Re: JSF2 + Myfaces CODI2 + Myfaces Trinidad2

2011-05-17 Thread Gerhard Petracek
hi manuel, we just did a very basic test [1]. -> yes - it might be the case that the existing support module doesn't provide a workaround for it. regards, gerhard [1] https://svn.apache.org/repos/asf/myfaces/extensions/cdi/trunk/examples/jsf-playground/hello_myfaces-codi_trinidad12/ http://www.

Re: JSF2 + Myfaces CODI2 + Myfaces Trinidad2

2011-05-17 Thread Manuel Hartl
hi gerhard, > hi manuel, > > actually trinidad had to introduce special concepts and tricks to provide > different features (esp. for jsf 1.x). > it looks like at least one of them has problems with wrapped renderkits. > (in codi we are just wrapping artefacts and intercepting calls to add > func

Re: JSF2 + Myfaces CODI2 + Myfaces Trinidad2

2011-05-17 Thread Gerhard Petracek
hi manuel, actually trinidad had to introduce special concepts and tricks to provide different features (esp. for jsf 1.x). it looks like at least one of them has problems with wrapped renderkits. (in codi we are just wrapping artefacts and intercepting calls to add functionality - but we don't ch

Re: JSF2 + Myfaces CODI2 + Myfaces Trinidad2

2011-05-17 Thread Manuel Hartl
hi gerhard, > by the way - welcome to the myfaces list! thanks :) > you can file a jira-ticket (new feature) in our jira [1]. > > you can try to find a workaround for a new support module or you come up > with a solution for improving trinidad to avoid such issues at all. a good point. i asked mys

Re: JSF2 + Myfaces CODI2 + Myfaces Trinidad2

2011-05-17 Thread Gerhard Petracek
hi manuel, by the way - welcome to the myfaces list! you can file a jira-ticket (new feature) in our jira [1]. you can try to find a workaround for a new support module or you come up with a solution for improving trinidad to avoid such issues at all. regards, gerhard [1] https://issues.apache

Re: JSF2 + Myfaces CODI2 + Myfaces Trinidad2

2011-05-17 Thread Manuel Hartl
Hi Gerhard, 1) to whom should i adress the feature request? 2) as the problem seems to be the same as with codi-jsf1/trinidad1, the solution should be not portable? if i have some time this week i try to debug it. do you think it does make sense to look at the trinidad12-module and try to make it

Re: JSF2 + Myfaces CODI2 + Myfaces Trinidad2

2011-05-17 Thread Gerhard Petracek
hi manuel, if the trinidad-support module (myfaces-extcdi-trinidad12-support) doesn't work any more with trinidad2 (it used to work), please file a feature request. it would be great, if you can also debug the issue and try to find a workaround which we can use in a myfaces-extcdi-trinidad20-suppo

JSF2 + Myfaces CODI2 + Myfaces Trinidad2

2011-05-17 Thread Manuel Hartl
Hi MyFaces-CODI-Team, i try to use the following in combination: (JSF2 reference implementation) Apache Myfaces CODI-JSF2 0.9.5 Apache Myfaces Trinidad 2.0.0 1) first i got the "No RenderingContext" exception, but this was worked around with /** * Workaround for initializing the RenderingContex