[Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2017-07-27 Thread Alberto Salvia Novella
Disclaimer: inspired in GNOME, not Ubuntu. -- You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Bugs, which is subscribed to Ubuntu. https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/668415 Title: Movement of Unity launcher To manage notifications about this bug go to: https://bugs.launchpa

[Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2017-07-27 Thread Alberto Salvia Novella
Bottom-line: (https://plus.google.com/+AlbertoSalviaNovella/posts/eiTBoe3qEnL) -- You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Bugs, which is subscribed to Ubuntu. https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/668415 Title: Movement of Unity launcher To manage notifications about t

[Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2017-07-27 Thread Alberto Salvia Novella
** Changed in: ubuntu Importance: Undecided => Wishlist -- You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Bugs, which is subscribed to Ubuntu. https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/668415 Title: Movement of Unity launcher To manage notifications about this bug go to: https

Re: [Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2016-05-20 Thread Mark Shuttleworth
Wow. -- You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Bugs, which is subscribed to Ubuntu. https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/668415 Title: Movement of Unity launcher To manage notifications about this bug go to: https://bugs.launchpad.net/ayatana-design/+bug/668415/+subs

[Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2016-05-20 Thread zjz
Comment on--> I think the report actually meant that the launcher should be movable to other edges of the screen. I'm afraid that won't work with our broader design goals, so we won't implement that. We want the launcher always close to the Ubuntu button. status wontfix == As

[Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2016-05-20 Thread zjz
I think the report actually meant that the launcher should be movable to other edges of the screen. I'm afraid that won't work with our broader design goals, so we won't implement that. We want the launcher always close to the Ubuntu button. status wontfix a basic function and make Ubuntu not cus

[Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2016-03-20 Thread Tal Liron
Well. Apparently this bug was partially fixed for 16.04 by Marco Trevisan, in a hidden way: http://news.softpedia.com/news/it-s-official-ubuntu-16-04-lts-now-lets- you-move-the-unity-launcher-to-bottom-501932.shtml https://plus.google.com/u/0/+MarcoTrevisan/posts/X46usgf7gSk https://www.youtube.

[Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2015-10-26 Thread Томица Кораћ
@obligat @iloveyou I couldn't agree more. The entire Ubuntu movement is suffering just because of a single stuborn man (@sabdfl). This foolishness is honestly something I simply couldn't have imagined happening in 2010. And to think the same terrible problem is still present after 5 years... Well g

[Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2015-09-28 Thread Dania Luchinets
I love Ubuntu's global menu. Really. Combined with windows undecoration it's f_cking better then anything. Much more better then in a Mac. But I hate Ubuntu's nail-picked launcher. It's f_cking terrible. It's incompatible with using of multiple operative systems. No matter how Unity team make it su

Re: [Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2015-07-02 Thread Mark Shuttleworth
Thanks Mike, that's very gracious. I know the Unity team care to make it super-efficient to use, with a minimum of movements and the best keybindings for pro's, and they'll appreciate your thoughtful comments. Mark -- You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Bugs, wh

[Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2015-07-01 Thread outtatime
"You missed one: "Now it's clear how the launcher being on the left works across phone, tablet, PC and TV" - Mark Shuttleworth, 2013-02-19 ;)" *** The same UI on different devices is an epic fail. Different devices has different logic of handling. The tablet is usually without mouse, the PC n

[Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2014-08-31 Thread Mike
I originally wrote comment #342 complaining to Mark about how this decision was not in line with the ideology of freedom in open source and went on to rant about how some engineers firends and I switched to centos or gentoo for some work related work because of the unity interface, blah, blah, blah

[Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2014-08-08 Thread Kevin Seifert
I've been using Unity for several years, until recently (after the last update, my machine wouldn't boot). Recently, I switched over to xubuntu, which is also an awesome distro. I've been thinking about this "bug" off and on for about two years in the process. Here are my thoughts... hopefully

[Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2014-07-22 Thread Mike
@Mark Shuttleworth, @MarkShuttleworth, #MarkShuttleworth, sabdfl, mark@peregrine, mark@mark-XPS-15, however else I may get your attention sir :) Dear Mr. Shuttleworth, You have a great vision and when I first discovered Ubuntu at version 10.04 LTS, I loved it from the start because it embodied th

[Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2014-04-22 Thread elian
This relates to lack of hardware compositing/3D effects on older hardware .. I'm still using an ancient GeForce 5200 card (motherboard just refuses to quit). Shade/fade effects in 14.04 are exceedingly slow because I am assuming rendering is being done in software w/nouveau. With the nVidia binary

[Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2014-03-21 Thread graner
I am a new convert to Linux. I love Ubuntu but so far HATE this decision to force the dock to always be on the right side. This is a tension between logical semantics/convention (which is the argument Mark is making) and emotional preferences of taste. People simply have non-logical, emotionally

[Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2013-12-23 Thread Tal Liron
Thanks, Mark! Can't speak for everyone else here, but I think being able to use an alternative Launcher would provide a partial workaround for this "bug," allowing for it to be closed as "fixed." However, I still think it's important to allow the other components to be turned off (Dash and top Pa

Re: [Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2013-12-23 Thread Mark Shuttleworth
On 23/12/13 16:52, Tal Liron wrote: > You're mistaken about the modularity of Unity7: it's impossible right > now pick and chose components. Unity7 is an either-or affair: if you > want to use Launchy, you will have to deal with the Unity Launcher still > being on screen, which is of course unfeasi

[Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2013-12-23 Thread Tal Liron
Really appreciate your updating us on the vision. You're mistaken about the modularity of Unity7: it's impossible right now pick and chose components. Unity7 is an either-or affair: if you want to use Launchy, you will have to deal with the Unity Launcher still being on screen, which is of course

Re: [Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2013-12-23 Thread Mark Shuttleworth
Merry solstice, folks! Since we're into festive season spirit I'll take time again to express what I think is the real challenge: we have built a converged UI across phone, tablet and desktop. If you're running Unity7 (i.e. the standard desktop in 14.04) you're running code which only expresses the

[Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2013-12-21 Thread Rickard
@Mark Shuttleworth As stated before I would fund this change with £££ of allowing a Appearance setting that is optional (so, does not affect default approach) to allow the Launcher bar to be placed at the bottom of the screen or any side in fact. Please cost this change and we the community shal

[Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2013-03-25 Thread Paulo Fino
Dear Mark, Can there be a 180 degree switch? Moving most of what's on the left to the right (launcher, Ubuntu button, window controls) and vice-versa? Ubuntu and Unity are the result of an amazing effort millions of people have accompanied and contributed to over all these years. My deepest resp

Re: [Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2013-03-20 Thread elian
I still think that there is a market for a user friendly linux desktop AS WELL AS a market for a user friendly OS on portable/consumer devices, I don't blame Canonical for trying to make a profit to stay in business and trying to position for what it thinks will be the "next big thing". In a lot o

[Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2013-03-19 Thread Tal Liron
@Adam You make some strange arguments here. FOSS philosophy has nothing to do with customization. It's about providing access to the source code. The Unity project is 100% FOSS (GPL/LGPLv3). Ubuntu's goals might be different from yours. You might want to have a desktop perfectly configured for y

Re: [Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2013-03-19 Thread Adam Porter
On Wed, Feb 20, 2013 at 8:16 PM, Mark Shuttleworth <668...@bugs.launchpad.net> wrote: > On 02/20/2013 04:52 PM, Adam Porter wrote: >> On Wed, Feb 20, 2013 at 12:08 AM, Mark Shuttleworth >> <668...@bugs.launchpad.net> wrote: >>> if the feature was really that important, someone would have >>> steppe

[Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2013-03-04 Thread Derrick Gorman
Created an Account just to comment. I want to say, which I'm sure hasn't already been said before, but I want to express my concern for this "vision" that ubuntu has where it's abandoning it's following for a fixed/static image that is "easier" for developers. I am very disappointed in Ubuntu. I'

Re: [Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2013-02-20 Thread Mark Shuttleworth
On 02/20/2013 04:52 PM, Adam Porter wrote: > On Wed, Feb 20, 2013 at 12:08 AM, Mark Shuttleworth > <668...@bugs.launchpad.net> wrote: >> if the feature was really that important, someone would have >> stepped up to do it *properly*. > "Properly" as defined by you. You set the bar wherever you want

