On 8/11/26 6:56 AM, Suresh Ramasubramanian via Silklist wrote:
I don’t know, there are no countries where the government provides free
fiber to homes - even in the EU countries like Finland that treat
broadband as a fundamental right, you still pay a government or private
telco for the pipe.
If the government were to charge a tax the way the British were taxing
televisions (or are they still doing it) to provide BBC content .. and
then provide free fiber, that would be very ideal, if somewhat utopian.
"Free" isn't free, as you point out.
In many municipalities, the cost of providing the utility service is
higher than the usage. I certainly pay more for access to my town's
water system than I pay for the water I use. The cost of "free" roads
and "free" parking is all hidden away somewhere else - but it's never a
question of having paid to build it and then there's no cost associated
with upkeep and expansion.
Water and power and sewer are poor analogies, because there's really
only one entity being delivered. Roads might be better analogies to
network plumbing, because many kinds of goods can traverse the roads for
many reasons. The roads still need to be maintained (or not, which is a
whole different problem).
Telcos have struggled with finding reasons to charge for as long as
they've been deregulated. I think they missed the boat around the turn
of the last century, when they could have become ubiquitous payment
processors - they already had the billing relationships and everyone was
carrying the payment terminal in their pocket. But they were afraid of
taking on collection problems ... and that cost them a revolution.
Instead we have EMV and their member banks skimming every transaction,
and secondary offerings like Square and Venmo and Suica.
M-Pesa got it right. But no one in the western world wants to admit that
Africa did it better than they did.
--
Silklist mailing list
[email protected]
https://mailman.panix.com/listinfo.cgi/silklist