serviceability-dev
Thread
Date
Earlier messages
Later messages
Messages by Thread
Re: RFR: 8319589: Attach from root to a user java process not supported in Mac [v2]
Serguei Spitsyn
RFR: 8372957: After JDK-8282441 JDWP might allow some invalid FrameIDs to be used
Chris Plummer
Re: RFR: 8372957: After JDK-8282441 JDWP might allow some invalid FrameIDs to be used
Chris Plummer
Re: RFR: 8372957: After JDK-8282441 JDWP might allow some invalid FrameIDs to be used
Alex Menkov
Re: RFR: 8372957: After JDK-8282441 JDWP might allow some invalid FrameIDs to be used
Serguei Spitsyn
Re: RFR: 8372957: After JDK-8282441 JDWP might allow some invalid FrameIDs to be used
Chris Plummer
Integrated: 8372957: After JDK-8282441 JDWP might allow some invalid FrameIDs to be used
Chris Plummer
Re: RFR: 8364343: Virtual Thread transition management needs to be independent of JVM TI [v12]
Patricio Chilano Mateo
Re: RFR: 8364343: Virtual Thread transition management needs to be independent of JVM TI [v12]
Serguei Spitsyn
Re: RFR: 8364343: Virtual Thread transition management needs to be independent of JVM TI [v11]
Patricio Chilano Mateo
Re: RFR: 8364343: Virtual Thread transition management needs to be independent of JVM TI [v11]
Serguei Spitsyn
Re: RFR: 8364343: Virtual Thread transition management needs to be independent of JVM TI [v11]
Patricio Chilano Mateo
Re: RFR: 8319589: Attach from root to a user java process not supported in Mac [v7]
Sergey Chernyshev
Re: RFR: 8319589: Attach from root to a user java process not supported in Mac [v7]
Serguei Spitsyn
Re: RFR: 8319589: Attach from root to a user java process not supported in Mac [v7]
Sergey Chernyshev
Re: RFR: 8372098: Move AccessFlags to InstanceKlass [v7]
Coleen Phillimore
Re: RFR: 8372098: Move AccessFlags to InstanceKlass [v7]
Serguei Spitsyn
Re: RFR: 8372098: Move AccessFlags to InstanceKlass [v7]
Coleen Phillimore
Integrated: 8371194: serviceability/sa/TestJhsdbJstackMixedWithXComp.java failing
Yasumasa Suenaga
Re: RFR: 8366659: ObjectMonitor::wait() can deadlock with a suspension request [v19]
Anton Artemov
Re: RFR: 8372098: Move AccessFlags to InstanceKlass [v6]
Coleen Phillimore
Re: RFR: 8372098: Move AccessFlags to InstanceKlass [v6]
Serguei Spitsyn
Re: RFR: 8372098: Move AccessFlags to InstanceKlass [v6]
Coleen Phillimore
Re: RFR: 8371194: serviceability/sa/TestJhsdbJstackMixedWithXComp.java failing [v4]
Yasumasa Suenaga
Re: RFR: 8371194: serviceability/sa/TestJhsdbJstackMixedWithXComp.java failing [v4]
Chris Plummer
Re: RFR: 8371194: serviceability/sa/TestJhsdbJstackMixedWithXComp.java failing [v4]
Yasumasa Suenaga
Re: RFR: 8371194: serviceability/sa/TestJhsdbJstackMixedWithXComp.java failing [v4]
David Holmes
Re: RFR: 8364343: Virtual Thread transition management needs to be independent of JVM TI [v10]
Patricio Chilano Mateo
Re: RFR: 8364343: Virtual Thread transition management needs to be independent of JVM TI [v10]
David Holmes
Re: RFR: 8364343: Virtual Thread transition management needs to be independent of JVM TI [v10]
Patricio Chilano Mateo
Re: RFR: 8364343: Virtual Thread transition management needs to be independent of JVM TI [v10]
Serguei Spitsyn
Re: RFR: 8364343: Virtual Thread transition management needs to be independent of JVM TI [v10]
Patricio Chilano Mateo
RFR: 8372809: Test vmTestbase/nsk/jdi/ThreadReference/isSuspended/issuspended001/TestDescription.java failed: JVMTI_ERROR_THREAD_NOT_ALIVE
Chris Plummer
Re: RFR: 8372809: Test vmTestbase/nsk/jdi/ThreadReference/isSuspended/issuspended001/TestDescription.java failed: JVMTI_ERROR_THREAD_NOT_ALIVE
