On Apr 4, 2010, at 9:22 PM, Sriram, Kotikalapudi wrote:

> 
> Are you leaning towards an "Invalid" or "Unknown" for the decision
> when an AS set is found for the origin AS in an update?
> I think when we had a discussion on this topic long time ago,
> the thinking was that we should try to discourage the usage
> of AS sets. I am trying to figure if that meant calling the 
> update "Invaid" in this situation?


Of ~344k prefixes in the current routing system:

Today:
 o 61 prefixes with AS_SETS
 o 50 only include a single AS in the set
 o only 48 different sets appear
 o 1 includes only 4 occurrences of the same AS 
 o 1 includes 4 occurrences of the same AS and an IANA DSU AS
 o 5 of those have an origin code of incomplete

In 2005: 
 o 45 prefixes with AS_SETS
 o 31 only include a single AS in the set
 o only 39 different sets appear
 o 1 includes a unique AS and an IANA DSU AS 
 o 4 with incomplete origin code

So, one couple make an assumption that only 9 of these have any
chance of being an problem today, and it might well not be an issue 
-- unless you're one of those folks, of course.

As long as the spec supports it and people use it, we 
need to, methinks...

-danny



_______________________________________________
sidr mailing list
[email protected]
https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/sidr

Reply via email to