Re: [Talk-us] Oahu, Hawaii CDP boundaries

2019-09-07 Thread stevea
I agree; this sounds correct. I've lived in the USA for several decades (my entire life), though I do travel. Country, state, county, city (in the USA) rather neatly map onto admin_level= 2, 4, 6 and 8 (respectively). There are wider-area exceptions (like township=7) and in some places

Re: [Talk-us] Oahu, Hawaii CDP boundaries

2019-09-07 Thread Joseph Eisenberg
ZIP Codes (US Postal Service codes) are not administrative boundaries. They are widely used for addressing, for routing and for deliveries by private companies in addition to the USPS, but they are not used for any official administrative purposes, at least not in the States where I have lived.

Re: [Talk-us] Oahu, Hawaii CDP boundaries

2019-09-06 Thread Mateusz Konieczny
6 Sep 2019, 22:10 by stevea...@softworkers.com: > I slightly disagree with Mateusz that we "reflect local postal" boundaries, > as we don't do that in the USA with ZIP codes: they are routing algorithms, > not actual areas definable by a (multi)polygon. > Note that I was asking whatever it

Re: [Talk-us] Oahu, Hawaii CDP boundaries

2019-09-06 Thread stevea
One minor correction, one minor addition to my previous post on this topic. Where I said "...none of these seems like it would be a boundary=admin_level..." this is more correctly stated "none of these seems like they should be a boundary=administrative..." Also, I have recently discovered

Re: [Talk-us] Oahu, Hawaii CDP boundaries

2019-09-06 Thread stevea
This is from a thread on impo...@openstreetmap.org of the same title (Vol. 123, Issue 6). The thread is not attached here, but it involves Brian asking after tagging CDP boundaries in Oahu County and its coterminous incorporated consolidated-city-county of Honolulu. Brian, I agree with Mateusz