So many of the usual objection to https://rmf.vc/PPI. But this does help me practice explaining.
There is a world of difference between free and "paid for in a way to make it free-to-use". We pay for roads and sidewalks in a way to make it free-to-use. Transporting bit is say %1 the cost of roads so any community that can have roads can provide connectivity. I think the fundamental confusion is between the so-called pipe and what we do with it. In days of yore, you didn't own phone wire. While I can speak mainly for US history, it is the pattern for the world. You wanted to place a phone call so you had the phone company run a wire to your house. You aren't even allowed to own the phone - the phone calls were a service. This is just like with railroads - you bought a ride. Today roads are just a surface, and you make your own rides (sidewalks/strolls), So we pay for roads as public infrastructure. There are lots other factors such as going from rivalrous to non-rivalrous. Remember roads and sidewalks facilitate travel but we aren't confined to them. The same thing happened with the wire or fiber. It was owned by a provider to deliver their service (phone/cable TV). Today that services are 100% outside the fiber. (the fungible packets are not the service) And it isn't is even a dumb pipe because IP doesn't need to be confined to pipes since the packets each go their own path and only collect at the endpoints. The service does not exist in the pies. So you are right – there is no money in owning the pipe. But the legacy companies are charging you rent even when they are no longer providing the service. How is that fiber any different from the sidewalk? Even if it is just a dumb pipe dumb pipe and there is no revenue shouldn't you ask how they are making so much money? Perhaps having you pay for the same sidewalk again and again each month is very profitable? If you just implement a simple Wi-Fi mesh in a village how much effort should be put into preventing you from using it for no reason other than charging 10x the cost monthly forever and ever? Why doesn't the community pool its resources and pay as a whole for essentially no cost? I can respond to the usual objections if you want ... On 8/11/2026, 3:04:28 AM, Suresh Ramasubramanian <[email protected]> wrote: Um, if you live in a village with roads and electric utilities, the local authority will surely charge you rates and taxes to pay for all that you describe, unless you posit that the roads will maintain themselves and traffic will be controlled so that you aren’t run over by a car because there is no money for working street lights. Even by the standards of the usual utopian notions, this analogy of crossing the road to a clinic falls far short. Yes what you described is the classic pipe but in a different way - there is no profit these days in just selling the pipe, only in reselling “other” things to an effectively sort of captive audience .. or rather not so captive, because if you feel the selling is getting to be too much and the quality of service is low, all you do is take your number and port it to another provider. —srs From: Bob Frankston <[email protected]>Date: Tuesday, 11 August 2026 at 8:26 AMTo: Udhay Shankar N <[email protected]>; Intelligent conversation <[email protected]>Cc: Bob Frankston <[email protected]>; Suresh Ramasubramanian <[email protected]>Subject: Re: [Silk] silk -> 6GThe term ISP is a quaint leftover from days of yore when AOL (or the Indian version) was the gateway to the Internet.You're making my point. The profit comes from selling services that no longer have any relationship to the physical infrastructure. It's as if DHL owned the streets and can demand a fee from FedEx. The key is to recognize that the business of the facilities or pipes no longer has any relationship to what we do using them so each needs a native business model.It's like the movement for railroads owning the rails to roads that anyone can use to provide transport.Could you imagine a monthly fee for an IP light bulb? So how is that any different from a village with local facilities charging you a fee for a connection to the clinic across the street? On 8/10/2026, 10:36:09 PM, Udhay Shankar N <[email protected]> wrote:On Tue, Aug 11, 2026 at 7:56 AM Suresh Ramasubramanian via Silklist <[email protected]> wrote: That said, no telco I can think of is making much money on their own value added services - they get their money from bundling eg netflix and other third party products to their customers. This is not true in at least one case I am aware of. It is possibly the largest pureplay ISP in the country (i.e not a mobile service provider or landline provider) and is profitable not just being a 'dumb pipe' but also on the IPTV operations. Interestingly, one of their more profitable parts of the IPTV operations are the hyperlocal cable channels. It turns out that people want to watch their kids play cricket on the cable channel, and therefore advertisers love it. Udhay
-- Silklist mailing list [email protected] https://mailman.panix.com/listinfo.cgi/silklist