Alex Menkov
Re: RFR: 8372809: Test vmTestbase/nsk/jdi/ThreadReference/isSuspended/issuspended001/TestDescription.java failed: JVMTI_ERROR_THREAD_NOT_ALIVE
Serguei Spitsyn
Re: RFR: 8372809: Test vmTestbase/nsk/jdi/ThreadReference/isSuspended/issuspended001/TestDescription.java failed: JVMTI_ERROR_THREAD_NOT_ALIVE
Chris Plummer
Integrated: 8372809: Test vmTestbase/nsk/jdi/ThreadReference/isSuspended/issuspended001/TestDescription.java failed: JVMTI_ERROR_THREAD_NOT_ALIVE
Chris Plummer
Re: RFR: 8319589: Attach from root to a user java process not supported in Mac [v6]
Tres Finocchiaro
Re: RFR: 8319589: Attach from root to a user java process not supported in Mac [v6]
Larry Cable
Re: RFR: 8319589: Attach from root to a user java process not supported in Mac [v6]
David Holmes
Re: RFR: 8319589: Attach from root to a user java process not supported in Mac [v6]
David Holmes
Re: RFR: 8319589: Attach from root to a user java process not supported in Mac [v6]
Laurence Cable
Re: RFR: 8319589: Attach from root to a user java process not supported in Mac
Sergey Chernyshev
Re: RFR: 8372098: Move AccessFlags to InstanceKlass [v5]
Coleen Phillimore
Re: RFR: 8372098: Move AccessFlags to InstanceKlass [v5]
Vladimir Ivanov
Re: RFR: 8372098: Move AccessFlags to InstanceKlass [v5]
Dean Long
Re: RFR: 8372098: Move AccessFlags to InstanceKlass [v5]
Coleen Phillimore
Re: RFR: 8372098: Move AccessFlags to InstanceKlass [v5]
Dean Long
Re: RFR: 8372098: Move AccessFlags to InstanceKlass [v5]
Dean Long
Re: RFR: 8372098: Move AccessFlags to InstanceKlass [v5]
Coleen Phillimore
Re: RFR: 8372098: Move AccessFlags to InstanceKlass [v5]
Dean Long
Re: RFR: 8372098: Move AccessFlags to InstanceKlass [v5]
Chen Liang
Re: RFR: 8372098: Move AccessFlags to InstanceKlass [v5]
Coleen Phillimore
Integrated: 8353738: Update TLS unit tests to not use certificates with MD5 signatures
Matthew Donovan
Re: RFR: 8366659: ObjectMonitor::wait() can deadlock with a suspension request [v18]
Anton Artemov
RFR: 8372615: Many container tests fail when running rootless on cgroup v1
Casper Norrbin
Re: RFR: 8372615: Many container tests fail when running rootless on cgroup v1
David Holmes
Re: RFR: 8372615: Many container tests fail when running rootless on cgroup v1 [v2]
Casper Norrbin
Re: RFR: 8372615: Many container tests fail when running rootless on cgroup v1 [v2]
Casper Norrbin
Re: RFR: 8372615: Many container tests fail when running rootless on cgroup v1 [v2]
Severin Gehwolf
Re: RFR: 8372615: Many container tests fail when running rootless on cgroup v1 [v2]
Casper Norrbin
Re: RFR: 8372615: Many container tests fail when running rootless on cgroup v1 [v2]
Severin Gehwolf
Re: RFR: 8372615: Many container tests fail when running rootless on cgroup v1 [v2]
David Holmes
Re: RFR: 8372615: Many container tests fail when running rootless on cgroup v1 [v2]
Casper Norrbin
Integrated: 8372615: Many container tests fail when running rootless on cgroup v1
Casper Norrbin
RFR: 8372588: [asan] serviceability/sa/TestJmapCore.java and TestJmapCoreMetaspace.java fail after recent improvements
Matthias Baesken
Re: RFR: 8372588: [asan] serviceability/sa/TestJmapCore.java and TestJmapCoreMetaspace.java fail after recent improvements
Thomas Stuefe
Re: RFR: 8372588: [asan] serviceability/sa/TestJmapCore.java and TestJmapCoreMetaspace.java fail after recent improvements
Arno Zeller
Re: RFR: 8372588: [asan] serviceability/sa/TestJmapCore.java and TestJmapCoreMetaspace.java fail after recent improvements
