the council right of way data is still covered by OS copyright, so is not suitable for inclusion in OSM. I would be in breach of OS copyright if I was to do the same in Shropshire. Right of way data also lacks the location of stiles, gates etc. Adding thes

Re: [Talk-GB] Sources - was "Re: Upcoming changes to OpenStreetMap.org website"

2013-11-18 Thread Jonathan
Why re-invent the wheel? There's nothing wrong with "copying" a source that is open, yes, there's always the caveat of the quality of its data and yes verify some of it with your own survey but there is too much of the World to map and too few people. Stand on the shoulders of Giants! Last we

Re: [Talk-GB] Sources - was "Re: Upcoming changes to OpenStreetMap.org website"

2013-11-18 Thread Jonathan
I should re-phrase my comment, GPS traces are important, but for small niche parts of the map or brand new developments. I do use GPS, but the bulk of editing is done from other sources, and I don't mean Bing, there are loads of sources coming online every day. In Worcestershire, where the lo

Re: [Talk-GB] Sources - was "Re: Upcoming changes to OpenStreetMap.org website"

2013-11-18 Thread Philip Barnes
Also the area we are lacking at the moment is rights of way, these are often not visible on satellite imagery and the only way to map them is to go out and walk them with a GPS. Phil (trigpoint) -- Sent from my Nokia N9 On 18/11/2013 13:03 SomeoneElse wrote: Jonathan wrote: ... but are t

[Talk-GB] Sources - was "Re: Upcoming changes to OpenStreetMap.org website"

2013-11-18 Thread SomeoneElse
Jonathan wrote: ... but are traces really that important now? They have some uses but the bulk of sources now and going forward are from other methods? If "other methods" means "copying from other data sources rather than actually going out and surveying" then you're never going to get "the b