Re: [time-nuts] 53230A noise floor

2015-07-07 Thread Magnus Danielson
Anders, Beware that there is both lambda and omega filterings on counters to enhance their performance over pi counters, and that this relates to frequency output. However, for propper ADEV and friends you have to be careful. TI-mode is to be used in order to avoid the lambda or omega propert

Re: [time-nuts] 53230A noise floor

2015-06-24 Thread Anders Wallin
I finally had time to compare the 53230A CONT (resolution-enhanced, aka lambda-counting) and RCON (undocumented! reciprocal continuous counting, aka pi-counting) modes, and wrote down some notes: http://www.anderswallin.net/2015/06/cont-vs-rcon-mode-on-the-53230a-frequency-counter/ comments on my

Re: [time-nuts] 53230A noise floor

2015-04-07 Thread Mod Mix
Ole Petter Ronningen: Tangetially relevant; I made a "patch" for TimeLab to use the gap-free frequency measurement-mode for the 53230A, if anyone is interested. Thanks for this great support! Ulli ___ time-nuts mailing list -- time-nuts@febo.com To uns

Re: [time-nuts] 53230A noise floor

2015-04-07 Thread Ole Petter Ronningen
Tangetially relevant; I made a "patch" for TimeLab to use the gap-free frequency measurement-mode for the 53230A, if anyone is interested. On Fri, Apr 3, 2015 at 4:34 PM, Tom Van Baak wrote: > > There is probably a good explanation for the ADEV-level in standard > > (pi-counting?) reciprocal fre

Re: [time-nuts] 53230A noise floor

2015-04-04 Thread Poul-Henning Kamp
In message <973e79bb-7b83-40a8-9799-c3b072a68...@n1k.org>, Bob Camp writes: >This is by no means a bash on the 53230. Properly fed, it’s a fine >device. Every fancy counter I’ve seen has these sort of issues one >way or the other. Absolutely. But I'm just trying to alert Anders that wha

Re: [time-nuts] 53230A noise floor

2015-04-03 Thread James via time-nuts
53230A to give low single shot resolution at the expense of slightly higher channel skew. James -Original Message- From: Anders Wallin To: Discussion Sent: Fri, 3 Apr 2015 12:04 Subject: [time-nuts] 53230A noise floor Hi all, I ran some tests on a new 53230A counter tha

Re: [time-nuts] 53230A noise floor

2015-04-03 Thread Bob Camp
Hi If you use the same sort of small step synthesizer approach and get very close (but not equal to) the reference, you can find “dead spots” where the resolution is not as good as you expected it to be. You need to be able to step off in 1x10^-11 steps to do a good job of plotting it. Sweeping

Re: [time-nuts] 53230A noise floor

2015-04-03 Thread Anders Wallin
> > > See the part the end that shows why averaging breaks ADEV: > http://leapsecond.com/pages/adev-avg/ > Hi Tom, thanks for reminding me of that page. I did no averaging of the data myself, and I think it's logical that the counter noise floor goes down with increasing gate time - I just hav

Re: [time-nuts] 53230A noise floor

2015-04-03 Thread Magnus Danielson
Anders, On 04/03/2015 11:49 AM, Anders Wallin wrote: Hi all, I ran some tests on a new 53230A counter that just arrived: http://www.anderswallin.net/2015/04/keysight-53230a-noise-floor-test/ The time-interval single-shot noise and resulting ADEV seems easy enough to explain. I didn't yet have

Re: [time-nuts] 53230A noise floor

2015-04-03 Thread James via time-nuts
ion :). James -Original Message- From: Anders Wallin To: Discussion Sent: Fri, 3 Apr 2015 12:04 Subject: [time-nuts] 53230A noise floor Hi all, I ran some tests on a new 53230A counter that just arrived: http://www.anderswallin.net/2015/04/keysight-53230a-noise-floor-test/ The t

Re: [time-nuts] 53230A noise floor

2015-04-03 Thread Poul-Henning Kamp
In message , Anders Wallin writes: >I ran some tests on a new 53230A counter that just arrived: >http://www.anderswallin.net/2015/04/keysight-53230a-noise-floor-test/ Anders, I think that setup didn't measure what you think. When you feed the counter EXT REF from the same source you m

Re: [time-nuts] 53230A noise floor

2015-04-03 Thread Tom Van Baak
> There is probably a good explanation for the ADEV-level in standard > (pi-counting?) reciprocal frequency counter mode as well as the roughly > 1/sqrt(10) enhancement in ADEV when increasing the gate-time 10-fold. Anders, See the part the end that shows why averaging breaks ADEV: http://lea

Re: [time-nuts] 53230A noise floor

2015-04-03 Thread Bob Camp
Hi You may want to take a look at some of Bill Riley’s (and others) papers on how pre-filtering can lead to errors in an ADEV calculation. Simply put - the frequency mode is a filter and it is not the right one to have in front of an ADEV calculation. Bob > On Apr 3, 2015, at 5:49 AM, Ander

[time-nuts] 53230A noise floor

2015-04-03 Thread Anders Wallin
Hi all, I ran some tests on a new 53230A counter that just arrived: http://www.anderswallin.net/2015/04/keysight-53230a-noise-floor-test/ The time-interval single-shot noise and resulting ADEV seems easy enough to explain. I didn't yet have time to look closely at Enrico Rubiola's notes over her