I am not versed on TD planes, but it has always been my understanding that any plane with a given airfoil has an optimum wing loading at which it will fly best based in large part to the airfoil used. Now granted "best" is a poor choice of words, perhaps efficiently is more accurate?
In any regards, I would think lightness for lightness sake is a fools mission, and in TD events it would seem to me your sailplanes weight (mass) has it's largest influence with dork or spot landings whereas low mass carbon reinforced light planes have the potential to sustain less damage than heavy ships with greater inertia. I know in large scale soaring weight usually translates into energy, and flying performance, up to a point, will increase up to the magic wing loading number. With a 33% scale ship that could easily be up to 37 pounds! TD guys are always amazed when they fly their first 5-6 meter ship and the light bulb goes off. Maybe or maybe not germane to your question... JD Endless Mountain Models http://www.scalesoaring.com email: [EMAIL PROTECTED] -----Original Message----- From: George Voss [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Sunday, July 11, 2004 5:26 PM To: RCSE E-mail Subject: [RCSE] Is it worth it? Put on your thinking caps and let me know what you think. The question is: How much weight loss is necessary to notice a difference in flying/landing capability? The plane is question is an unlimited size plane with about 8 sq.ft. of wing (1151 sq.in.), weighs in at about 78 ounces and has a long tail moment. The plane is flown in normally mild wind conditions, but rarely in calm conditions. It's flown in AMA style contests only, no F3X anything. Average winds are typically 5-12mph. The plane has ballast capabilities. I weighed the molded stabs against a custom made "light" set of stabs and I can lose 4g if I change out the stabs. Total weight savings at a 4:1 tail moment ratio would be 16g or slightly over 1/2 an ounce. The rudder is also molded but I'm not going to pull it off to weigh it. I'll guess I can save 3g with a new light one so now we have a 7g savings in the tail and a 1-ounce loss in overall weight. The only other thing I could change is the pushrod system, which weighs a little over an ounce according to the CST web site. Since 90% is behind the CG, we'll call it one ounce. If I leave the stab and rudder alone, I'll lose roughly 4 ounces total weight. If I include the stab and rudder I'll lose roughly 5 ounces total. My guess is keeping the molded stab is a good idea strength wise. The question then is: Is a 4-ounce weight loss, which equal 1/2 ounce per square foot, worth the trouble? Making the rudder pull-pull will be an evenings worth of work. If we use the correct materials, the actuation system is proven safe and weighs virtually nothing. Is 1/2 an ounce of wing loading worth the trouble? For the engineers, how do you calculate the weight of a pushrod in inch/ounces over its total length? Or asked another way, since the pushrod weighs in at slightly over an ounce and 90% of it is behind the CG, is 1 ounce times 0.9 going to give me the correct answer? If I put the pushrod on 2 scales, one at each end of the rod, each would show 1/2 of the total weight. So how much of this total 1 ounce weight can I calculate at the rudder hookup? gv RCSE-List facilities provided by Model Airplane News. Send "subscribe" and "unsubscribe" requests to [EMAIL PROTECTED] Please note that subscribe and unsubscribe messages must be sent in text only format with MIME turned off. RCSE-List facilities provided by Model Airplane News. Send "subscribe" and "unsubscribe" requests to [EMAIL PROTECTED] Please note that subscribe and unsubscribe messages must be sent in text only format with MIME turned off.