Re: [Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2013-02-20 Thread Adam Porter
On Wed, Feb 20, 2013 at 12:08 AM, Mark Shuttleworth <668...@bugs.launchpad.net> wrote: > if the feature was really that important, someone would have > stepped up to do it *properly*. "Properly" as defined by you. You set the bar wherever you want, and if someone doesn't jump high enough, it's no

[Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2013-02-20 Thread Tal Liron
Pavel Golikov (Paullo) worked hard and created a patch. His code is still available here: https://code.launchpad.net/~paullo612/unity/unityshell-rotated As to whether it was not good enough quality to be merged into Unity, well, nothing about that was updated in this bug. There may have been per

[Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2013-02-20 Thread robert shearer
"If you look back over the long history of the bug, you'll see that we're quite open to landing code which implements launcher movement. Mark" So post #3 on this thread, (reproduced here below), is "quite open"...??? If multiple 'won't s' is open i would hate to see what closed looks like. " I th

Re: [Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2013-02-19 Thread Mark Shuttleworth
If you look back over the long history of the bug, you'll see that we're quite open to landing code which implements launcher movement. However, it needs to: * address the hard problems that raises (i.e. it needs to work properly for everyone, not just in a hacky way for some people) * be well w

[Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2013-02-19 Thread Tal Liron
"Now it's clear that instead of being transparent the whole time and just telling the community why decisions were being made, we were fed vague explanations that made us feel disrespected and excluded from the process." -- The Community (well, me speaking for it... ;) Mark, nice of you to chime i

Re: [Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2013-02-19 Thread Mark Shuttleworth
You missed one: "Now it's clear how the launcher being on the left works across phone, tablet, PC and TV" - Mark Shuttleworth, 2013-02-19 ;) -- You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Bugs, which is subscribed to Ubuntu. https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/668415 Tit

[Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2013-02-19 Thread DissidentRage
"I'm afraid that won't work with our broader design goals, so we won't implement that. We want the launcher always close to the Ubuntu button." - Mark Shuttleworth, 2010-10-30 "We should not inflict bad ideas on our users just because we’re curious or arrogant or stubborn or proud." - Mark Shutt

[Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2013-02-16 Thread quequotion
>>I'm afraid that won't work with our broader design goals, so we won't >>implement that. We want the launcher always close to the Ubuntu button. I disagree. Why couldn't the Ubuntu button be as mobile as the launcher? Is it not part of the launcher? At the very least Unity needs left and righ

[Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2013-01-28 Thread obligat
Dear Mark Shuttleworth! Launcher is on the bad side. I mean the window decorations, the dash, the launcher (with ubuntu-logo, with dash-button, in current, but mirrored form) can be horizontal mirrored to the right side without bugs? In its current form is useless and uncomfortable to work acro

[Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2013-01-25 Thread Neil
After using unity since it's release (Not at first) I have to say I still don't like it, not 1 little bit. The way I have gotten around the "problem" is to make unity launcher small and auto hide and stalled CairoDock. It keeps it hidden and can still be used when needed, makes a good second lau

[Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2013-01-25 Thread Robin Nilsson
Please fix this! I like Ubuntu but these "decisions" are just as stupid as the answers to why it won't be fixed. And no, I don't accept the "If you don't like it, don't use it"-answer. -- You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Bugs, which is subscribed to Ubuntu. h

[Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2013-01-17 Thread WhatTheTech
Hi there, I'm rather new to Ubuntu, having only installed it two days ago on a Samsung Chromebook. At first, I wasn't sure about it - coming from using macs for many years it felt mildly familiar, but just not quite there. After some customization (moving to the radiance theme, adding a brightness

[Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2013-01-16 Thread jim davies
Add me to the many who want this bug fixed. Putting personal design goals or "vision" over user choice appears childish & counterproductive. Maximizing user choice should always be Job One for ANY computer OS, open-source or otherwise. Concerns over difficulty for left-handed users or wasted scree

[Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2013-01-08 Thread Adam Porter
And you know what, if I hear one more person talk about "usability studies" or "user testing" or research, I think I will throw up. We all know what Mark Twain said about statistics. Here we are, real people, reporting real problems, but we aren't relevant, because we aren't a statistic. I'd lik

[Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2013-01-08 Thread Adam Porter
Chalk another one up for the Ubuntu Hall of Shame. Absolute power corrupts absolutely. The handwriting is on the wall. Debian keeps chugging along. -- You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Bugs, which is subscribed to Ubuntu. https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/668415

[Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2013-01-02 Thread Eduard Gotwig
I just want to express how angry I am on you Mark, and your Designers, to just remove these functions, so users can't move it anymore. -- You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Bugs, which is subscribed to Ubuntu. https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/668415 Title: Mov

Re: [Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2012-12-10 Thread elian
Yes well there's that, but also how the gnome 3 team had also stopped listening to users -gnome had a perfectly usable desktop - the project succeeded...I guess they must've got bored..what is Ubuntu to do as a downstream consumer of the technology? After using Windows 8 I can see why ubuntu team

[Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2012-12-10 Thread flyingfisch
@Rickard: I almost feel it would be better to fork the Ubuntu project and make Unity more customizable than ever. It seems like the Ubuntu team has stopped listening to users. -- You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Bugs, which is subscribed to Ubuntu. https://bu

Re: [Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2012-11-01 Thread elian
My main office PC with an 8X AGP GeForce 5200 can no longer run Ubuntu as of 12.10. I actually started using 12.04 and used a combination of a Unity with Autohide turned on and minimum sensitivity + CairoDock GL - when I wanted the Unity menu I just pressed the "SUPER" key, otherwise I used the Ca

[Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2012-11-01 Thread Rickard
@Mark Shuttleworth I agree with having it on the left as default. We need a standard somewhere :) I do not agree that we cannot have it as a user selected option from the Appearance menu (just like the icon re-sizer that you eventually succumbed too but did not appear in the original unity) as a

[Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2012-07-30 Thread Jon Hanna
Ironically, my finding the design decision to have the launcher on the left in Ubuntu encouraged me to move the taskbar on my Windows install there too (something I'd tried before with a smaller screened laptop that had 1280*800 as its native resolution, and quickly undid). It works great on a 1600

[Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2012-06-18 Thread Axel Napolitano
@Tal Liron I agree with you. Forking is not really a good solution to address such kind of problems. In this case simply because of the fact, that it is not official canonical software and therefore not part of the canonical maintained packages. Anyhow it was a matter of time until someone decides

[Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2012-06-18 Thread Tal Liron
@Axel Napolitano I think this plea from you is the most succinct summary we've seen of the attitude problem: "I hope that canonical can be a bit less dogmatic and a bit more pragmatic." A quick update: Issac Joseph has created a project called "Unity Revamped" which seems to address some of thes

[Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2012-06-18 Thread Axel Napolitano
Cite from Mark Shuttleworth: "I think the report actually meant that the launcher should be movable to other edges of the screen. I'm afraid that won't work with our broader design goals, so we won't implement that. We want the launcher always close to the Ubuntu button." @Mark Shuttleworth The

[Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2012-06-13 Thread IKT
" they seem to be doing quite a good job in many cases" They're not, the windows ui is HORRIBLE, take a look a the control panel for that mess, have you ever had to actually support people doing things with it? "and are popular for a reason." That's a fallacy, known as argumtum ad populum, by th

[Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2012-06-13 Thread Magnes
@IKT - why? they seem to be doing quite a good job in many cases and are popular for a reason. Throwing away opinions because they mention some company you don't like is a no no - in my opinion. -- You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Bugs, which is subscribed to

[Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2012-06-12 Thread IKT
"Even friggn micorsoft allows" quoting microsoft on user interface design is a no no. -- You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Bugs, which is subscribed to Ubuntu. https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/668415 Title: Movement of Unity launcher To manage notifications

[Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2012-06-08 Thread Vanderhoth
Why has this not been resolved yet? Having the unity launcher on the left is unacceptable in multiple situations and saying "won't fix" without providing a very good clear reason beyond "It doesn't fit in our border design goals" is unacceptable. What design goal could possibly warrant not being a

[Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2012-05-26 Thread Kevin Seifert
Perhaps this bug report doesn't describe a technical problem, as much as it points to what politicians might call a "messaging" issue. Some people love the old interface and thought it was perfect. That means it's impossible to change it, because there's no way to improve on perfection. Two po

[Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2012-05-25 Thread Yury
This is quite annoying when you work on a monitor with a "portrait" orientation. -- You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Bugs, which is subscribed to Ubuntu. https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/668415 Title: Movement of Unity launcher To manage notifications about

[Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2012-04-27 Thread Tal Liron
So, with Unity 5 officially out with Ubuntu 12.04, I thought I'd test its multi-monitor support. The good news is that it is no longer totally broken. The ability to put a Launcher on each monitor *is* a solution. The option to have the Launcher only on the primary monitor (called "laptop" mode, f

[Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2012-04-26 Thread Gustavo Pinto
If the launcher is not to be moved, I can envision a few other ways of resolving the issue of highly annoying accidental invocations: 1) Go back to using the corner to activate the launcher. Given how a few icons will be on the lower part of the screen, having to travel to the top and then to the

[Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2012-04-24 Thread David Perkinson
Here is something that might help some left-handers: install the CompizConfig settings manager, and set the launch reveal to one of the corners, say the top-left. -- You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Bugs, which is subscribed to Ubuntu. https://bugs.launchpad.n

[Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2012-04-23 Thread David Perkinson
I use my Lenovo tablet computer for teaching and for presentations at conferences. I am left-handed, and especially with the tablet, it is useful to have scroll bars on the left. However, this means that often when reaching for the scroll bar the launcher comes out of hiding, which is quite annoy

[Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2012-04-20 Thread Jon Skarpeteig
Given the 290 comments before me, I realize I won't be adding anything new, but I wanted to share my frustration anyway, just to point out how annoying this is to a lot of people by pure volume of complaints. I have been using the unity-rotate plugin a while, but it has severe limitations, such as

Re: [Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2012-04-05 Thread Maarten Kossen
@Renato Silva: what you describe has nothing to do with the movement of the Unity launcher. What you describe has got to do with launcher sensitivity, something you will be able to control via System Settings in 12.04 LTS. Moving the launcher would solve the problem, naturally, but isn't the ca

[Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2012-04-02 Thread Renato Silva
"Won't Fix" a simple positioning setting to fix ridiculous wrong clicks when you try to access application items on the left? There are usually more clickable items on the left (back button in Firefox, window buttons, first application menu etc) than on the right or bottom. It's just sane to allow

[Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2012-03-24 Thread Lee
I dislike the left sidebar but have to tolerate this because the launcher is unmovable by your initial design. The reason you gave me is: 1)The integration between the Top Bar, the BFB , the Dash and Launcher. 2)At the moment it's important that Unity get stabilisation work during the next

[Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2012-03-18 Thread Tibi
this is wrong mister mark.. if you are so sure that you are a visionaire, let the ppl the option to CHOOSE either your way, or their way..what do you have to loose anyway.. its not like you are not a genius and everybody would choose the layout you try to impose anyway... this is pure arrogance, an

[Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2012-01-16 Thread Andy Brown
Any chance of this being reopened, please? I have become very productive over the years using a dock located at the bottom of the screen both in Ubuntu and OSX. With Unity the screen just feels far too heavily 'weighted' towards the left which results in my mouse behaviour feeling 'unnateral' whe

[Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2012-01-09 Thread Tal Liron
@David I've seen enough free software projects come and go in my day such that 1) I have a good sense of when leadership problems are endemic, as in Unity, and 2) I have an appreciation for the messy diversity of people involved in any given project. The combination of these two contradictory fact

[Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2012-01-09 Thread David Gómez
@Tal Yep, too much time discussing (although i won't call discussing when most of the comments are from the stubborn "small group" and not from Canonical), time which could have been spent testing Pavel Golikov patch. Would have been included, i'd be just adding my two cents testing the patch to f

[Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2012-01-09 Thread el_gallo_azul
Wow that's a long thread. I would like to support the request to make the Launchpad moveable - I wish to place it at the bottom of the screen. The reason is I was smashed up in a traffic accident over two years ago, and as a result my eyesight and hand coordination don't work like they useta. The

[Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2012-01-09 Thread Tal Liron
@SRoesgen Wow. And to think that all this work (on both sides) could have have been spent on: 1) working with Pavel Golikov to get his patch accepted, with it being released on the dev PPA; and 2) testing and reporting real bugs by the community to get the movable Launcher feature to full quality.

[Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2012-01-09 Thread SRoesgen
@Danillo (and @all who want a summary of the whole discussion) Concerning "sheer, childish stubborness" 1) comment 2# told us already the bug "won't fix" -> there was no explanation besides saying it is a design decision 2) comment #13 stated they will explore an RTL decision (after it was poin

[Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2012-01-09 Thread Tal Liron
@Danillo What about respect for us? What about the trouble, time and effort so many members of the community have put into commenting on this bug report? What about the years of effort we put into promoting Ubuntu in our workspaces, and among families and friends? Nobody has come out to thank us.

[Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2012-01-09 Thread Danillo
I'm sorry, but talking about "sheer, childish stubborness" after a member of the design team took the trouble of answering our questions and giving us the reasons for the current state of the launcher is IMO dishonest and just plain offensive and disrespectful both to the design team as to the user

[Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2012-01-08 Thread SRoesgen
@Tal Liron >It's just sheer, childish stubborness at this point. All of the reasons >provided for the "won't fix" on this bug (and let's remember: those kept >changing) turned out to be excuses. They decided not to make the Launcher >movable, and they're going to stick to that decision whatever

[Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2012-01-07 Thread Tal Liron
@SRoesgen Sigh. I said it before, but it's worth repeating (isn't this whole bug report about repitition? from both sides?) -- it's astounding that after all the hand-wringing about the lack of manpower available to enable a movable Launcher, the proposed solution for multi-monitor support is an o

[Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2012-01-07 Thread SRoesgen
@Tal Liron >he remaining option is that I break the walls in my office and staple my desk >to the ceiling so that I can make sure that the leftmost monitor is my primary >monitor, because that's the only configuration Unity supports. :/ Funny as your comment is, I am afraid that it is not true a

[Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2012-01-07 Thread Tal Liron
In my ongoing quest to find a solution for the brokenness Unity causes in my multimonitor setup -- without throwing *all* of Unity out the window -- I've been exploring LXDE and liking it a whole lot. For those who would like to try it, I wrote a guide: http://ubuntuforums.org/showthread.php?p=11

[Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2012-01-04 Thread flyingfisch
@Danillo: I get your point. Now that I understand that the current version of unity is more aimed at beginners I think that Unity is pretty good (my mom who is very technologically-challenged loves it). It just lacks some usability features. So maybe there can be a power version of unity that still

[Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2012-01-02 Thread SRoesgen
>If you want to prove your point, the best way to do this is to do usability >tests, and not with the Gnome-2 power users, but with >the simple people that >Ubuntu is aiming for. Get two Ubuntu computers, one with the default >left-launcher and another with >the bottom-launcher from Unity plugin

[Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2012-01-02 Thread Danillo
I want to thank you John Lea for your attention and your patience in answering questions. It's really appreciated! People complain about the design team, but more often than not users act almost like bosses to them. Do you think that Unity bashing will make anyone more likely to listen to you if y

[Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2011-12-31 Thread Marek Paśnikowski
Mr Mark Shuttleworth, and those of you, who decided upon the shape of Unity. I don't care about Ubuntu anymore. The reason I write this last letter to you is because I want you to see how shallow your design decisions were. You tell continuously about lack of resources. You also want to bring the

[Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2011-12-29 Thread flyingfisch
** Tags added: unity -- You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Bugs, which is subscribed to Ubuntu. https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/668415 Title: Movement of Unity launcher To manage notifications about this bug go to: https://bugs.launchpad.net/ayatana-design/+

[Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2011-12-26 Thread flyingfisch
Same here. I LOVE those big icons. That's why I am upset when the Ubuntu dev team goes directly against the wishes of the community. I really like unity and I don't want to leave it if I don't have to. Of course its going to introduce more bugs!!! EVERY change one makes to a website, program, or OS

[Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2011-12-25 Thread sangmin
I think my comment could be ignored because many people already said them. But I cannot resist myself to say some complaints. In the first place, I actually liked Unity showing a launchpad with big icons and Dash Home interface. I still like it. Then I wanted it to be on the bottom. Then,,, huh...

