Re: [tips] Motivation by Shame

2009-03-28 Thread Joan Warmbold
You say positive reinforcements worked better than negative reinforcement for your Canadian scholar Bill? Didn't B.F. say something to that effect also? Joan jwarm...@oakton.edu > Stephen Black asks: > > 1) What is the earliest reported use of contingency contracts with dire > consequences for n

Re: [tips] Motivation by Shame

2009-03-28 Thread William Scott
Stephen Black asks: 1) What is the earliest reported use of contingency contracts with dire consequences for non-compliance? 2) What is the earliest specific reference to the possibly apocryphal American Nazi contingency? Stephen Malott, R., Whaley, D., and Malott, M. (1997). Elementary Princ

Re: [tips] Motivation by Shame

2009-03-28 Thread sblack
> On Mar 27, 2009, at 10:03 AM, Michael Britt wrote: > > > Interesting article on the front page of the Chronicle this week > > called, "Falling Behind? Try Shame, Fear, and Greed". Basically the > > idea is that people are trying to motivate themselves by "taking a > > contract out on themselve

Re: [tips] Motivation by Shame

2009-03-27 Thread Michael Britt
Yes, good point Marc: it does depend on how you phrase it. Are you trying to "eat less" (in which case you're trying to stop the behavior of eating), in which case if you "contract" to donate to a cause you don't believe in then you're using negative punishment, or does your contact have y

RE: [tips] Motivation by Shame

2009-03-27 Thread Marc Carter
> -Original Message- > From: Michael Britt [mailto:michael.br...@thepsychfiles.com] > Sent: Friday, March 27, 2009 10:03 AM > To: Teaching in the Psychological Sciences (TIPS) > Subject: [tips] Motivation by Shame > [snip] > > Sounds like simple negative reinforcement? > Wouldn't that

Re: [tips] Motivation by Shame

2009-03-27 Thread Paul Brandon
Yes -- avoidance behavior. An old behavioral technique also mentioned by Thaler and Sunstein in Nudge. On Mar 27, 2009, at 10:03 AM, Michael Britt wrote: Interesting article on the front page of the Chronicle this week called, "Falling Behind? Try Shame, Fear, and Greed". Basically the ide