Mike Monett wrote:

> Re: CS>Ionic versus Colloidal,
> From: M. G. Devour
> Date: Sat, 26 Mar 2005 16:51:23
> http://escribe.com/health/thesilverlist/m78945.html
>
>   > Greetings Frank,
>
>   > You write:
>
>   >> What Quinto and Trem fail to address is the fact that  no medical
>   >> researcher anywhere  has ever been able to  find  any significant
>   >> amount of  ionic  silver   in   human  blood  serum.  Sometimes a
>   >> beautiful theory can be destroyed by a single ugly fact. It seems
>   >> that this ugly fact is most conveniently ignored.
>
>   > Which *BEGS* that we ask the *rest* of the question:
>
>   > Does ingesting  an  ionic silver preparation  produce  any *OTHER*
>   > form of   silver   compound,   complex,   or   particulate  in the
>   > bloodstream? Any form at all?
>
>   > We don't really care if there is "any significant amount  of ionic
>   > silver in  human blood serum..." We all know that  silver  ions do
>   > not last long in the bloodstream.
>
>   This is not necessarily true, Mike. Silver chloride has a solubility
>   of 0.89 ppm in distilled water. This means a concentration less than
>   this results  in the silver and chlorine ions  going  their separate
>   ways.

Silver chloride does indeed have a solubility of .89 ppm at 20 C, slightly
higher at body temperature.

>
>
>   Increasing the  concentration produces a white dispersion  of silver
>   chloride as  the  compound  comes  out  of  solution.

I am not sure what you mean by increasingly, if you exceed the solubility
limit then yeh, the excess will precipitate out.

> The resulting
>   compound is inert and cannot engage in biological activity,

True, but how is this relevent. You were talking about silver chloride
which is in solution below the solubility limit. It cannot exceed the
solubility limit in the blood stream since there is no chemical way it
would be formed in the blood stream unless ionic silver were given
interveniously.

> which is
>   similar to silver hydroxide which I have recently shown is insoluble
>   in dw:
>
>   http://escribe.com/health/thesilverlist/m78851.html

You have shown no such thing, all you have shown is that you do not know
the difference between soluble silver hydroxide and finely divided silver
metal.  If silver hydroxide were insoluble, then there would be no such
thing as an ionic portion of EIS, which of course there is.

>
>
>   Normally the  solubility of a compound decreases  as  competing ions
>   are introduced in the solution. For example, adding salt (NaCl) to a
>   solution of  silver  chloride (AgCl)  reduces  the  solubility since
>   sodium competes  with  silver for the chlorine  ion.  I  believe the
>   solubility may  fall to about 0.4ppm, but I do not have  the links
>   handy.

That issue has already been resolved by postings of peer reviewed journal
articles that give this information.  The common ion factor is only
effective to about .1% chloride ion content, the solubility goes back up
due to the silver forming silver chloride complexes above that point.  In
fact at the chloride content of the blood, it is right back to around .9
ppm and increasing rapidly with increasing chloride content.

>
>
>   However, Marshall's calculations seem to indicate the  solubility of
>   silver chloride  is still very close to 0.89ppm in human  blood, due
>   to other factors.
>

No, not my calculations, look at the curves I posted, they show it quite
clearly and are from journal articles..

>
>   This means  the  silver  ion   remains  free  to  engage  in killing
>   bacteria, viruses,  and fungus when below  this  concentration. Ivan
>   mentioned this  point  several times in the archives, but  I  do not
>   have the links available at the moment.

Silver ions appear to remain ions for less than a minute once they reach
the blood. The big question is where do they go, do they become particles,
plate out on the particles already there, get chelated, or bind with
proteins.  We know that at least some become particles and plate out on
particles already there because that is what causes argyria when silver
compounds are taken internally.

>
>
>   The crux  of  the argument is it is extremely  difficult  to produce
>   such a high concentration of silver ions in the bloodstream.

I think it is impossible to produce any level of ions in the blood stream
for more than a very brief time.  They quickly take a non-ionic form,
whatever that may be, which of course is why one can take EIS, and the
silver chloride eventually makes it into the blood stream despite it's low
solubility.

>
>
>   If you use sublingual absorption, and assume 100% efficiency, then 1
>   oz of  20uS cs will dilute to 110 parts per billion in  5  litres of
>   blood. (The  calculations  are in an earlier report.)  This  is well
>   below the level needed to precipitate out as silver chloride.

Correct.

>
>
>   It would  be  extremely   difficult   to   measure  this  level with
>   conventional lab equipment. You need to know what to look for and be
>   prepared for the interference effects of other ions and  proteins in
>   blood, which  could overwhelm the instrument. It's  like  pointing a
>   camera at the sun and trying to take a photo of a tree branch.

Actually 110 parts per billion is very easy to measure.  When I use my
instrument to measure 20 ppm EIS, I have to dilute it by about a factor of
20 to 100 to keep from saturating the instrument which has a full scale of
1 ppm. 110 ppb is 11% of full scale on that instrument.

>
>
>   This concentration  level also assumes 100%  absorption,  which will
>   never happen.

Not 100%, but most like over 90%.

> But the resulting ion concentration in  the  blood is
>   sufficient to kill the Shingles virus, cold sores, and any  cough or
>   flu that I have experienced. So it doesn't take much silver  ions to
>   be effective.
>

The resulting silver content is sufficient to kill these.  But what for it
is in is still open to question.  The only thing it appears it cannot be is
ionic, since various tests have determined that the ionic silver only
remains for a very short time in blood before becoming something else which
is not ionic.

>
>   > What we  care  about is if there is *ANY* form of  silver  that is
>   > formed in  the bloodstream after ingesting  a  predominantly ionic
>   > preparation?
>
>   There could be other interactions with the silver ion, such  as with
>   metalloproteins. I'm  sure   you   have   seen  Fred  Peschel's very
>   interesting report at
>
>   http://colloidalsilverresearch.com/colloidal_silver_transport.htm
>
>   These take the biological effects to a much higher level,  and point
>   to a  potential  immune system dependance  on  silver,  which modern
>   medicine has not recognized yet. But I believe this may turn  out to
>   be a  very  important  factor in our diet which  we  have  lost. For
>   example, think  how  much  better you  feel  after  eating  a dinner
>   including mushrooms in the salad. Mushrooms concentrate silver.

This is indeed an interesting avenue to pursue.

Marshall