Re: [DISCUSS] discontinue 4-x HBase 1.0 releases?

2015-11-17 Thread Nick Dimiduk
FYI, HBase has recently decided to discontinue the 1.0.x line. I believe the pending 1.0.3 release is expected to be the last. On Wed, Sep 30, 2015 at 10:36 AM, James Taylor wrote: > Thanks for letting us know, Anirudha & James. Makes sense to keep the 1.0 > branch going in light of this hard de

Re: [DISCUSS] discontinue 4-x HBase 1.0 releases?

2015-11-17 Thread Andrew Purtell
That's my understanding as well. On Tue, Nov 17, 2015 at 10:56 AM, Nick Dimiduk wrote: > FYI, HBase has recently decided to discontinue the 1.0.x line. I believe > the pending 1.0.3 release is expected to be the last. > > On Wed, Sep 30, 2015 at 10:36 AM, James Taylor > wrote: > >> Thanks for

Re: [DISCUSS] discontinue 4-x HBase 1.0 releases?

2015-11-17 Thread James Taylor
Until the CDH distro moves off of 1.0, we'll likely want to continue releasing Phoenix on top of it (even if there are no further HBase 1.0 releases). That's assuming our CDH Phoenix users want the new features and bug fixes we're developing. On Tue, Nov 17, 2015 at 6:28 PM, Andrew Purtell wrote:

Re: [DISCUSS] discontinue 4-x HBase 1.0 releases?

2015-11-17 Thread Stephen Wilcoxon
Agreed. Until Cloudera moves CDH off Hbase 1.0, Phoenix should continue to support it. On Tue, Nov 17, 2015 at 8:31 PM, James Taylor wrote: > Until the CDH distro moves off of 1.0, we'll likely want to continue > releasing Phoenix on top of it (even if there are no further HBase 1.0 > releases)

Re: [DISCUSS] discontinue 4-x HBase 1.0 releases?

2015-11-17 Thread Andrew Purtell
Shouldn't be a big challenge, the friction for porting back patches from a 1.1 based tree to a 1.0 based tree will be low. The exception will be anything touching Region/HRegion but those differences can be mostly handled with simple substitution. For CDH users, note there's also https://github.co

Re: [DISCUSS] discontinue 4-x HBase 1.0 releases?

2015-09-18 Thread James Taylor
+user list Please let us know if you're counting on HBase 1.0 support given that we have HBase 1.1 support. Thanks, James On Fri, Sep 18, 2015 at 4:11 PM, Nick Dimiduk wrote: > Seems like a better question for the users mailing list. Probably it > depends on where the vendors are going, if the

Re: [DISCUSS] discontinue 4-x HBase 1.0 releases?

2015-09-18 Thread Jesse Yates
Along the same lines as HBase, it seems fine to discontinue old code lines until such point as there is someone willing to maintain a given line - a new RM. Essentially, its the same as an RM stepping down from managing a release and no releases happening until someone cares enough to make a new on

Re: [DISCUSS] discontinue 4-x HBase 1.0 releases?

2015-09-18 Thread anil gupta
We use HDP at TrueCar. Currently, it ships with HBase1.1 And previous version of HDP shipped with HBase0.98. On Fri, Sep 18, 2015 at 5:53 PM, James Taylor wrote: > +user list > > Please let us know if you're counting on HBase 1.0 support given that we > have HBase 1.1 support. > > Thanks, > Jame

Re: [DISCUSS] discontinue 4-x HBase 1.0 releases?

2015-09-18 Thread James Heather
We're using CDH5, which runs HBase 1.0. I think it would kill the whole Phoenix project for us if there were no 1.0 support. James On 19/09/15 01:53, James Taylor wrote: +user list Please let us know if you're counting on HBase 1.0 support given that we have HBase 1.1 support. Thanks, Ja

Re: [DISCUSS] discontinue 4-x HBase 1.0 releases?

2015-09-21 Thread Anirudha Khanna
Same for us, we are also using CDH5 and it would be a big setback if HBase-1.0 support is stopped by the community. Anirudha On Sat, Sep 19, 2015 at 12:01 PM, James Heather wrote: > We're using CDH5, which runs HBase 1.0. > > I think it would kill the whole Phoenix project for us if there were

Re: [DISCUSS] discontinue 4-x HBase 1.0 releases?

2015-09-30 Thread James Taylor
Thanks for letting us know, Anirudha & James. Makes sense to keep the 1.0 branch going in light of this hard dependency you have. James On Mon, Sep 21, 2015 at 10:38 PM, Anirudha Khanna wrote: > Same for us, we are also using CDH5 and it would be a big setback if > HBase-1.0 support is stop