Re: AppDB rating definitions, was: Re: Canonical and wine

2008-12-16 Thread M.Kiesel
On Mon, 15 Dec 2008, Austin English wrote: What about clarifying the wording on http://appdb.winehq.org/help/?sTopic=maintainer_ratings ? My suggestion for Platinum: Application installs and runs flawlessly completely/at highest settings 'out of the box'. No changes required in winecfg.

AppDB rating definitions, was: Re: Canonical and wine

2008-12-15 Thread M.Kiesel
On Fri, 12 Dec 2008, Austin English wrote: If I had a nickel for every times I've seen platinum and gold ratings for apps that had dozens of native dlls or complicated scripts to work around wine bugs, I'd be a much richer man. What about clarifying the wording on

Re: AppDB rating definitions, was: Re: Canonical and wine

2008-12-15 Thread Sparr
I think that Highest Settings is unfair, there are issues with many games in Windows with settings maxed (Check Oblivion forums, every problem we have in wine is also had by people in native windows). Default settings is a far more appropriate measuring stick. I also think there needs to be a

Re: AppDB rating definitions, was: Re: Canonical and wine

2008-12-15 Thread Austin English
2008/12/15 M.Kiesel wine-de...@continuity.cjb.net: On Fri, 12 Dec 2008, Austin English wrote: If I had a nickel for every times I've seen platinum and gold ratings for apps that had dozens of native dlls or complicated scripts to work around wine bugs, I'd be a much richer man. What about

Re: AppDB rating definitions, was: Re: Canonical and wine

2008-12-15 Thread Rosanne DiMesio
On Mon, 15 Dec 2008 19:28:18 -0600 Austin English austinengl...@gmail.com wrote: 2008/12/15 M.Kiesel wine-de...@continuity.cjb.net: On Fri, 12 Dec 2008, Austin English wrote: If I had a nickel for every times I've seen platinum and gold ratings for apps that had dozens of native dlls or

Re: AppDB rating definitions, was: Re: Canonical and wine

2008-12-15 Thread Ben Klein
Mentioning bug severity levels in appdb submission rules is asking for trouble. Most appdb users don't use bugzilla at all. 2008/12/16 Rosanne DiMesio dime...@earthlink.net: On Mon, 15 Dec 2008 19:28:18 -0600 Austin English austinengl...@gmail.com wrote: 2008/12/15 M.Kiesel

Re: AppDB rating definitions, was: Re: Canonical and wine

2008-12-15 Thread Austin English
On Mon, Dec 15, 2008 at 10:56 PM, Ben Klein shackl...@gmail.com wrote: Mentioning bug severity levels in appdb submission rules is asking for trouble. Most appdb users don't use bugzilla at all. Agreed. Please bottom post on Wine mailing lists. 2008/12/16 Rosanne DiMesio