Lutz Schmidt
Re: RFR: 8372588: [asan] serviceability/sa/TestJmapCore.java and TestJmapCoreMetaspace.java fail after recent improvements
Matthias Baesken
Integrated: 8372588: [asan] serviceability/sa/TestJmapCore.java and TestJmapCoreMetaspace.java fail after recent improvements
Matthias Baesken
RFR: 8372704: ThreadMXBean.getThreadUserTime may return total time
Jonas Norlinder
Re: RFR: 8372704: ThreadMXBean.getThreadUserTime may return total time
David Holmes
Re: RFR: 8372704: ThreadMXBean.getThreadUserTime may return total time
Alan Bateman
Re: RFR: 8372704: ThreadMXBean.getThreadUserTime may return total time [v2]
Jonas Norlinder
Re: RFR: 8372704: ThreadMXBean.getThreadUserTime may return total time [v2]
Kevin Walls
Re: RFR: 8372704: ThreadMXBean.getThreadUserTime may return total time [v2]
Alan Bateman
Integrated: 8372704: ThreadMXBean.getThreadUserTime may return total time
Jonas Norlinder
RFR: 8372039: post_sampled_object_alloc is called while lock is handled
Leonid Mesnik
Re: RFR: 8372039: post_sampled_object_alloc is called while lock is handled [v2]
Leonid Mesnik
Re: RFR: 8372039: post_sampled_object_alloc is called while lock is handled [v2]
Erik Österlund
Re: RFR: 8372039: post_sampled_object_alloc is called while lock is handled [v3]
Leonid Mesnik
Re: RFR: 8372039: post_sampled_object_alloc is called while lock is handled [v4]
Leonid Mesnik
Re: RFR: 8372039: post_sampled_object_alloc is called while lock is handled [v4]
Erik Österlund
Re: RFR: 8372039: post_sampled_object_alloc is called while lock is handled [v4]
Leonid Mesnik
Re: RFR: 8372039: post_sampled_object_alloc is called while lock is handled [v4]
Alex Menkov
Re: RFR: 8372039: post_sampled_object_alloc is called while lock is handled [v5]
Leonid Mesnik
Re: RFR: 8372039: post_sampled_object_alloc is called while lock is handled [v5]
Alex Menkov
Re: RFR: 8372039: post_sampled_object_alloc is called while lock is handled [v5]
Serguei Spitsyn
Re: RFR: 8372039: post_sampled_object_alloc is called while lock is handled [v6]
Leonid Mesnik
Re: RFR: 8372039: post_sampled_object_alloc is called while lock is handled [v6]
Serguei Spitsyn
Integrated: 8372039: post_sampled_object_alloc is called while lock is handled
Leonid Mesnik
Re: RFR: 8364343: Virtual Thread transition management needs to be independent of JVM TI [v9]
Patricio Chilano Mateo
Re: RFR: 8364343: Virtual Thread transition management needs to be independent of JVM TI [v9]
Coleen Phillimore
Re: RFR: 8364343: Virtual Thread transition management needs to be independent of JVM TI [v9]
Patricio Chilano Mateo
Re: RFR: 8364343: Virtual Thread transition management needs to be independent of JVM TI [v8]
Patricio Chilano Mateo
Re: RFR: 8369736 - Add management interface for AOT cache creation [v11]
Mat Carter
Re: RFR: 8369736 - Add management interface for AOT cache creation [v11]
Kevin Walls
Re: RFR: 8369736 - Add management interface for AOT cache creation [v11]
Mark Reinhold
Re: RFR: 8369736 - Add management interface for AOT cache creation [v11]
Mark Reinhold
Re: RFR: 8369736 - Add management interface for AOT cache creation [v10]
Mat Carter
Re: RFR: 8369736 - Add management interface for AOT cache creation [v9]
Mat Carter
Re: RFR: 8370691: Add new Float16Vector type and enable intrinsification of vector operations supported by auto-vectorizer [v5]
Jatin Bhateja
Re: RFR: 8370691: Add new Float16Vector type and enable intrinsification of vector operations supported by auto-vectorizer [v5]
