Hello Solar, Brooks, and Malcolm.

Solar wrote:

"The activities enganged in by the GMO companies should arouse suspicion in 
anyone. Reckless action by the USDA, in letting GMO crops be freely planted, 
without any research whatsoever, should also be looked at with a jaundiced eye.

Ask yourself if you feel comfortable with these facts. Monsanto's "roundup 
ready" variety of crops are not what they seem. If, for some reason, the farmer 
decides there is no need to spray Roundup (say there aren't any weeds in the 
fields), the "roundup ready" crops will die. They have been so altered as to 
REQUIRE the use of an herbicide, specifically Roundup.

How about this one. Just a handful of companies can control the food supply of 
the world, and the ultimate pricing of such. Using "terminator technology", all 
seeds produced by the plants are sterile. Therefore, the farmer MUST buy new 
seeds every year, at the going price, which is decided by a small handful of 
companies. Want to see the ultimate in greed and power? There it is. No one 
eats unless they can pay your price.

Because there is no feasible way to contain pollen from these plants, some of 
these characteristics WILL find their way into surrounding, non-GMO plants as 
well. It is already happening. This doesn't even begin to address the issue of 
bT corn pollen, and how it is nearly wiping out the entire population of 
Monarch butterflies.

While the GMO companies try and claim they are doing this for the betterment of 
mankind, I personally feel it is nothing more than another diabolical attempt 
to gain total power, as witnessed time and again throughout history.

Personally, I support biodiversity. It is the way the world has always been. To 
allow companies, especially ones with a checkered past in the areas of human 
safety, to brew up the world's food supply in some lab, without ANYONE even 
keeping an eye on them, could be a bigger episode in human history than the 
early use of lead pipes to supply drinking
water.    -- Best regards, Solar"

Brooks Bradley and Malcolm Stebbins wrote:

"Hello Brooks, were you aware of the effect GMO corn or its pollen is having on 
Mexican corn varieties?  I'll try to scratch up a reference before I leave 
(vacation) but as I remember the news report, most everyone grows corn, even if 
only a few plants.  Many, peasant, middle class or ??? have their own 'pet' 
varieties, passed down through the family.  Apparently despite the Mexican 
government's refusal to allow imports for any reason (at least pre- Vicente 
Fox) it is showing up in the feed stocks, and food shelves, and streets and 
sidewalks where locals pointed it out to the reporter covering the story, and 
contaminating the local adapted heirloom forms. One problem I see with the 
GMO's is their crossing genes from animal to vegetable kingdoms, or vice versa, 
with all the perversions in between.  The stability of the species within the 
kingdoms, despite the evidence of chance and deliberate crossing throughout the 
millenia - not to mention the rise of new species - is
evidence that within each kingdom such crossings will probably be self limiting 
or beneficial, though the Mexican corn story  might give some pause.  However 
when it comes to crossing genetic material from animal to vegetable, for 
instance,  or more - well, pandemically - bacterium to either, we run the risk 
of discovering things we would rather not. Chiefly I detest having such 
recklessness of others foisted upon me so they can make more money - as if they 
didn't have enough!
Grumble, mumble, mutter!


Brooks Bradley wrote:

>                                         Dear Kevin,
>                                 While not pundits, we have, for a number of
> years, researched and followed this issue with much interest.  There is
> neither time...nor bandwidth....on this forum , to pursue a reliable and
> rational explanation-in-depth to your observation.
>                             However, if one is, truly, interested in
> determining whether or not a genuine "threat" exists, I suggest they do some
> direct investigation of the entire secenario surrounding the issue.  The most
> powerful challenge seems to  revolve around the question of whether the
> production of GMO organisms---under the present development
> methodologies....is or is not a COLLATERAL threat to other biological
> systems----and if so, how pronounced is such a threat?  We would caution that
> in cases threatening rapid and wide-spread dissemination of  MODIFIED GENES,
> especially ones capable of inflicting irreversible changes.....many, presently
> unforseen consequences are likely to follow----some, possibly, of catastrophic
> impact.  The greatest threat to the world's biological systems.....stemming
> from any "headlong" rush into precipitating a distribution of
> "super-competing" species, may be the simple fact that humankind may be
> incapable of putting Pandora back-into-the-box.
>                     It is troubling to see the majority of public address
> concentrating upon the immediate concerns for , primarily, the human food
> supply.  Our research indicates the possiblity of a much greater threat to
> ancillary species and even entire eco-systems.....in cases of untoward
> escapes......than presently admitted by the leading-edge advocates of this
> technology.
>                     I do not wish to instigate an adversarial
> posture....toward anyone----but rather to encourage reasonable reflection on
> an issue ( which  I believe) is FAR greater in potential consequence than the
> elements of present contention.
>                         The great tragedy seems to be that events are being
> accelerated, primarily, based upon immediate access to economic gains of the
> highest order........regrettably with few safeguards for protecting the
> Biosphere.
>                                                         Sincerely,  Brooks 
> Bradley."


I fully agree with virtually all of the above points raised about specific and 
general threats from both the inadvertant consequences of GM technology itself, 
and the greedy conglomerates abusing that technology as a tool of exploitation, 
with the apparent blessing of criminally negligent government departments. 
Strong and urgent action is needed - but it needs to be appropriate, not a 
kneejerk thing.

As Brooks states: "humankind may be incapable of putting Pandora 
back-into-the-box.". Fact is, there is absolutely no reasonable prospect of 
uninventing GM technology. Fact is, even if all the big GM corporations like 
Monsanto were stopped tomorrow, economic, political and military rivalry 
between nations will gaurantee it's continued development by government, 
tertiary and military institutions, as surely as it does in other fields like 
cloning, IT, nuclear technlogy etc. Consequently, the best that can be hoped 
for is to strive to ensure responsibility, caution, and above all 
accountability in the future direction and application of GMO technology. 
Unreasonable demands for the complete ban of all GM products may work as a 
strategy in the short term, but such an overly hasty approach will surely be 
made to rebound against the proponents in the longer run. We need to 
distinguish between outright evil practices as exemplified by the terminator 
seed 'initiatives', high danger situations such as the cross 
polination/infection instances already reported, and the prospect of 
significant benefits from enhanced food varieties having greater pest and 
drought resistance, higher nutrient yields etc. As I have stated elsewhere - 
don't be too hasty to throw out the baby with the bathwater. 

regards, Kevin Nolan