Re: Install Wizard 'Looks Too Complicated

2009-12-07 Thread Chris Jones
> Date: Tue, 1 Dec 2009 21:16:30 +1100 > From: Kyle Amadio > Subject: Re: Install Wizard 'Looks Too Complicated' > To: ubuntu-devel-discuss@lists.ubuntu.com > Message-ID: > <24b8dd680912010216j2d86f731v1bc17aa030913...@mail.gmail.com> > Content-

Re: Install Wizard 'Looks Too Complicated'

2009-12-04 Thread Shentino
For what it's worth, my vote is that gparted should be included as part of the installer. Everything else though seems fine. On Tue, Dec 1, 2009 at 2:16 AM, Kyle Amadio wrote: > Just for FUN I did a Fedora 12 install of Gnome and KDE. > > Must say that Ubuntu is dead simple and fast. Fedora was

Re: Install Wizard 'Looks Too Complicated'

2009-12-04 Thread Kyle Amadio
Just for FUN I did a Fedora 12 install of Gnome and KDE. Must say that Ubuntu is dead simple and fast. Fedora was "nearly easy" but for some reason it just does not flow like Ubuntu's does. Leave the installer alone it is simple and fast. -- Regards Kyle Amadio International TV Shopping System

Re: Install Wizard 'Looks Too Complicated'

2009-12-01 Thread Caleb Marcus
In fact, the Ubuntu installer used to use an embedded GParted editing box. I much preferred that to the current setup. On Tue, Dec 1, 2009 at 1:29 PM, Shentino wrote: > One of my pet peeves with the installer is how long it takes to detect the > partitioning...and redetect it every...single...op

Re: Install Wizard 'Looks Too Complicated'

2009-12-01 Thread Caleb Marcus
I'm not sure if I like this proposal -- I believe splitting things up into small steps makes it easier on the user. For one thing, the first questions we ask are the language and the keyboard layout, which are essential to the user's understanding of the rest of the installer. Many users won't set

Re: Install Wizard 'Looks Too Complicated'

2009-12-01 Thread Shentino
One of my pet peeves with the installer is how long it takes to detect the partitioning...and redetect it every...single...operation...so...slowly. My suggestion is that GParted be used to handle this. In fact I often use that to do the partitioning BEFORE I do the installer because I don't want

Re: Install Wizard 'Looks Too Complicated'

2009-12-01 Thread John McCabe-Dansted
On Wed, Dec 2, 2009 at 12:06 AM, Daniel Hollocher wrote: > password.  Any sort of password automation would simplify the > situation for a few people at the expense of making it more > complicated for the rest of us.  The level of encryption doesn't seem > to matter. OK. The issue where we want t

Re: Install Wizard 'Looks Too Complicated'

2009-12-01 Thread Evan
I agree with Daniel that combining all the screens goes to far, but I sort of like the concept behind Ryan's single-screen dialogue. How about something like this: Screen 1: Welcome Brief welcome message. Language - From what they chose at boot, dropdown list. Keyboard - Autodetected as it already

Re: Install Wizard 'Looks Too Complicated'

2009-12-01 Thread Daniel Hollocher
I think the issue is that you need to have the user enter the password anyway, for the users sake. The user needs to know and remember the password, which is why the installer asks twice already. The original idea was to use the windows password so the user doesn't need to be asked during install

Re: Install Wizard 'Looks Too Complicated'

2009-12-01 Thread John McCabe-Dansted
On Tue, Dec 1, 2009 at 5:27 AM, James Westby wrote: >  * It's a feature of dubious value to begin with. After it had taken some >    time doing its thing you would need to have the user type in the password >    anyway to confirm (you can't assume, and you can't really show it to them). Quite. "C

Re: Install Wizard 'Looks Too Complicated'

2009-12-01 Thread Ryan Dwyer
I'm picturing a single dialog with an overview of the current values and options to change them. The fields I've marked as buttons would have the current value as the button text so the user only has to click the value to change it. Language: [English (US)] (this would be a droplist) Location: [Ne

Re: Install Wizard 'Looks Too Complicated'

2009-12-01 Thread Mohammed Bassit
On Mon, 2009-11-30 at 21:54 -0400, Derek Broughton wrote: > James Westby wrote: > > > On Mon Nov 30 13:47:34 -0500 2009 John Moser wrote: > >> List some not-silly reasons. > > > > You're serious? Ok. > > > > * Takes a long time to crack any password that's not in the dictionary > > and > >

Re: Install Wizard 'Looks Too Complicated'

