Stephen A. Lawrence wrote:
> No, it makes good sense. This school of logic is thousands of years old
> and has been carefully thought out. You should not assume that you know
> better than philosophers and logicians.
>
>
> True.
>
> And that's an appeal to authority, too, by the way...
>
It
Actually it is *postlogical thinking *
http://egooutpeters.blogspot.com/2011/03/modes-of-thinking-my-taxonomy.html
Galantini is a very local authorithy, and university professors are not
necessarily experts in steam. Rossi is against the idea of measuring the
ENTHALPY of steam,(as Jed also suggest
On 11-06-17 09:31 PM, Jed Rothwell wrote:
Stephen A. Lawrence mailto:sa...@pobox.com>> wrote:
If that's not "appealing to an authority" then I don't know the
meaning of simple English sentences.
You do know the meaning of simple English sentences, but this meaning
does not apply to
Just to reiterate, Stephen A. Lawrence wrote:
> Rossi is citing actual, bona fide authorities in the relevant field such as
>> Dr. Galantini. That is a legitimate thing to do ...
>>
>
> Not with a complete lack of cited data, not in any scientific forum.
Rossi made it very clear to me that th
Stephen A. Lawrence wrote:
> If that's not "appealing to an authority" then I don't know the meaning of
> simple English sentences.
>
You do know the meaning of simple English sentences, but this meaning does
not apply to formal logic. Words and expressions in daily language often
mean somethin
On 11-06-17 06:51 PM, Jed Rothwell wrote:
Someone here said that Rossi is offering "an appeal to authority."
Strictly speaking, he is not.
Yes, he is. His evidence that the steam is dry is "So-and-so says so."
But no data is presented to back So-and-so's opinion; all we have is a
bare co
As everyone here knows, Steve Krivit wrote a report about a visit to Rossi's
factory in Bologna:
http://blog.newenergytimes.com/2011/06/16/preliminary-report-of-interviews-with-e-cat-trio-rossi-focardi-and-levi/
On one hand, I thought this report was pretty good, but on the other hand I
can well
7 matches
Mail list logo
