I’ve written about this extensively https://Frankston.com including 
https://rmf.vc/IEEE5GPast but I keep trying to see if I can make it simple. I'm 
writing this as the old guy who remembers when phones were, well, phones. So we 
might need to synchronize vocabularies.

The concept of telecommunications assumes we have dumb endpoints and depend on 
the network to keep the bits in order – like two tin cans and a string. The 
phone company offers services like phone calls and relies on the network to 
keep the voice waveform intact along the path. Your speech is freight just like 
a postal letter. The business model is simple – the revenue from the service 
pays for the facilities. It’s identical to railroads selling rides.

As I wrote in https://rmf.vc/VoIPInflection, with intelligent endpoints we no 
longer depend on a provider assuring a clear path. The computers at the 
endpoints can program around it. What is interesting is that the meaning does 
not exist between the two endpoints! In that essay I used a simple example but 
if I say “Patel” in a conversion the knowledge of which Patel I’m referring to 
only exists in the minds (or computers) at the endpoints.

This is like the tokenization of AI – the facilities we use to do networking 
(it is no longer a physical network) carries meaningless (or fungible) tokens, 
AKA (encrypted) packets.

We’re able to innovation because the network provider is no longer fighting us. 
I realize that most readers on this list don’t remember the days before 
answering machines when you’d run soaking out of the shower to answer the 
phone. Nearly 100% of the calls (in the US) completed, but only by that you 
mean it rang. Only 40% of the time was it completed to humans but to telecom 
that is not their measure. In about 1970 the US Supreme Court said people could 
attach their own devices and suddenly people had answer machines!

The Internet’s packets take this a step further by taking 100% of the 
intelligence out of the network and ask for “best efforts” but no guarantees of 
delivery. They can program round the rest and innovation.

The existential threat to the very concept of telecommunications is that 100% 
of the value is created outside of their facilities. In a normal market this 
would have resolved itself by shifting to infrastructure funding as we did with 
railroads🡪roads. But thanks to the heroic efforts of the telecom cartel – FCC 
and the PTTs the telcos are protected from market forces (a story in its own 
right). And our attempts to innovation get second-guessed by the telcos.

#5G comes into this story because it is a desperate attempt to claw back value 
from the users. It is based on the principle the VoIP is impossible because 
applications are dumb and require an intelligent network, nay, a super 
intelligent network that can capture the value. They promise low latency. After 
all, if the Mars rover used #5G we wouldn’t have a two-hour delay – the 
salespeople promise that.

I wrote Empowering People … and Their Things in response to an article about 
IoT in India which was classic telecom with amazing complexity. It missed the 
power of normalizing infrastructure to fungible packets.

Another example was the heyday of Facebook basics which I was well-meaning but 
rather that starting with empowering communities to build local infrastructure, 
it was positioned as n upsell to cellular. So India was right to reject it.

OK, this is far too long …





On 8/10/2026, 1:22:53 PM, Thaths <[email protected]> wrote:

On Mon, Aug 10, 2026 at 9:51 AM Bob Frankston via Silklist <> wrote:The 
technologies may be fine and exciting but beware 5G/6G which are a desperate 
attempt by the 19th century telecom companies to try to fight against the 
existential threat of the Internet and empowered users as intelligence moves 
out of their network into our devices.Good reminder about not falling for 
marketing speak such as 6G (or Web 3.0, remember that?). Could you expand on 
this? Especially the intelligence moving into our (emphasis mine) devices? If 
anything the world seems to be moving toward walled gardens gatekept by the 
likes of Zuck and Dario and Pichai. Not much intelligence on-device (at least 
on-device under end-user control) these days. Thaths-- Homer: Hey, what does 
this job pay?Carl:  Nuthin'.Homer: D'oh!Carl:  Unless you're crooked.Homer: 
Woo-hoo!
-- 
Silklist mailing list
[email protected]
https://mailman.panix.com/listinfo.cgi/silklist

Reply via email to