Bhavana Kilambi
Re: RFR: 8370691: Add new Float16Vector type and enable intrinsification of vector operations supported by auto-vectorizer [v5]
Bhavana Kilambi
Re: RFR: 8370691: Add new Float16Vector type and enable intrinsification of vector operations supported by auto-vectorizer [v5]
Emanuel Peter
Re: RFR: 8370691: Add new Float16Vector type and enable intrinsification of vector operations supported by auto-vectorizer [v5]
Bhavana Kilambi
Re: RFR: 8370691: Add new Float16Vector type and enable intrinsification of vector operations supported by auto-vectorizer [v5]
Jatin Bhateja
Re: RFR: 8370691: Add new Float16Vector type and enable intrinsification of vector operations supported by auto-vectorizer [v5]
Bhavana Kilambi
RFR: 8372552: unhandled oop in the JvmtiEventController::set_user_enabled
Leonid Mesnik
Re: RFR: 8372552: unhandled oop in the JvmtiEventController::set_user_enabled
Chris Plummer
Re: RFR: 8372552: unhandled oop in the JvmtiEventController::set_user_enabled
Leonid Mesnik
Re: RFR: 8372552: unhandled oop in the JvmtiEventController::set_user_enabled
Alex Menkov
Re: RFR: 8372552: unhandled oop in the JvmtiEventController::set_user_enabled
Serguei Spitsyn
Integrated: 8372552: unhandled oop in the JvmtiEventController::set_user_enabled
Leonid Mesnik
Integrated: 8370203 - Add jcmd AOT.end_recording diagnostic command
Mat Carter
Re: RFR: 8364343: Virtual Thread transition management needs to be independent of JVM TI [v7]
Patricio Chilano Mateo
Re: RFR: 8364343: Virtual Thread transition management needs to be independent of JVM TI [v7]
Coleen Phillimore
Re: RFR: 8364343: Virtual Thread transition management needs to be independent of JVM TI [v7]
Coleen Phillimore
Re: RFR: 8364343: Virtual Thread transition management needs to be independent of JVM TI [v7]
Patricio Chilano Mateo
Re: RFR: 8364343: Virtual Thread transition management needs to be independent of JVM TI [v7]
Coleen Phillimore
Re: RFR: 8364343: Virtual Thread transition management needs to be independent of JVM TI [v7]
Patricio Chilano Mateo
Re: RFR: 8364343: Virtual Thread transition management needs to be independent of JVM TI [v7]
Patricio Chilano Mateo
Re: RFR: 8364343: Virtual Thread transition management needs to be independent of JVM TI [v7]
Coleen Phillimore
Re: RFR: 8364343: Virtual Thread transition management needs to be independent of JVM TI [v9]
Patricio Chilano Mateo
Re: RFR: 8364343: Virtual Thread transition management needs to be independent of JVM TI [v9]
Coleen Phillimore
Re: RFR: 8364343: Virtual Thread transition management needs to be independent of JVM TI [v6]
Patricio Chilano Mateo
Re: RFR: 8364343: Virtual Thread transition management needs to be independent of JVM TI [v5]
Patricio Chilano Mateo
RFR: 8352654: [REDO] nsk/jvmti/ tests should fail when nsk_jvmti_setFailSt…
Leonid Mesnik
Re: RFR: 8352654: [REDO] nsk/jvmti/ tests should fail when nsk_jvmti_setFailStatus() is called
Alex Menkov
Re: RFR: 8352654: [REDO] nsk/jvmti/ tests should fail when nsk_jvmti_setFailStatus() is called
Leonid Mesnik
Re: RFR: 8352654: [REDO] nsk/jvmti/ tests should fail when nsk_jvmti_setFailStatus() is called [v2]
Leonid Mesnik
Re: RFR: 8352654: [REDO] nsk/jvmti/ tests should fail when nsk_jvmti_setFailStatus() is called [v2]
Alex Menkov
Re: RFR: 8352654: [REDO] nsk/jvmti/ tests should fail when nsk_jvmti_setFailStatus() is called [v2]
Serguei Spitsyn
Re: RFR: 8352654: [REDO] nsk/jvmti/ tests should fail when nsk_jvmti_setFailStatus() is called [v2]
Serguei Spitsyn