Re: [Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2011-12-24 Thread Fernando
@SRoesgen Do you think that Unity movable launcher will ever be solved? That is why I had proposed another option for those people who can't install Unity on their production machines because of the launcher. If you think it is a minor problem for you, I have lots of testimonials that says that Uni

[Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2011-12-24 Thread Tal Liron
@SRoesgen With 269 comments (mine is 270!), *every* aspect of this bug has been mentioned already, at least once. :) I suggest we all give it a rest. It is very clear that this bug report is not helping one bit. Mark has not budged since comment 2, and in the plans for 12.04 we see that the Unity

[Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2011-12-24 Thread SRoesgen
@Tal Liron I already mentioned that strange new Multi Monitor concept before. But up to now, there has not been any comment/answer to that. @Fernando As I said before I was happy that all of the last comments were not about leaving Unity behind but instead focused on bringing forward valid argu

Re: [Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2011-12-23 Thread Fernando
I think that people unhappy with these new user interfaces, should opt to try Xubuntu. I've made this decision after trying Unity and seeing that isn't an user interface that helps users be productive. It gets in the way of everybody that tries to use it. After many complaints, and discussions, I s

[Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2011-12-23 Thread Tal Liron
I found some information about planned multi-monitor support in 12.04, and how it would impact the Launcher. The bottom line is that the Unity team is dead serious about not making the Launcher movable. So, how are they going to solve the current bugs? By having the Launcher on all monitors! The i

[Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2011-12-22 Thread Tal Liron
There are two "elephants in the room" for this bug. The first is the poor job the Unity team is doing in explaining their position to the community, for which I opened this bug: https://bugs.launchpad.net/unity/+bug/882274 The second is the inconsistency and implausibility of the explanation. Th

[Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2011-12-22 Thread flyingfisch
JohnLea wrote: >@flyingfisch; I posted the reasons we are not able to add Launcher movement >atm in comment #226. Basically implementing this >change so that it works >correctly with all the other Unity elements in a bug free manner is *a lot* of >work from both a design and >development standpo

Re: [Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2011-12-22 Thread Maarten Kossen
@SRoesgen: I think the left border will be the most unlikely place for a false positive, even when flipping the pages of a book. If it were up to me, I would require the finger to almost hit the left-most line of pixels. That would work well, I think. On 12/22/2011 02:00 PM, SRoesgen wrote: > @

[Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2011-12-22 Thread SRoesgen
@Maarten Kossen Swiping into any direction would be a nice and handy metaphor for turning the pages of a book. But instead of this the swiping will reveal the launcher which people might not even know exists because it is auto-hidden on a touch screen? Well, nicely done. For me this sound not v

Re: [Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2011-12-22 Thread Maarten Kossen
@Magnes: not if it's on the left of the screen and you swipe right-to-left to reveal it (just like moving your mouse to the right). At least, that's what I remember having seen in some plan. On 12/22/2011 10:22 AM, Magnes wrote: > Hiding launcher on a touchscreen? That would be pretty hard to us

[Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2011-12-22 Thread Adam Funk
realn wrote: > How will we be skipping to the next track on our future > laptops? By shaking them, too ? No, that's for rebooting: http://dilbert.com/strips/comic/1995-04-03/ -- You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Bugs, which is subscribed to Ubuntu. https://b

[Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2011-12-22 Thread Magnes
Hiding launcher on a touchscreen? That would be pretty hard to use. -- You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Bugs, which is subscribed to Ubuntu. https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/668415 Title: Movement of Unity launcher To manage notifications about this bug go

Re: [Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2011-12-22 Thread Maarten Kossen
@Magnes: your arguments are quite invalid when it's a hiding launcher. On 12/22/2011 08:55 AM, Magnes wrote: > Tablets, phones and some LCDs with pivot have portrait mode in which > launcher on the left takes too much space and is ridiculously high. > Tablets especially are often used in this mode

[Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2011-12-22 Thread Magnes
Tablets, phones and some LCDs with pivot have portrait mode in which launcher on the left takes too much space and is ridiculously high. Tablets especially are often used in this mode. So if you want to make Unity for tablets you need to make it movable anyway. (and on phones it would have to be on

Re: [Bug 668415] Re: Movement of Unity launcher

2011-12-21 Thread Maarten Kossen
@realn: Well, every major OS out there (Windows, Mac OS X, Ubuntu) are moving to such a situation. See the new launchpad (or whatever it's called) on Mac OS X that is much like the springboard on iOS and the new Windows Phone OS (or whatever it's called) and Windows 8 with their similar setup.

  1   2   3   4   >