Re: Functional Test strategies with Maven

2009-03-03 Thread Martin Höller
Hi Martijn! I'm joining this discussion a little late, but have some references to add which may help making up your mind: http://docs.codehaus.org/display/MAVENUSER/Maven+and+Integration+Testing http://www.jroller.com/carlossg/entry/functional_testing_with_maven_cargo hth, - martin On Monday

Re: RE: Re: Functional Test strategies with Maven

2009-03-02 Thread martijnverburg
- From: martijnverb...@gmail.com [mailto:martijnverb...@gmail.com] Sent: Monday, March 02, 2009 11:26 AM To: users@maven.apache.org Subject: Re: Re: Functional Test strategies with Maven Hi David, > Martijn - I've seen this done a couple of different ways. I can

RE: Re: Functional Test strategies with Maven

2009-03-02 Thread Cummings,Steven
help provide feedback for if/when integration testing is officially supported. /S -Original Message- From: martijnverb...@gmail.com [mailto:martijnverb...@gmail.com] Sent: Monday, March 02, 2009 11:26 AM To: users@maven.apache.org Subject: Re: Re: Functional Test strategies with Maven Hi

Re: Re: Functional Test strategies with Maven

2009-03-02 Thread martijnverburg
Hi David, Martijn - I've seen this done a couple of different ways. I can't say that there is any particular set of advantages/disadvantages that makes one more attractive than another. I'm sure you've already thought about these, but here they are, just the same: #1 - The functional tests

Re: Functional Test strategies with Maven

2009-03-02 Thread David C. Hicks
Martijn - I've seen this done a couple of different ways. I can't say that there is any particular set of advantages/disadvantages that makes one more attractive than another. I'm sure you've already thought about these, but here they are, just the same: #1 - The functional tests are named w

Re: Re: Re: Functional Test strategies with Maven

2009-03-02 Thread martijnverburg
Hi all, Are these functional tests invoked as jUnit / TestNG tests? I have written similar, integration type functional tests with mocks, but they were still based on jUnit / TestNG. I simply stored them in the same name>-->test-->src-->java are being used for unit tests. I differentiated betwee

Re: Re: Functional Test strategies with Maven

2009-03-02 Thread Ian Petzer
Are these functional tests invoked as jUnit / TestNG tests? I have written similar, integration type functional tests with mocks, but they were still based on jUnit / TestNG. I simply stored them in the same -->test-->src-->java are being used for unit tests. I differentated between the two sets th

Re: Functional Test strategies with Maven

2009-03-02 Thread Ian Petzer
Hi Martin, What is the reasoning beyond the separation of the functional tests? Is it because you would like to run them separately from your other unit tests? If so, have you considered using profiles to control what tests are run by Maven? If not, what goal are you trying to obtain by putting t