In a message dated 5/11/2005 2:46:28 AM Central Standard Time, beyondvaccinat...@yahoogroups.com writes:
My objections to CS are related to its mechanism of action - I don't see it as being unique in its action, nor all that "holistic," even if it works as it's said to. It's an anti-microbial, and while I certainly believe in using anti-microbials, I don't see any particular advantage to CS over a thousand others, including many herbal formulas I've had good results with over the years, such as echinacea mixtures. Christie, one of the things I love about you is that you take the time to do the research, get the facts, and give the pros and cons when sharing your knowledge. Along with the many others who've benefitted from your knowledge, I think you're 'brilliant' and you have no agenda other than the health and wellbeing of our animals. However, I've also been a member of silver-list@eskimo.com for years, and have found it to also be populated with brilliant minds who willingly share their knowledge of cs and its applications. Some are micro-biologists, engineers, chemists, even retired pharmacists, as well as many alternative health practictioners. The list has well over 1,000 members, and some of its contributors are what others (myself included) consider to be 'out there' in their philosophies and ideologies. Thankfully the moderator there is also well-skilled in diplomacy, and maintains an off-topic list where non cs discussions migrate to. I too have my own generator and have found so many benefits from cs that I would never be without it. And like you, I don't wish to debate the subject. Anyone who's interested can go to the cs list and dive in. BUT! I've had occasion to treat parvo (as part of an animal outreach group) with cs and Parvaid. Truthfully, it's worked for 2 out of 3 if caught early. Here's the clincher, tho. the cs needs to be given alternately orally and rectally every 60 to 90 minutes for approx. 24 hrs. That's practically impossible for 'regular' people to do at home and out of the question at the vets' office. In our experience, we've found that when the exhausting 60 to 90 min. protocol isn't followed, the pups won't make it. And they have suffered, as you say. This is simply not true. I've worked 24/7 on entire litters of puppies with Parvo. The survival rate is nearly 100% if fluid therapy is the primary modality of treatment. It is a lot of work but very rewarding when you see these babies turn around and begin to live.. CS would be a nice adjunct..and may speed up recovery but is not a necessary part of the treatment. Dehydration and electrolyte imbalance is the primary cause of death in these puppies. I am thrilled beyond belief to know about Tamiflu! I took the information to our vet, but didn't get much response. I'll keep trying. Thank you for bringing the info on Tamiflu to the list, and please keep us posted with it. I'm a few hours from the Mexican border, probably could get it there but don't know protocol/dosage for parvo. Laura H., TX
