Petr Slechta wrote: > Hello Jim, > > I don't know which file do you address by the following: > >> Can pkgs include anything they need even if it duplicates >> other jar files? > > If you mean findbugs-ant-1.3.5.jar file, then this is not Ant > implementation, it is just findbugs' extension to the Ant, i.e. command > that extends standard Ant to be able to run findbugs from ant scripts.
Sorry. I meant ant.jar. I'm concerned about these jar files: 163 f none usr/share/lib/java/findbugs/asm-analysis-3.1.jar 164 f none usr/share/lib/java/findbugs/asm-xml-3.1.jar 165 f none usr/share/lib/java/findbugs/asm-util-3.1.jar 167 f none usr/share/lib/java/findbugs/jsr305.jar 169 f none usr/share/lib/java/findbugs/asm-tree-3.1.jar 170 f none usr/share/lib/java/findbugs/dom4j-1.6.1.jar 172 f none usr/share/lib/java/findbugs/ant.jar 173 f none usr/share/lib/java/findbugs/asm-3.1.jar 174 f none usr/share/lib/java/findbugs/jaxen-1.1.1.jar 175 f none usr/share/lib/java/findbugs/asm-commons-3.1.jar 176 f none usr/share/lib/java/findbugs/bcel.jar Is ant.jar functionally the same as what is already installed here? /usr/share/lib/ant/ant.jar Can you do a symlink for findbugs to the current ant.jar location? Do you build any of the above or do you just copy them? I'm not concerned about these jar files, assuming you build them: 166 f none usr/share/lib/java/findbugs/findbugs-ant-1.3.5.jar 168 f none usr/share/lib/java/findbugs/findbugs-1.3.5.jar 171 f none usr/share/lib/java/findbugs/annotations.jar Just to clarify, I'm concerned about the following: 1. Does findbugs duplicate ant.jar that already exist? 2. Can jar files be ported to SFW without building from src? 3. Should the following jar files be located at /usr/share/lib/java since they are more general purpose then findbugs? asm-*.jar http://asm.objectweb.org/ dom4j*.jar http://www.dom4j.org/ jaxen*.jar http://jaxen.codehaus.org/ bcel.jar http://jakarta.apache.org/bcel/ 4. Should the above four projects be ported separately? How we approach findbugs jar files can define how we approach jar files in the future. Cheers, Jim > > > > Jim Walker wrote: >> Petr Slechta wrote: >>> Hello! >>> >>> Comments from Paul Cunningham incorporated, second version of webrev >>> is available at http://cr.opensolaris.org/~pslechta/findbugs2/ >>> >> >> Brian, >> >> Can you take a look at the package contents: >> >> http://cr.opensolaris.org/~pslechta/findbugs2/usr/src/pkgdefs/SUNWfindbugs/prototype_com.html >> >> >> >> It doesn't seem to correspond to the LSARC/2008/642 interfaces: >> >> Is this internal file the most recent proposal file: >> fosslist.txt >> >> I don't see any external interface summary: >> http://www.opensolaris.org/os/community/arc/caselog/2008/642 >> >> Norm, >> >> What's the current sfw c-team policy on jar files including jar >> files like ant which are present elsewhere? >> >> Specifically: >> >> Can pkgs include anything they need even if it duplicates >> other jar files? >> >> Do jar files need to be built from source code? >> >> Cheers, >> Jim >
