Thanks.
“How about you become a DESTINATION instead of a fat pipe?” says it in a
nutshell. They could (ab)use their control of the path to steal business from
AWS, Azure et al.
It is telling that these stories seem to fade away but persist in the
imagination of the marketers. It's those engineers that spoil the party by
looking behind the curtain. [is that term "looking behind the curtain a US only
metaphor from the Wizard of Oz]?
The frustrating aspect is that Amazon came so close to infrastructure with
Whispernet and later their Sidewalk effort (access via Alexa and other devices)
to provide connectivity among their devices but didn't recognize they were
building an infrastructure that could that created an opportunity to drive the
sales of devices along with increased use of services by simply being able to
assume connectivity.
BTW. I presume you are referring to David Isenberg who wrote about stupid
networks while at ATT.
On 8/11/2026, 12:33:57 PM, Tim Bray <[email protected]> wrote:
Haha, I have not one, not two, but three sad/funny stories about telcos and the
Internet. Moving backwards through time…
2015 or so: 5G
When 5G was first being set up I was working at AWS and we were besieged by
overexcited entrepreneurs with dollar signs in their eyes telling us how we had
to do a massive buildout for all the business 5G was going to bring in. The
senior engineering staff was puzzled - “so, we get faster pipes and in some
situations lower latency, what’s changed qualitatively?” Crickets. AWS
eventually did roll out a project where you could deploy cloud infrastructure
in 5G base stations, apparently was going to be useful for self-driving cars
and a few other things I forget. No idea how successful that was but I don’t
hear much about it…
Mid-200s: Destination
Early 200s: I was working at Sun and we sold boatloads of servers to telcos and
the telcos were pissed because the hotshots at the portals (AOL & so on) and
search engines were making all the money. So CEO Scott McNealy went around and
visited all the telco CEOs and said “How about you become a DESTINATION instead
of a fat pipe?” CEOs: “Please take our money, can we install next month?”
Scott came back and asked the engineers “Um, let’s build something that’ll make
telcos into destinations, could we have it next quarter?” I seem to recall it
was called “Project Destination”. Don’t know if it ever shipped.
Early-200s: Fat pipe
Back in 2003 I wrote a blog piece called Fast and Always On sneering at cable
companies and telcos who thought they could enrich the Internet - some here
might find it entertaining, 23 years later. David Isen, a popular Internet
prognosticator back in the day, gave a pretty funny Dr-Seuss-flavored talk at a
big O’Reilly conference in 2006, a few dozen lines of rhyming rhetoric, ending
by getting the audience to chant along: "Fat Pipe, Always On, Get Out of the
Way!”
Still sounds good. -Tim
--
Silklist mailing list
[email protected]
https://mailman.panix.com/listinfo.cgi/silklist