[time-nuts] Re: Timestamping counter techniques : phase computation question

2022-01-31 Thread Erik Kaashoek
@Bob Yes, the resolution provided with the HW is a given and is good enough so I am most interested in those well known techniques to improve on it. Can you provide some pointers? I am aware of techniques like analog interpolation and time to data to improve the accuracy but these required ad

[time-nuts] Re: Looking For An Antenna

2022-01-31 Thread va2hdd
Hi Chris. As Tom said before these units are cheap and abundant because they can not be used as time reference even if you do find an antenna. To make things worse the antenna itself is active (i.e. amplified) with a down converter that will bring down the 468 MHz signal frequency to around

[time-nuts] Re: Looking For An Antenna

2022-01-31 Thread kyrrin
    I used to own/use a 468-DC. They are, unfortunately, useless now because NOAA stopped transmitting the UHF-based time code over the GOES satellites in the early 2000's (this is, very likely, why it was so cheap).     In short ... Even if you got a perfect antenna for the unit, there's noth

[time-nuts] Re: Looking For An Antenna

2022-01-31 Thread Tom Van Baak
Hi Chris, Sorry, a 468 MHz GOES antenna won't help. That satellite timing service ended 15+ years ago, another victim to the global success of GPS. So antenna or not, the receiver has no signal to lock on to. That's why the receivers are so cheap these days. There may be old postings in the ti

[time-nuts] Looking For An Antenna

2022-01-31 Thread NoName via time-nuts
I'm new to the group.  I'm looking for an antenna for a Kinemetrics 468-DC.  I only paid a few bucks for the unit and all the surplus companies want 800-900USD for an antenna. Does anyone have a source for a reasonably priced antenna, or, has anyone built one that they would care to share the deta

[time-nuts] Re: Timestamping counter techniques : phase computation question

2022-01-31 Thread Bill Metzenthen
On 1/2/22 04:00, Attila Kinali wrote: [1] "New frequency counting principle improves resolution", by Johanson, 2005 https://doi.org/10.1109/FREQ.2005.1574007 (there was a non-paywalled version of this, but the link has gone away) Is this it? https://pendulum-instruments.com/wp-content/uploads/2

[time-nuts] Re: Clock specs for audio (was: High precision OCXO supplier for end costomers)

2022-01-31 Thread use...@teply.info
On 10.01.22 16:23, Lux, Jim wrote: And I suppose this is why it's worth talking to the mfr than looking through the catalogs. There might well be some key requirement that if relaxed slightly would work out quite well in terms of availability. We run into this all the time in the space busin

[time-nuts] Re: Timestamping counter techniques : phase computation question

2022-01-31 Thread Magnus Danielson via time-nuts
Erik, On 2022-01-31 22:17, Erik Kaashoek wrote: @Magnus The time interval of the capturing of the counters is not always exactly the same. There could be even substantial variation if the capture interval is close to the event interval. Is this a problem for the calculation method you propose?

[time-nuts] Re: Timestamping counter techniques : phase computation question

2022-01-31 Thread Bob kb8tq
Hi What you run into on a lot of setups are dead bands. You get a series of (effectively) same / same /same /same sample groups. Applying math to them gives you the (obvious) result … everything is perfect. If you have (say) a 200 MHz clock, your data will be “chunked” into 5 ns spaced buckets o

[time-nuts] Re: Timestamping counter techniques : phase computation question

2022-01-31 Thread Erik Kaashoek
@Magnus The time interval of the capturing of the counters is not always exactly the same. There could be even substantial variation if the capture interval is close to the event interval. Is this a problem for the calculation method you propose? Erik ___

[time-nuts] Re: Timestamping counter techniques : phase computation question

2022-01-31 Thread Erik Kaashoek
In the nist documents a separation is made between a measurement device that provides single observations spaced in time and the statistical processing that uses these observations over a long time period. My focus is the on methods to come to the best possible single observation as input to the st

[time-nuts] Re: Timestamping counter techniques : phase computation question

2022-01-31 Thread Magnus Danielson via time-nuts
Erik, On 2022-01-31 20:32, Erik Kaashoek wrote: Thanks all for the good input. @Magnus, I need some time to understand the math as it has been over 30 years since when I used to do this kind of math. There is no intention to store the collected captures, only to present a measurement at the mea

[time-nuts] Re: Timestamping counter techniques : phase computation question

2022-01-31 Thread Bob kb8tq
Hi > On Jan 31, 2022, at 2:32 PM, Erik Kaashoek wrote: > > Thanks all for the good input. > > @Magnus, I need some time to understand the math as it has been over 30 > years since when I used to do this kind of math. > There is no intention to store the collected captures, only to present a > m

[time-nuts] Re: Timestamping counter techniques : phase computation question

2022-01-31 Thread Erik Kaashoek
Thanks all for the good input. @Magnus, I need some time to understand the math as it has been over 30 years since when I used to do this kind of math. There is no intention to store the collected captures, only to present a measurement at the measurement interval, so currently I'm calculating the

[time-nuts] Re: Timestamping counter techniques : phase computation question

2022-01-31 Thread Attila Kinali
On Mon, 31 Jan 2022 17:42:38 +0100 Erik Kaashoek wrote: > he clock is a 200MHz perfect clock. > The events come from an unknown quality XCO at 10 MHz > The measurement interval is 0.1 seconds > The goal is to derive the phase (and also the frequency) of the XCO versus > the clock from the counter

[time-nuts] Re: Timestamping counter techniques : phase computation question

2022-01-31 Thread Bob kb8tq
Hi One thing that is still unclear: Why do you have two clocks tagging the events? You have a simple crystal oscillator and are looking at 0.1 seconds. That oscillator likely “bounces around” ( = has a noise floor) at about 1x10^-8 or so. Indeed, your “perfect” clock likely has similar issues.

[time-nuts] Re: Timestamping counter techniques : phase computation question

2022-01-31 Thread Attila Kinali
On Sun, 30 Jan 2022 12:46:19 +0100 Erik Kaashoek wrote: > 1: Is using linear regression as described above a good method to > calculate the phase relation between events and clock? If not, what > method to use? Yes, it is. You can see each measurment as an statistically independent sample. Pen

[time-nuts] Re: Timestamping counter techniques : phase computation question

2022-01-31 Thread Erik Kaashoek
Excellent questions. The goal is to measure with a certain interval the phase of repetitive events versus a clock. The clock is assumed to be perfect. Also the counters are assumed to be perfect. The events can change their frequency and phase but any change within one measurement interval is allo

[time-nuts] Re: Timestamping counter techniques : phase computation question

2022-01-31 Thread Magnus Danielson via time-nuts
Hi Erik, On 2022-01-30 12:46, Erik Kaashoek wrote: In a timestamping counter I'm trying to calculate phase and frequency using statistical techniques. The counter has two counters, one for the input events and one for an internal clock. The capturing of these counters happens synchronized with

[time-nuts] Re: Timestamping counter techniques : phase computation question

2022-01-31 Thread Bob kb8tq
HI > On Jan 31, 2022, at 10:23 AM, Erik Kaashoek wrote: > > There was a small error in my previous post > > Here are the complete and corrected numbers > Below table shows: > > Event counter(Y) : The exact count of events since the start of the counter > captured at the time of the event. > C

[time-nuts] Re: Timestamping counter techniques : phase computation question

2022-01-31 Thread Erik Kaashoek
There was a small error in my previous post Here are the complete and corrected numbers Below table shows: Event counter(Y) : The exact count of events since the start of the counter captured at the time of the event. Clock Counter(X) : The clock cycles since the start of the counter captured