Re: [WiX-users] Crystal Reports Merge Module Installation Woes

2008-01-04 Thread Bob Arnson
Szentpali Janos wrote: Can you suggest some strategy to help one install components that do not come in msi-s or msm-s but that are shared/common components that could/would possibly be installed by non msi setups If you're not using stable component IDs through MSI, the closest you'll get is

Re: [WiX-users] Crystal Reports Merge Module Installation Woes

2008-01-04 Thread Szentpali Janos
Bob Arnson írta: Szentpali Janos wrote: Can you suggest some strategy to help one install components that do not come in msi-s or msm-s but that are shared/common components that could/would possibly be installed by non msi setups If you're not using stable component IDs through MSI, the

Re: [WiX-users] Crystal Reports Merge Module Installation Woes

2008-01-03 Thread Szentpali Janos
Bob Arnson írta: Szentpali Janos wrote: Merge modules are generally now considered bad practice... If this is true than what is the point of the whole MSI system? I mean if I have a 3rd party component (x.dll) that 4th party and 5th party are using too, how does the system decide that the

Re: [WiX-users] Crystal Reports Merge Module Installation Woes

2008-01-03 Thread Bob Arnson
Szentpali Janos wrote: Does that mean that the same file, installed by two unrelated setup packages into the same path, with two distinct component and file ids (guids) will still be correctly uninstalled/managed? No, that's what component rules are about. The component GUID and resource IDs

Re: [WiX-users] Crystal Reports Merge Module Installation Woes

2008-01-03 Thread Szentpali Janos
Bob Arnson írta: Szentpali Janos wrote: Does that mean that the same file, installed by two unrelated setup packages into the same path, with two distinct component and file ids (guids) will still be correctly uninstalled/managed? No, that's what component rules are about. The component

Re: [WiX-users] Crystal Reports Merge Module Installation Woes

2008-01-02 Thread Bob Arnson
Szentpali Janos wrote: Merge modules are generally now considered bad practice... If this is true than what is the point of the whole MSI system? I mean if I have a 3rd party component (x.dll) that 4th party and 5th party are using too, how does the system decide that the x.dll component

Re: [WiX-users] Crystal Reports Merge Module Installation Woes

2007-12-31 Thread greenaj
Ugh, I just send this reply but forgort to include the Subject: Anyway, Thanks. I did get everything working with the merge module, and I did find the standalone MSI alternative to the merge module. I hope that the licensing is the same with the XTal MSI as with the merge module. I do use

Re: [WiX-users] Crystal Reports Merge Module Installation Woes

2007-12-30 Thread Mike Dimmick
2007 00:45 To: wix-users@lists.sourceforge.net Subject: [WiX-users] Crystal Reports Merge Module Installation Woes I am using Wix v3 Build 3.0.3632.0 and am trying to merge the Crystal Reprots for Visual Studio 2005 merge module into my project. I can not get the reports to work on the installation

Re: [WiX-users] Crystal Reports Merge Module Installation Woes

2007-12-30 Thread Szentpali Janos
Merge modules are generally now considered bad practice... If this is true than what is the point of the whole MSI system? I mean if I have a 3rd party component (x.dll) that 4th party and 5th party are using too, how does the system decide that the x.dll component installed by the 4th party's

[WiX-users] Crystal Reports Merge Module Installation Woes

2007-12-29 Thread greenaj
I am using Wix v3 Build 3.0.3632.0 and am trying to merge the Crystal Reprots for Visual Studio 2005 merge module into my project. I can not get the reports to work on the installation box. I created identital setups using InstallShield 9.0 and the Visual Studio 2005 setup projects. BOTH OF