Re: [zfs-discuss] Per filesystem scrub

2008-04-07 Thread Peter Tribble
Jeff, On Mon, Mar 31, 2008 at 9:01 AM, Jeff Bonwick [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Peter, That's a great suggestion. And as fortune would have it, we have the code to do it already. Scrubbing in ZFS is driven from the logical layer, not the physical layer. When you scrub a pool, you're

Re: [zfs-discuss] Per filesystem scrub

2008-04-05 Thread Jeff Bonwick
Aye, or better yet -- give the scrub/resilver/snap reset issue fix very high priority. As it stands snapshots are impossible when you need to resilver and scrub (even on supposedly sun supported thumper configs). No argument. One of our top engineers is working on this as we speak. I say

Re: [zfs-discuss] Per filesystem scrub

2008-04-01 Thread Darren J Moffat
kristof wrote: I would be very happy having a filesystem based zfs scrub We have a 18TB big zpool, it takes more then 2 days to do the scrub. Since we cannot take snapshots during the scrub, this is unacceptable We have recently discovered the same issue on one of our internal build

Re: [zfs-discuss] Per filesystem scrub

2008-04-01 Thread Adam Leventhal
On Mar 31, 2008, at 10:41 AM, kristof wrote: I would be very happy having a filesystem based zfs scrub We have a 18TB big zpool, it takes more then 2 days to do the scrub. Since we cannot take snapshots during the scrub, this is unacceptable While per-dataset scrubbing would certainly be a

Re: [zfs-discuss] Per filesystem scrub

2008-04-01 Thread Wade . Stuart
[EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote on 04/01/2008 04:25:39 AM: kristof wrote: I would be very happy having a filesystem based zfs scrub We have a 18TB big zpool, it takes more then 2 days to do the scrub. Since we cannot take snapshots during the scrub, this is unacceptable We have recently

Re: [zfs-discuss] Per filesystem scrub

2008-04-01 Thread Webmail
We have recently discovered the same issue on one of our internal build machines. We have a daily bringover of the Teamware onnv-gate that is snapshoted when it completes and as such we can never run a full scrub. Given some of our storage is reaching (or past) EOSL I really want to be

Re: [zfs-discuss] Per filesystem scrub

2008-03-31 Thread Jeff Bonwick
Peter, That's a great suggestion. And as fortune would have it, we have the code to do it already. Scrubbing in ZFS is driven from the logical layer, not the physical layer. When you scrub a pool, you're really just scrubbing the pool-wide metadata, then scrubbing each filesystem. At 50,000

Re: [zfs-discuss] Per filesystem scrub

2008-03-31 Thread kristof
I would be very happy having a filesystem based zfs scrub We have a 18TB big zpool, it takes more then 2 days to do the scrub. Since we cannot take snapshots during the scrub, this is unacceptable Kristof This message posted from opensolaris.org

[zfs-discuss] Per filesystem scrub

2008-03-29 Thread Peter Tribble
A brief search didn't show anything relevant, so here goes: Would it be feasible to support a scrub per-filesystem rather than per-pool? The reason is that on a large system, a scrub of a pool can take excessively long (and, indeed, may never complete). Running a scrub on each filesystem allows