Hi Malcom, "What is your take on the desirability of ionic silver on infected mucosae? "
>From what I have seen here, both will work; some will make a case that the particles are less likely to react with other substances and get lodged in the skin. Some will make a case that the ions work better. Sticking the silver in salt is, I think, a bit different that having silver particles in a relatively low concentration solution of salt. I betcha Ivan can say something about that, if he has the time and interest. My definition of "ion", taken from general dictionaries is "any charged particle". So either a small clump of silver or single atom of silver is called by many authorities, an "ion". I distinguish between particulate silver and ionic monatomic silver by calling one "dissolved silver ion" and the other a "sol". There is a lot more speculation here than really hard data. Generally, most long time observers think that the hazards of silver are associated with: 1. Silver compounds; particularly Silver Nitrate. 2. By-products of the method by which the sol (or solution) is created; e.g. some arc methods introduce nitrates into the water. 3. Protein additives used to hold large particles in suspension. 4. The use of alloys less fine than 0.999 containing substantial amounts of toxic metals such as nickel, iron, and even lead. 5. Massive doses of metallic silver; in excess of about 3.8 Grams/day for a standard adult human unit. 6. There have been undocumented reports of allergy to silver, particularly jewelry grade, causing cracking and bleeding of the skin, but nothing specifically about relatively high purity silver. 7. I prefer Ag sol to Ag solution. 8. The people who seem to have the credentials and or knowledge and the dedication to "truth before profit" to answer these questions that I personally trust are Ivan, Marshall, Brooks, Frank Key, and others not belittled by not being remembered at this moment. You will may get more useful info from them or others on the list who have made a study of your particular issues. James-Osbourne: Holmes Here's one for you Chuck, "Reality never was what it used to be" -----Original Message----- From: Malcolm Stebbins [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Tuesday, April 16, 2002 1:33 PM To: [email protected] Subject: Re: CS>CS>Nebulizing CS Interesting! But; " ...once the impossible has been eliminated, whatever remains, however improbable, ..." or words to that effect <g> Darn! Sir Arthur has escaped the bookshelf again. It seems clear (?) that ionic reactions are indeed dependent on ions, however the solubility of small charged silver particles under the constant 'picking' of Chloride ions may be another story, and I can only offer the crude experiment of putting a piece of silver wire into damp salt and observing whatever crud forms on its surface. . . What is your take on the desireability of ionic silver on infected mucosae? I have had good luck with straight LVDC CS from my first simple device to present current limited stirred polarity switched Rube Goldberg variation (sorry, almost) in stopping colds and/or respiratory flu via inhaled spritzer application. This for myself and several parents of snot nosed children as well as the kids themselves when they could be held down long enough and coerced to breath again. "James Osbourne, Holmes" wrote: > Current belief for many here is that the NaCl will react only with monatomic > Ag ions; the true sol should remain as silver particles. > > James-Osbourne: Holmes > > -- The silver-list is a moderated forum for discussion of colloidal silver. To join or quit silver-list or silver-digest send an e-mail message to: [email protected] -or- [email protected] with the word subscribe or unsubscribe in the SUBJECT line. To post, address your message to: [email protected] Silver-list archive: http://escribe.com/health/thesilverlist/index.html List maintainer: Mike Devour <[email protected]>

