Corvus, you raise innumberable good points. I'll try to cover the 
ones about which I have something pithy to say.

> First, is there an archive site where I can find the answers to all
> the questions I am about to ask, which undoubtably you have seen
> several times before?

Look in the footer. Look *deeep* in the footer. <grin>

> I intend to drop the voltage a bit, and add some sort of currant
> regulation, and distill some water. 

All reasonable things to try.

> But I have now about a pint of transparent liquid that looks alot
> like urine.  

I prefer to think of it as the color of beer! <grin>

> So, I think I can make the stuff.  But now I need to know if I
> should.  I have read lots of web pages about this.  I'm not
> impressed.

Good for you! There is *not* a lot to be impressed about when it 
comes to objective support for CS on the web or in the mainstream 
literature. The stuff is *not* mainstream approved. There is *not* a 
ton of well funded research and testing to back it up.

Understanding *why* that's the case will lead you to a *much* better 
understanding of where we're at here.

> Most of the pages almost say I can live forever if I drink this
> stuff, specificly THEIR stuff which is somehow better than the
> stuff sold at the last web page I looked at.

Yup. No matter where you go, there's marketing hype. Most folks just
regurgitate the same baloney they picked up from other web sites and
a handful of published articles in the popular press.

> Other web pages seem sincere, and are non-comercial.  They seem to
> want to share information about something they believe is very
> helpful.

I hope that is the core motivation of this list. It's why I 
discourage openly commercial activity and ask folks to share what 
they know from their own experience and study where possible.

> Unfortuantly they usually appear to be kooks to me. 

I resemble that remark! <grin>

> I'm sorry, I don't want to be judgemental, but this is something I
> am contemplating takeing internally and in some quantity larger
> than a taste.  And I don't believe in most of what the authors of
> some of these websites seem to believe in.

Actually, Corvus, my own background is in science and technology, so 
I am just as sensitive and skeptical toward nonsense technobabble 
and esoteric mysticism as you are. 

However, it so happens that many of the people most interested in CS
are also interested in broader aspects of alternative health. And
*that* topic guarantees you'll run across everything from the time
tested to the utterly wild.

As in all things, *USE YOUR JUDGEMENT*. If it's crap, it'll show. But 
I would advise you to keep one small corner of your mind open and 
reserved for the more wildly speculative. Little bits of that stuff 
have turned out to be real sometimes, no matter how fanciful or 
foolish the proponants' explainations have been.

Most of the serious experimentors on this list came here to get away 
from the marketing hype. We've made it our goal to try to sort what 
we know from what we suspect from the lies, myths, and hoopla of the 
hucksters and "debunkers." Give'em a chance.

> So, it looks to me like the FDA lied.

Though, what happened first was -- the marketers of CS lied, or at 
least overstated their case. I personally don't agree that we need an 
FDA at all, but given their existance and the regulatory framework 
they have erected, it's not even a small surprise that the CS 
hucksters got stomped. It's now an issue of trying to survive the 
collateral damage to all of us bystanders.

See some of the stuff at Bruce Marx's site at csprosystems.com for a 
good explanation of what's been going on with the FDA.

> At Rebecca Jones's site, she says that her complexion can't be
> covered over with makeup.  Her coloring is really unfortunate, but I
> suspect makeup can cover over just about anything.  Also, the silver
> that caused her argyria was from nose drops, and I think that was
> some sort of compound of silver. I am uncomfortable with saying that
> she is misleading because her case is very unfortunate, but in my
> mind she has about as much credibility as the kooky websites that
> promote CS even though they don't sell it.

You've read it very well. She (Rosemary Jacobs) says she does not 
even know what exactly was in the nose drops that turned her blue nor 
does she report how much she used. But, compared to what we know 
about quantities and forms of silver that are necessary to cause 
argyria, we're not even close with a properly made home brew product.

> the FDA or Rebecca or someone claims that silver once in the body is
> permanent and is never excreted.  

*IF* you take high doses of soluble silver salts and they precipitate 
large particles just below the skin, you bet. The body's lymph system 
can't transport silver in that form.

However, elevated levels of silver metal have been observed in the 
feces of animals and people taking modern, small particle CS, just as 
you'd expect given that it's the liver's job to filter them out and 
dump them in the gut for elimination.

> I don't remember the term, but what is the margin between what is
> considered a theraputic dose of CS and a harmful dose.  Both in
> official medical community and in the opinion of this list?

The official medical community doesn't have an opinion, other than,
don't do it. It's unproven. We don't *know* how much you'd have to
take for it to harm you, since we don't know of anybody turning blue
yet. 

However, there *can* be other issues to beware, among them:
disruption of friendly gut flora and all its consequences; the 
possibility of a "healing crisis" or Herxheimer reaction where the 
rapid die-off of germs in the body causes temporary and potentially 
serious increase in symptoms; and the rarer possibility of a direct 
intolerance or allergy to silver.

> Look, I want to believe, but I must have more inforation.  I am
> dismissing anecdotal evidence because I am already biased.

Be careful here, because the very best indications we have that CS is 
useful *is* the anecdotal testimony of folks that have used the stuff 
to improve their situation. Enough of these folks are not trying to 
sell you anything, and their stories are just not going to go away no 
matter *who* says they're bunk.

> I want to know if colloidal silver is safe.  We can talk about
> effectiveness later.  I am profoundly skeptical, yet I have a pint
> of the stuff and some of it has already passed my lips.

You must determine that for yourself. Read everything you can, listen 
and keep asking questions, paw through the archives. When you're 
done, you'll have a pretty good idea of whether you can trust this 
stuff or not.

First, find out the quantities of silver involved in the reported 
cases of argyria and compare that to the dose rates typical for the 
CS preparations you've encountered so far. Then, ask whether the 
silver we're taking is being excreted or not?

Answer those questions and you'll be much better prepared to make an 
informed decision.

> Is there a devils advocate on the list?  Speak up, convince me this
> stuff is poison.  But make it a good case, I will unfortuantly and
> unfairly hold you to a higher standard of evidence than your peers
> on the list.

Actually, no, not really. We have plenty of conflicting opinions on a 
lot of things, but the underlying assumption here is that CS *seems* 
to work and has enough anecdotal evidence in its favor to make it 
worth studying.

If you want to see the arguments of the debunkers, just visit any of 
the alternative health related usenet newsgroups, like 
alt.health, sci.life-extension, or misc.health.alternative, and 
you'll see all the devil's advocacy you can stomach.

Go to dejanews and search their usenet archives for colloidal silver.

> I believe that within my lifetime effective conventional
> antibiotics will be unavailable, for one or more of several reasons
> that are almost certainly off topic for the list.

Well, I imagine we've talked about most of them too. There are quite 
a few anti-mainstream skeptics here and no small preparedness 
oriented contingent looking for survivable technologies.

> I hope you will all be patient with me, I'm learning and that
> sometimes gets messy.

You've been watching us for *how long* you say? <grin>

Welcome aboard. Don't give up before you get enough information to 
base a good decision on. We'll be here to help.

Be well,

Mike D.

[Mike Devour, Citizen, Patriot, Libertarian]
[[email protected]                       ]
[Speaking only for myself...              ]


--
The silver-list is a moderated forum for discussion of colloidal silver.

To join or quit silver-list or silver-digest send an e-mail message to: 
[email protected]  -or-  [email protected]
with the word subscribe or unsubscribe in the SUBJECT line.

To post, address your message to: [email protected]
Silver-list archive: http://escribe.com/health/thesilverlist/index.html
List maintainer: Mike Devour <[email protected]>