Integrated: 8352654: [REDO] nsk/jvmti/ tests should fail when nsk_jvmti_setFailStatus() is called
Leonid Mesnik
Integrated: 8367656: Refactor Constantpool's operand array into two
Johan Sjölen
Re: RFR: 8371893: [macOS aarch64] use dead_strip linker option to reduce binary size [v5]
Matthias Baesken
Re: RFR: 8371893: [macOS aarch64] use dead_strip linker option to reduce binary size [v5]
Erik Joelsson
Re: RFR: 8371893: [macOS] use dead_strip linker option to reduce binary size [v5]
Matthias Baesken
Re: RFR: 8371893: [macOS] use dead_strip linker option to reduce binary size [v5]
Sergey Bylokhov
Re: RFR: 8371893: [macOS] use dead_strip linker option to reduce binary size [v5]
Matthias Baesken
Re: RFR: 8371893: [macOS] use dead_strip linker option to reduce binary size [v5]
Matthias Baesken
Re: RFR: 8371893: [macOS] use dead_strip linker option to reduce binary size [v5]
Sergey Bylokhov
Re: RFR: 8371893: [macOS] use dead_strip linker option to reduce binary size [v5]
Lutz Schmidt
Re: RFR: 8371893: [macOS] use dead_strip linker option to reduce binary size [v5]
Sergey Bylokhov
Re: RFR: 8371893: [macOS] use dead_strip linker option to reduce binary size [v5]
Matthias Baesken
Re: RFR: 8370691: Add new Float16Vector type and enable intrinsification of vector operations supported by auto-vectorizer [v4]
Jatin Bhateja
RFR: 8371380: [LOOM] The debug agent should avoid enabling VIRTUAL_THREAD_START/END events when possible
Chris Plummer
Re: RFR: 8371380: [LOOM] The debug agent should avoid enabling VIRTUAL_THREAD_START/END events when possible
Chris Plummer
Re: RFR: 8371380: [LOOM] The debug agent should avoid enabling VIRTUAL_THREAD_START/END events when possible
Serguei Spitsyn
Re: RFR: 8371380: [LOOM] The debug agent should avoid enabling VIRTUAL_THREAD_START/END events when possible
Chris Plummer
Re: RFR: 8371380: [LOOM] The debug agent should avoid enabling VIRTUAL_THREAD_START/END events when possible
Chris Plummer
Re: RFR: 8371380: [LOOM] The debug agent should avoid enabling VIRTUAL_THREAD_START/END events when possible
Chris Plummer
Re: RFR: 8371380: [LOOM] The debug agent should avoid enabling VIRTUAL_THREAD_START/END events when possible
Chris Plummer
Re: RFR: 8371380: [LOOM] The debug agent should avoid enabling VIRTUAL_THREAD_START/END events when possible
Serguei Spitsyn
Re: RFR: 8371380: [LOOM] The debug agent should avoid enabling VIRTUAL_THREAD_START/END events when possible
Alex Menkov
Re: RFR: 8371380: [LOOM] The debug agent should avoid enabling VIRTUAL_THREAD_START/END events when possible
Chris Plummer
Re: RFR: 8371380: [LOOM] The debug agent should avoid enabling VIRTUAL_THREAD_START/END events when possible [v2]
Chris Plummer
Re: RFR: 8371380: [LOOM] The debug agent should avoid enabling VIRTUAL_THREAD_START/END events when possible [v2]
Alex Menkov
Re: RFR: 8371380: [LOOM] The debug agent should avoid enabling VIRTUAL_THREAD_START/END events when possible [v2]
Serguei Spitsyn
Re: RFR: 8371380: [LOOM] The debug agent should avoid enabling VIRTUAL_THREAD_START/END events when possible [v2]
Chris Plummer
Re: RFR: 8371380: [LOOM] The debug agent should avoid enabling VIRTUAL_THREAD_START/END events when possible [v2]
Serguei Spitsyn
Re: RFR: 8371380: [LOOM] The debug agent should avoid enabling VIRTUAL_THREAD_START/END events when possible [v3]
Chris Plummer
Re: RFR: 8371380: [LOOM] The debug agent should avoid enabling VIRTUAL_THREAD_START/END events when possible [v4]
Chris Plummer
