Re: [Vo]:Massive Rossi Claim: "97 E-Cats In Operation Right Now Across 4 Countries"

2011-04-30 Thread Jed Rothwell
Jones Beene wrote: > It must have been lost in cyberspace for a day. > > > > In any event, you have not come up with an effective response – one that > does not involve something Rossi ‘said’ … > Actually, it involves: 1. What Rossi said. 2. What Levi et al. observed on the outside of the cel

RE: [Vo]:Massive Rossi Claim: "97 E-Cats In Operation Right Now Across 4 Countries"

2011-04-30 Thread Jones Beene
Apparently you failed to notice the date of that post. Yesterday. It must have been lost in cyberspace for a day. In any event, you have not come up with an effective response - one that does not involve something Rossi 'said' . since essentially that makes it irrelevant for the obvious rea

RE: [Vo]:Massive Rossi Claim: "97 E-Cats In Operation Right Now Across 4 Countries"

2011-04-30 Thread Jones Beene
From: Jed Rothwell Jones Beene wrote: Their statement is either senile or idiotic, take your pick. Copper migration is well known, and no lucid physicist misses this point. Kullander misses it. Is he senile or stupid? > JR: I do not think that this much copper can migrate through stainless

Re: [Vo]:Massive Rossi Claim: "97 E-Cats In Operation Right Now Across 4 Countries"

2011-04-30 Thread Jed Rothwell
Jones Beene wrote: > > JR: I do not think that this much copper can migrate through stainless > steel, so I doubt that can explain the presence of the copper. > > You did read the patent application, no? > > Direct quote from Publication number: US 2011/0005506 A1 Filing date: Aug > 4, > 2009 "A

RE: [Vo]:Massive Rossi Claim: "97 E-Cats In Operation Right Now Across 4 Countries"

2011-04-30 Thread Jones Beene
From: Jed Rothwell Jones Beene wrote: Their statement is either senile or idiotic, take your pick. Copper migration is well known, and no lucid physicist misses this point. Kullander misses it. Is he senile or stupid? > JR: I do not think that this much copper can migrate through stainless stee

Re: [Vo]:Massive Rossi Claim: "97 E-Cats In Operation Right Now Across 4 Countries"

2011-04-29 Thread Jed Rothwell
Jones Beene wrote: Their statement is either senile or idiotic, take your pick. Copper migration is well known, and no lucid physicist misses this point. Kullander misses it. Is he senile or stupid? I do not think that this much copper can migrate through stainless steel, so I doubt that c

RE: [Vo]:Massive Rossi Claim: "97 E-Cats In Operation Right Now Across 4 Countries"

2011-04-29 Thread Jones Beene
From: Jed Rothwell Jones Beene wrote: I find it closer to delusional than conclusive. These two Swedes are acting more like cheer-leaders than top scientists. Kullander is 'emeritus' and could be approaching senility . . . > JR: In my opinion, such ad hominem comments are inappropriate fo

Re: [Vo]:Massive Rossi Claim: "97 E-Cats In Operation Right Now Across 4 Countries"

2011-04-29 Thread Alexander Hollins
You do not say anything about the numbers. Insulting the people without talking about the numbers is worthless, and makes you look like a troll and an imbecile. Is there something wrong with the numbers they mentioned? Can you show math saying it IS possible to do with chemical energy? Alexande

Re: [Vo]:Massive Rossi Claim: "97 E-Cats In Operation Right Now Across 4 Countries"

2011-04-29 Thread Jed Rothwell
Jones Beene wrote: I find it closer to delusional than conclusive. These two Swedes are acting more like cheer-leaders than top scientists. Kullander is 'emeritus' and could be approaching senility . . . In my opinion, such ad hominem comments are inappropriate for this forum. There is no

RE: [Vo]:Massive Rossi Claim: "97 E-Cats In Operation Right Now Across 4 Countries"

2011-04-29 Thread Jones Beene
From: Jed Rothwell Mattia Rizzi wrote: >Cold fusion has been replicated thousands of times in hundreds of labs, and ***conclusively verified*** by people such as Levi and Kullander. You are too enthusiastic. Even Hanno Essén said (on Italian's Skeptics Society (CICAP) magazine (Quer