Re: [Talk-us] Tiger Zip Data Removal Project (Update)

Marc Gemis wrote: I wonder whether it is interesting to know the difference between concrete, asphalt and pervious concrete. All three have different characteristics whether it be comfort for the cyclist or being dangerous under icy conditions or durability under heavy loaded trucks. What do you

Re: [Talk-us] Tiger Zip Data Removal Project (Update)

On 2017.07.17. 06:16, Marc Gemis wrote: > I wonder whether it is interesting to know the difference between > concrete, asphalt and pervious concrete. All three have different > characteristics whether it be comfort for the cyclist or being > dangerous under icy conditions or durability under

Re: [Talk-us] Tiger Zip Data Removal Project (Update)

I wonder whether it is interesting to know the difference between concrete, asphalt and pervious concrete. All three have different characteristics whether it be comfort for the cyclist or being dangerous under icy conditions or durability under heavy loaded trucks. What do you think ? Is it worth

Re: [Talk-us] Tiger Zip Data Removal Project (Update)

Kevin Kenny wrote: > Fair enough. I will confess that I'm a little lackadaisical about > tagging the surface on hard-surfaced roads. It appears that > some sort of hard surface is more or less assumed by default. > I do tag 'gravel', 'compacted', 'shale', 'sand', 'ground' > assiduously, and

Re: [Talk-us] Tiger Zip Data Removal Project (Update)

On Sun, Jul 16, 2017 at 11:47 AM, Richard Fairhurst wrote: > Bryan Housel wrote: >> We haven’t discussed automatic removal of any other tiger tags. >> (I don’t have a strong opinion for either keeping or removing them.) > > I have a really strong opinion _against_ removing

Re: [Talk-us] Tiger Zip Data Removal Project (Update)

Bryan Housel wrote: > We haven’t discussed automatic removal of any other tiger tags. > (I don’t have a strong opinion for either keeping or removing them.) I have a really strong opinion _against_ removing tiger:reviewed tags where the road type and surface have not been manually reviewed!

Re: [Talk-us] Tiger Zip Data Removal Project (Update)

Hey Hans, We have a closed issue on the iD tracker for automatic removal of `tiger:reviewed`: https://github.com/openstreetmap/iD/issues/2697 We haven’t discussed automatic removal of any other tiger tags. (I don’t have a strong opinion for

Re: [Talk-us] Tiger Zip Data Removal Project (Update)

Thanks for the advice everyone. I have moved on to my normal editing. About the soft approach to tiger removal. I see no reason not to look into it. Do i bring up these questions on github for Josm & iD? On Jul 12, 2017 10:15 PM, wrote: > Hi Hans, > > I sincerely hope you’ll

Re: [Talk-us] Tiger Zip Data Removal Project (Update)

Hi Hans, I sincerely hope you’ll reconsider because I know that you have a lot of positive energy to bring to the US community. I think what you might take away from this is that a single thread on the mailing list is not always enough to gauge the temperature of the community. There are many

Re: [Talk-us] Tiger Zip Data Removal Project (Update)

Frederik wrote: > I notice that at least two people who have negatively commented on your > recent edits in changeset comments - Max Erickson and Steve A - are > regulars on this mailing list, but they didn't get involved when you > discussed the issue here four weeks ago. As this is my second

Re: [Talk-us] Tiger Zip Data Removal Project (Update)

Hans, Just wanted to say to not give up working on osm. Open Knowledge and Open source brings out the worst in people sometimes, just look at the wikipedia edit wars, and other strife, for example the systemd discussion. Some people get very territorial about 'their' section of the map and upset

Re: [Talk-us] Tiger Zip Data Removal Project (Update)

Hans, On 07/08/2017 10:37 PM, Hans De Kryger wrote: > So last month i started a discussion about a project i took on removing > Tiger zip data across the U.S. I brought it to the community after i > received concern from quite a few mappers in the U.S. I notice that at least two people who have

[Talk-us] Tiger Zip Data Removal Project (Update)

So last month i started a discussion about a project i took on removing Tiger zip data across the U.S. I brought it to the community after i received concern from quite a few mappers in the U.S. After getting more unfriendly changeset comments and messages in my inbox i'm officially done. The