Re: [tips] While we are on the topic of Skinner

2014-01-17 Thread Mike Palij
Paul, You've written two posts and I'll try to answer your points. I will "snip" some of your statements below in order to save space and make the text more readable. I will number my points in order to make them easier to refer to in subsequent posts. Consider the following points: (1) I don't

Re: [tips] While we are on the topic of Skinner

2014-01-17 Thread Paul Brandon
And remember the 'Two Freds' (Skinner and Keller) presentations at ABA (Association for Behavior Analysis) meetings! On Jan 17, 2014, at 11:04 AM, Ken Steele wrote: > > A followup to Rick's comments. > > Skinner once described the following situation. (I am blanking on the > source.) He had m

Re: [tips] While we are on the topic of Skinner

2014-01-17 Thread Ken Steele
A followup to Rick's comments. Skinner once described the following situation. (I am blanking on the source.) He had made an off-the-cuff joke which produced a strong reaction in his audience. He describes going back to his office and trying to remember the words and intonation he used so he

RE: Re:[tips] While we are on the topic of Skinner

2014-01-17 Thread rfro...@jbu.edu
-Original Message- From: Mike Palij [mailto:m...@nyu.edu] A behavioral account might be relevant to certain situations but are unlikely in others (e.g., how would a behaviorist explain satire?). -Mike Palij New York University m...@nyu.edu -- I

Re: [tips] While we are on the topic of Skinner

2014-01-17 Thread Paul Brandon
>From a behavioral viewpoint verbal behavior IS behavior and obeys the same >basic laws. The -situations- in which it occurs are unique, leading to unique analyses (there are journals filled with these). And it's an oversimplification to say that " Skinner did not believe in the study of cog

Re: [tips] While we are on the topic of Skinner

2014-01-17 Thread Jeffry Ricker, PhD
On Jan 17, 2014, at 8:54 AM, Gerald Peterson wrote: > It appeared fine here. Enjoyed the reference too...and the picture. Thanks. Perhaps it's a problem with our email system. I'll check into it. Best, Jeff -- - J

Re: [tips] While we are on the topic of Skinner

2014-01-17 Thread Gerald Peterson
It appeared fine here. Enjoyed the reference too...and the picture. G.L. (Gary) Peterson,Ph.D Psychology@SVSU > On Jan 17, 2014, at 10:53 AM, "Jeffry Ricker, Ph.D." > wrote: > > > I'm going to try this again because it seems that my email consisted of a > bunch of "mish-mosh." The joke a

Re: [tips] While we are on the topic of Skinner

2014-01-17 Thread Paul Brandon
) > Cc: Michael Palij > Subject: Re:[tips] While we are on the topic of Skinner > > ... A behavioral account might be relevant to certain situations but are > unlikely in others (e.g., how would a behaviorist explain satire?). Paul Brandon Emeritus Professor of Psychology Minnesota S

RE: Re:[tips] While we are on the topic of Skinner

2014-01-17 Thread William Scott
From: Mike Palij Sent: Friday, January 17, 2014 8:36 AM To: Teaching in the Psychological Sciences (TIPS) Cc: Michael Palij Subject: Re:[tips] While we are on the topic of Skinner ... A behavioral account might be relevant to certain situations but are

Re:[tips] While we are on the topic of Skinner

2014-01-17 Thread Mike Palij
On Thu, 16 Jan 2014 20:39:53 -0600 (CST), Joan Warmbold wrote: Carol--consider contacting the Skinner foundation via his daughter, Julie Vargas at opera...@bfskinner.org. Folks who knew Skinner have told me that he had a wonderful sense of humor so bet he would have had an opinion. Certainly o

Re: [tips] While we are on the topic of Skinner

2014-01-16 Thread Joan Warmbold
Carol--consider contacting the Skinner foundation via his daughter, Julie Vargas at opera...@bfskinner.org. Folks who knew Skinner have told me that he had a wonderful sense of humor so bet he would have had an opinion. Certainly ones life experiences and reference systems play an important role,

Re: [tips] While we are on the topic of Skinner

2014-01-16 Thread Carol DeVolder
Thanks, Mike and Paul (Paul responded back channel as he had already squandered his posts yesterday :) ) Mike, I have read many of the things you mentioned and I'm familiar with Darwin's take on it, as well as the changes through the centuries *vis a vis *the various philosophers. I have not found

Re: [tips] While we are on the topic of Skinner

2014-01-16 Thread Paul Brandon
Skinner discusses humor on pages 285ff and 395 of Verbal Behavior (1957). For a more contemporary account see Catania's LEARNING text (p264 in the 4th edition (1999) -- there should be a similar analysis in the 5th, but I've lent it to someone): "Any verbal topography potentially can take on any

re: [tips] While we are on the topic of Skinner

2014-01-16 Thread Mike Palij
On Wed, 15 Jan 2014 12:40:38 -0800, Carol DeVolder wrote: >What sources should I look at to find a behaviorist view of laughter, >mirth, and humor? I realize I'm being vague--that's on purpose. :) A few points to consider: (1) If you have not examined the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy's en

Re: [tips] While we are on the topic of Skinner

2014-01-15 Thread Paul Brandon
An interesting question! A quick browse through the contents of a few behavioral journals didn't turn up anything; behaviorists usually either examine basic processes, or practical solutions to problems. I wouldn't be surprised if there's something in Skinner's Verbal Behavior (he had something

[tips] While we are on the topic of Skinner

2014-01-15 Thread Carol DeVolder
What sources should I look at to find a behaviorist view of laughter, mirth, and humor? I realize I'm being vague--that's on purpose. :) Thanks, Carol -- Carol DeVolder, Ph.D. Professor of Psychology St. Ambrose University 518 West Locust Street Davenport, Iowa 52803 563-333-6482 --- You are cu