Re: [whatwg] CENTER, MENU, DIR, NL; Re: Presentational elements in Web Applications 1.0

2007-11-01 Thread Ian Hickson
On Thu, 1 Nov 2007, Keryx Web wrote: I use it sometimes for a very small form, where I think p or hx is inappropriate and fieldset is overkill. As in form action=login.php method=post div label for=unameUsername:/label input type=text name=uname id=uname /div div

Re: [whatwg] CENTER, MENU, DIR, NL; Re: Presentational elements in Web Applications 1.0

2007-11-01 Thread Keryx Web
Ian Hickson is reading his mail so fast this almost feels like IM ;-) Why is p inappropriate? According to HTML5, it's exactly the element you want, in fact. a) To my linguistic senses that's not a paragraph b) I've seen several people use the div-element (like it or not). Should all their

Re: [whatwg] CENTER, MENU, DIR, NL; Re: Presentational elements in Web Applications 1.0

2007-11-01 Thread Matthew Paul Thomas
On Oct 30, 2007, at 4:33 AM, Ian Hickson wrote: ... On Sun, 15 Jan 2006, Matthew Paul Thomas wrote: ... Authors should use presentational markup whenever there is no available semantic markup for the relevant meaning, or when they are providing authoring facilities for people who cannot be