Re: Prevent people from updates with critical components

2010-05-31 Thread Joachim Langenbach
On Sunday 30 May 2010 12:27:21 C. Gatzemeier wrote: > Of course this would expose existing issues to a broader audience up > front, but that sounds like a good thing (as "release often" also > somehow means "expose often".), not only for users not unnecessarily > running into issues, but also for

Re: Prevent people from updates with critical components

2010-05-30 Thread C. Gatzemeier
Hi Joachim, let me just assure you that IMHO appropriate warnings before critical updates could prevent a lot of headaches. As the release notes are tracked/composed from launchpad entries, maybe the system could be made generic enough to work on top of bug trackers' tagging facilities (debian BT

Re: Prevent people from updates with critical components

2010-05-29 Thread Evan
On Saturday, May 29, 2010, Joachim Langenbach wrote: > Yes, that's totally correct! > > And from my point of view, really many people don't read release notes This is very true. I don't know what percent of users currently read the release notes before upgrading, but I know that a very tiny perce

Re: Prevent people from updates with critical components

2010-05-29 Thread Joachim Langenbach
Yes, that's totally correct! And from my point of view, really many people don't read release notes (including me). This are espacially new and unfamiliar users, but also other users, who think, if they release an update, it would work on most machines and of course every user thinks, that he o

Re: Prevent people from updates with critical components

2010-05-29 Thread Joao Pinto
Hello, if I understood your suggestion, you are proposing that the upgrade process should check for known issues and warn before allowing the user to proceed ? Critical issues with the upgrade process are expected to have some workaround implemented at the upgrade process level, non critical issue

Re: Prevent people from updates with critical components

2010-05-29 Thread Joachim Langenbach
Good Morning again, I'm a bit stunning, that nobody seems to be interested in such a thing. Im not afraid of coding it myself, even if I have not much time for that right now, but I think even in that case, a discussion about the preferred way is important. I'm wondering about the fact of lac

Prevent people from updates with critical components

2010-05-25 Thread Joachim Langenbach
Good Morning all! After last release update and time consuming error repairing, I've think about a system, to inform users with critical system components that an update is not recommended at their machine. My thought was a system like the following one: 1. Provide a list of kown critical comp