2009-11-30 Thread Derek Broughton
James Westby wrote: > On Mon Nov 30 13:47:34 -0500 2009 John Moser wrote: >> List some not-silly reasons. > > You're serious? Ok. > > * Takes a long time to crack any password that's not in the dictionary > and > more than a few characters long. > * Rainbow tables would be too large to

Re: Install Wizard 'Looks Too Complicated'

2009-11-30 Thread John Moser
Matt Wheeler wrote: > 2009/11/30 John Moser : > > Mainly just the bad press that Ubuntu would get as a result. Can you > imagine the headlines there would be? "Ubuntu operating system hacks > Windows computers" Agreed on marketing, though again I tend to not care. It doesn't send information

Re: Install Wizard 'Looks Too Complicated'

2009-11-30 Thread Matt Wheeler
2009/11/30 James Westby : > On Mon Nov 30 13:47:34 -0500 2009 John Moser wrote: >> List some not-silly reasons. > > You're serious? Ok. > >  * Takes a long time to crack any password that's not in the dictionary and >    more than a few characters long. >  * Rainbow tables would be too large to fit

Re: Install Wizard 'Looks Too Complicated'

2009-11-30 Thread James Westby
On Mon Nov 30 13:47:34 -0500 2009 John Moser wrote: > List some not-silly reasons. You're serious? Ok. * Takes a long time to crack any password that's not in the dictionary and more than a few characters long. * Rainbow tables would be too large to fit on the CD. * We can't know up-fro

Re: Install Wizard 'Looks Too Complicated'

2009-11-30 Thread Matt Wheeler
2009/11/30 John Moser : > List some not-silly reasons.  "Because people could use it for > theoretical/practicable attacks" is not a reason, because 1) you could > decline to reveal the password (but allow verification); and 2) there > are other tools for this that are just as accessable. Mainly j

Re: Install Wizard 'Looks Too Complicated'

2009-11-30 Thread John Moser
On Mon, Nov 30, 2009 at 2:36 PM, Shentino wrote: > With regards to cracking tools being bad, I imagine they do come in handy > during security audits. > If there's going to be hacking tools out there anyway, the good guys may as > well have them too, since you can't really take them away from the

Re: Install Wizard 'Looks Too Complicated'

2009-11-30 Thread Shentino
With regards to cracking tools being bad, I imagine they do come in handy during security audits. If there's going to be hacking tools out there anyway, the good guys may as well have them too, since you can't really take them away from the bad guys. On Mon, Nov 30, 2009 at 10:47 AM, John Moser

Re: Install Wizard 'Looks Too Complicated'

2009-11-30 Thread John Moser
On Mon, Nov 30, 2009 at 12:55 PM, Matt Wheeler wrote: > 2009/11/30 Jan Claeys : >> Op zondag 29-11-2009 om 00:47 uur [tijdzone +0800], schreef John >> McCabe-Dansted: >>> There are also algorithms for extracting the password from XP as >>> well... >> >> XP passwords are compared to hashes, and you

Re: Install Wizard 'Looks Too Complicated'

2009-11-30 Thread Matt Wheeler
2009/11/30 Jan Claeys : > Op zondag 29-11-2009 om 00:47 uur [tijdzone +0800], schreef John > McCabe-Dansted: >> There are also algorithms for extracting the password from XP as >> well... > > XP passwords are compared to hashes, and you can't extract the password > from a hash. There are brute-for

Re: Install Wizard 'Looks Too Complicated'

2009-11-30 Thread Jan Claeys
Op zondag 29-11-2009 om 00:47 uur [tijdzone +0800], schreef John McCabe-Dansted: > There are also algorithms for extracting the password from XP as > well... XP passwords are compared to hashes, and you can't extract the password from a hash. -- Jan Claeys -- Ubuntu-devel-discuss mailing lis

Re: Install Wizard 'Looks Too Complicated'

2009-11-28 Thread John McCabe-Dansted
On Sat, Nov 28, 2009 at 6:52 PM, Conrad Knauer wrote: ... > If the user is connected to the internet, might it be possible to > guess their physical location (e.g. for time zone) by IP address? > (http://www.tracemyip.org/ seems to be able to :) as most people will > want to install their systems

Install Wizard 'Looks Too Complicated'

2009-11-28 Thread Conrad Knauer
I just read the article "The Un-Scary Screwdriver" on http://www.gnomejournal.org/article/88/the-un-scary-screwdriver (via http://www.groklaw.net/newsitems.php) and the first part jumped out at me: --- One early spring day as we were walking home from the bakery on the corner, we passed by a neigh