[Bug 1520441] Re: USB OTG finicky and opaque

2015-12-02 Thread Jean-Baptiste Lallement
I confirm the problem on arale (rc-proposed / 183) I tried with a generic 4GB USB stick, formatted on a PC with a vfat filesystem. It works fine on krillin with the same version but not on arale where it fails with the same trace than in previous comment: Dec 2 15:29:28 ubuntu-phablet kernel: [

[Bug 1520441] Re: USB OTG finicky and opaque

2015-12-01 Thread Matthew Exon
OK, here's one. This is a SanDisk with an activity LED. Plug it in and it flashes for a bit. Then nothing. The drive is not mounted and I can't see the videos. It shows up in External Drives. The syslog seems to say that it was mounted. I've also include the part of the syslog where I unplug

[Bug 1520441] Re: USB OTG finicky and opaque

2015-12-01 Thread Matthew Exon
Argh! This morning all four USB drives are working fine. Just as you say, they can't be unmounted and I have to just unplug them. I've tried many times across many reboots but this is the first time any drive formatted outside the phone has ever worked. I have not changed any software or settin

[Bug 1520441] Re: USB OTG finicky and opaque

2015-12-01 Thread Pat McGowan
Also seems the drive needs to be inserted before starting file manager, that seems a bug that it doesn't detect it -- You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Bugs, which is subscribed to Ubuntu. https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/1520441 Title: USB OTG finicky and op

[Bug 1520441] Re: USB OTG finicky and opaque

2015-12-01 Thread Pat McGowan
My drive was not formatted on the device, it was pre-formatted and worked fine. I have only tried this one but I know other users have said they are able to do this. Re power issues that could be but hard to diagnose, perhaps the syslog would indicate something as the drive is mounted Re no files

[Bug 1520441] Re: USB OTG finicky and opaque

2015-12-01 Thread Pat McGowan
@jibel maybe your team could verify ** Changed in: canonical-devices-system-image Assignee: Pat McGowan (pat-mcgowan) => Jean-Baptiste Lallement (jibel) -- You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Bugs, which is subscribed to Ubuntu. https://bugs.launchpad.net/b

[Bug 1520441] Re: USB OTG finicky and opaque

2015-11-30 Thread Matthew Exon
What more info would you like? I've tried this now with some more devices. I have a very old 4GB SanDisk Cruzer, and I have two microSD card readers with two different cards, a 2GB and a 4GB, as well as the original Kingston drive. All of the drives show the "Unmount Error The device could not b

[Bug 1520441] Re: USB OTG finicky and opaque

2015-11-30 Thread Pat McGowan
I retired my 16GB sandisk and it actually worked quite well for me so we may need a bit more info. The notification that the device was detected and it would be scanned for content was received. I confirmed I could see the content in Music player and the gallery I could also see the files after u

[Bug 1520441] Re: USB OTG finicky and opaque

2015-11-30 Thread Pat McGowan
** Also affects: ciborium (Ubuntu) Importance: Undecided Status: New ** Changed in: canonical-devices-system-image Status: New => Confirmed ** Changed in: canonical-devices-system-image Milestone: None => backlog ** Changed in: canonical-devices-system-image Assignee: (