Re: RFR: 8371380: [LOOM] The debug agent should avoid enabling VIRTUAL_THREAD_START/END events when possible [v5]
Chris Plummer
Re: RFR: 8371380: [LOOM] The debug agent should avoid enabling VIRTUAL_THREAD_START/END events when possible [v5]
Alex Menkov
Re: RFR: 8371380: [LOOM] The debug agent should avoid enabling VIRTUAL_THREAD_START/END events when possible [v5]
Serguei Spitsyn
Withdrawn: 8371380: [LOOM] The debug agent should avoid enabling VIRTUAL_THREAD_START/END events when possible
duke
Re: RFR: 8369736 - Add management interface for AOT cache creation [v4]
Mat Carter
Re: RFR: 8370203 - Add jcmd AOT.end_recording diagnostic command [v7]
Mat Carter
Re: RFR: 8370203 - Add jcmd AOT.end_recording diagnostic command [v7]
Kevin Walls
Re: RFR: 8370203 - Add jcmd AOT.end_recording diagnostic command [v7]
Kevin Walls
Re: RFR: 8370203 - Add jcmd AOT.end_recording diagnostic command [v7]
Vladimir Ivanov
Re: RFR: 8370203 - Add jcmd AOT.end_recording diagnostic command [v7]
duke
Re: RFR: 8370203 - Add jcmd AOT.end_recording diagnostic command [v7]
Vladimir Ivanov
Re: RFR: 8370203 - Add jcmd AOT.end_recording diagnostic command [v6]
Mat Carter
Re: RFR: 8370691: Add new Float16Vector type and enable intrinsification of vector operations supported by auto-vectorizer [v3]
Daniel Fuchs
Re: RFR: 8370691: Add new Float16Vector type and enable intrinsification of vector operations supported by auto-vectorizer [v3]
Jatin Bhateja
Re: RFR: 8370691: Add new Float16Vector type and enable intrinsification of vector operations supported by auto-vectorizer [v3]
Jatin Bhateja
Re: RFR: 8353738: Update TLS unit tests to not use certificates with MD5 signatures [v7]
Matthew Donovan
Re: RFR: 8353738: Update TLS unit tests to not use certificates with MD5 signatures [v7]
Daniel Jeliński
Integrated: 8371458: [REDO] Remove exception handler stub code in C2
Ruben
Re: RFR: 8371893: [macOS aarch64] use dead_strip linker option to reduce binary size [v4]
Matthias Baesken
Re: RFR: 8371893: [macOS aarch64] use dead_strip linker option to reduce binary size [v4]
Matthias Baesken
Re: RFR: 8371893: [macOS aarch64] use dead_strip linker option to reduce binary size [v4]
Matthias Baesken
Re: RFR: 8371893: [macOS aarch64] use dead_strip linker option to reduce binary size [v4]
Matthias Baesken
Withdrawn: 8358890: VM option -XX:AllowRedefinitionToAddDeleteMethods should be obsoleted then expired
duke
Re: RFR: 8353738: Update TLS unit tests to not use certificates with MD5 signatures [v6]
Matthew Donovan
Re: RFR: 8353738: Update TLS unit tests to not use certificates with MD5 signatures [v6]
Daniel Jeliński
Re: RFR: 8353738: Update TLS unit tests to not use certificates with MD5 signatures [v5]
Matthew Donovan
Re: RFR: 8353738: Update TLS unit tests to not use certificates with MD5 signatures [v5]
Matthew Donovan
Integrated: 8282441: [LOOM] The debug agent should attempt to free vthread ThreadNodes
Chris Plummer
Re: RFR: 8372098: Move AccessFlags to InstanceKlass [v4]
Coleen Phillimore
Re: RFR: 8372098: Move AccessFlags to InstanceKlass [v4]
Vladimir Ivanov
Re: RFR: 8372098: Move AccessFlags to InstanceKlass [v4]
Dean Long
Re: RFR: 8372098: Move AccessFlags to InstanceKlass [v4]
Vladimir Ivanov
Re: RFR: 8282441: [LOOM] The debug agent should attempt to free vthread ThreadNodes [v4]
Chris Plummer
Re: RFR: 8282441: [LOOM] The debug agent should attempt to free vthread ThreadNodes [v4]
Alex Menkov
Re: RFR: 8282441: [LOOM] The debug agent should attempt to free vthread ThreadNodes [v4]
Chris Plummer
Earlier messages
Later messages