Am Samstag, den 29.07.2006, 13:15 +0200 schrieb Stefano Bagnara: > Noel J. Bergman wrote: > > Stefano Bagnara wrote: > > > >> the EHLO/EHLO is done before the AUTH can be issued so we only > >> have a "checkAuthNetworks" option and not a "checkAuthClients" > >> option like we did for other CmdHandlers. > > > > Sometimes, you have to defer the problem that you caught, so if the command > > handler finds the problem, it can set a session attribute itself (or another > > aware handler) to deal with later. > > > > For example, the block list code is intentionally handled in RCPT because I > > wanted to defer the error until we knew to whom they were sending the > > e-mail, thus allowing RFC compliance with postmaster@ and [EMAIL PROTECTED] > > Yes, of course. There are plenty of changes and improvements that can be > done here, but we are in RC and I'm replying to a message related to an RC. > > We have the filter in that place, we will not move it around at rc > level, as it is not a bug. (IMO) > > > The concept, for which we now have support in the v2.4 changes, was that an > > "EHLO" handler could actually be a suite of related handlers registered to > > be an EHLO handler, an AUTH handler, and some other type of handler(s), so > > that it could set a detected concern in EHLO, possibly clear it in AUTH, and > > check it downstream. > > I can see thousands of improvements that can be done there, as we can > add thousands handlers (we also can add thousands mailets). > Btw improvements belong to trunk now.. so feel free to submit them and > they will be included in the next release. > > > I've not formed an opinion on whether or not to fix this for v2.3 or wait > > for v2.4. I won't form an opinion until I see the proposed patch. > > > > --- Noel > > Instead, as time passes, my idea for delaying it to 2.4 is stronger. > > Again I could change ideas about things to put in 2.3 if we'll find > blocker issues and the 2.3.0 final will be delayed anyway. > > If we release 2.3.0 final soon we can start working on 2.4 and add this > and much more new features! > > Stefano
After i did now the changes i whould like to "delay" the improvment to 2.4. Let us release the handler like it is at the moment and add an comment how it works to the configuration. So: 2.4 -> +1 2.3 -> -0 bye Norman
signature.asc
Description: Dies ist ein digital signierter Nachrichtenteil
